Abstract
Right ventricular (RV) failure determines outcome in patients with pulmonary hypertension, congenital heart diseases and in left ventricular failure. In 2006, the Working Group on Cellular and Molecular Mechanisms of Right Heart Failure of the NIH advocated the development of preclinical models to study the pathophysiology and pathobiology of RV failure. In this review, we summarize the progress of research into the pathobiology of RV failure and potential therapeutic interventions. The picture emerging from this research is that RV adaptation to increased afterload is characterized by increased contractility, dilatation and hypertrophy. Clinical RV failure is associated with progressive diastolic deterioration and disturbed ventricular–arterial coupling in the presence of increased contractility. The pathobiology of the failing RV shows similarities with that of the LV and is marked by lack of adequate increase in capillary density leading to a hypoxic environment and oxidative stress and a metabolic switch from fatty acids to glucose utilization. However, RV failure also has characteristic features. So far, therapies aiming to specifically improve RV function have had limited success. The use of beta blockers and sildenafil may hold promise, but new therapies have to be developed. The use of recently developed animal models will aid in further understanding of the pathobiology of RV failure and development of new therapeutic strategies.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Introduction
Right ventricular (RV) failure is a major determinant of outcome in patients with pulmonary hypertension (PH), corrected congenital heart diseases (CHD) and in left ventricular failure due to ischemic heart disease [1–3]. Improved therapies for these diseases have led to a quickly expanding population of children and young adults at risk of mortality due to RV failure. For example, currently over four million adults in Europe and the USA suffer from late effects after treatment for CHD. Despite the pivotal involvement of the RV in both common and rare cardiovascular diseases, the mechanisms of RV failure have historically gotten little attention. Already in 1988, Reeves pleaded that “One must inquire how increasing pulmonary vascular resistance results in impaired RV function” (Reeves, cited in [4]). However, almost 20 years later in 2006, a Working Group on Cellular and Molecular Mechanisms of Right Heart Failure of the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute concluded that there was “a paucity of basic knowledge at all levels about the RV’s normal and pathological function” [5]. This observation led to a call to the research community to develop accurate preclinical models, to study the pathophysiology and pathobiology of RV failure and to develop new therapeutic strategies [5]. In this review, we summarize the research in animal models since then into the pathophysiology and pathobiology of RV failure and possible therapeutic interventions.
Modeling and evaluating a unique ventricle
The right ventricle is not a mirror image left ventricle
The RV has specific characteristics that affect the response to abnormal loading conditions, as extensively reviewed previously [6]. In short, firstly, the RV is derived from a distinct set of precursor cells (as compared to the LV), the so-called secondary heart field [7]. It is yet unknown whether this different embryological origin affects the response to abnormal loading conditions [8]. Secondly, the RV is a crescent-shaped structure wrapped around the LV that has a unique contraction pattern, which complicates functional and volumetric analysis. Thirdly, the normal RV is unloaded after birth. During fetal life, the RV and LV work in parallel to support the systemic and pulmonary circulation, but after birth, these circulations are serially connected and the pulmonary vascular resistance, which determines the afterload of the RV, progressively decreases. In patients with CHD, this unloading is often absent [9]. Fourthly, the dominant movement of the RV is longitudinal shortening, pressing the RV-free wall against the septum to create a bellows effect to empty into the low-resistance pulmonary circulation [6]. Finally, in normal adult conditions, the RV has a lower oxygen requirement as compared with the LV and lower coronary flow that mostly occurs during systole [10]. A comprehensive overview of differences between the RV and LV from a clinical and preclinical perspective was published recently [11]. In the current paper, we present a detailed analysis of the experimental literature describing the adaptation of the right ventricle in response to increased afterload.
Evaluation of RV function and failure
To interpret the findings in preclinical models and to translate these to clinical practice, a definition of RV failure is necessary. Right heart failure is not an entity as such but a continuum of disease severities and clinical symptoms and can be defined in congruence with previous definitions of heart failure by Sugawa and Sunagawa [12]. Heart failure is defined as the inability to meet the requirements of the metabolizing tissues of the body. RV failure is defined accordingly, but the clinical signs and symptoms may differ from those in LV failure [13]. The cardinal clinical characteristics of RV failure are low (effective) cardiac output (evident in exercise intolerance, fatigue, dyspnea and poor peripheral circulation) and fluid retention (evident in peripheral edema, effusion and ascites) [6, 13] (Table 1). It is therefore important, in clinical practice but also in preclinical animal experiments, to include these clinical signs in the assessment of RV function or failure, in addition to functional RV parameters.
In clinical practice, exercise capacity is used as an important guide to grade the severity of heart failure and as a prognostic indicator. Exercise capacity in patients can be determined by maximal cardiopulmonary exercise testing or by voluntary exercise performance, evaluated with a 6-min walk distance. Similarly, in animal models of RV disease, forced exercise capacity can be evaluated by a treadmill test [14, 15] and voluntary exercise capacity by spontaneous activity in a running wheel [8, 16, 17].
Mortality is the ultimate clinical sign of RV failure, and survival analysis may be included in studies. However, in animal models, other factors rather than RV failure that might impede survival (such as pulmonary disease and/or LV dysfunction in the monocrotaline model) should be excluded or accounted for [18]. Once RV disease has been characterized using clinical symptoms, exercise and/or mortality (Table 1), the disease state can be coupled to hemodynamic and cellular adaptation (Table 2).
Modeling RV abnormal loading conditions
To study the mechanisms of RV failure, animal models that mimic specific diseases have been developed. The diseases contributing to the spectrum of patients with RV failure can be divided into three main groups: (1) patients with PH, (2) (corrected) CHD and (3) RV failure secondary to left ventricular failure. Although distinct in etiology, these diseases share in common the abnormal loading conditions imposed on the RV, i.e., increased afterload, increased preload or a combination of both [19]. Increased afterload can be peripherally located, as in PH or fixed proximally as in pulmonary stenosis. Either way, the coupling between the RV and the pulmonary arteries is disturbed (Table 2). To represent these chronic abnormal loading conditions models of PH, pulmonary artery banding and/or pre-tricuspid systemic-to-pulmonary shunts have been developed. Knowledge on the RV response to an increase in preload is scarce [16, 20, 21] and will be discussed in a separate paper. In this review, we will focus on the response to increased afterload.
Models of increased afterload
Historically, researchers used the monocrotaline model (MCT) to induce PH (Table 2a). The MCT model has been invaluable for PH research, but it may be questioned whether rats with MCT-induced PH die from progressive PH, from RV failure or from other organ dysfunction [18]. Besides MCT, other models mimicking PH have been developed, e.g., hypoxia (with or without VEGF inhibitor SUGEN) or the induction of increased pulmonary blood flow [22–25]. Although all these models may represent pulmonary vascular disease adequately, the potential direct effects of the triggers used to induce PH on the RV limit their use to study the pathobiology of RVF.
The pulmonary artery banding model (PAB) avoids these limitations of the PH models (Table 2). The banding of the pulmonary artery induces no systemic or toxic effects, and the fixed constriction of the banding ensures a constant afterload, also when pulmonary vasodilators are administered. The time course of the phenotype in this model has shown considerable variability, which may stem from differences in strain, growth rate and size of constriction. Mild constriction will lead to a chronically compensated state with increased RV systolic pressure and RV hypertrophy, but no symptoms of RV failure [16, 26, 27]. Rats have been reported to survive up to 22 weeks in such condition, despite (near) systemic RV pressures [28]. However, a tighter PAB has been demonstrated to lead to clinical symptoms of RV failure, i.e., inactivity, decreased cleaning behavior (raised fur), poor peripheral circulation, dyspnea/tachypnea, ascites and pleural/pericardial effusions and, ultimately, mortality in a high percentage of animals [17, 29–31]. High-intensity exercise capacity [32] and voluntary low-intensity exercise [8, 16, 17] are reduced in this model. These data indicate that a well-sized PAB represents a valuable model of chronic pressure load-induced RV failure.
The physiology of RV adaptation to increased afterload
The RV response to increased afterload shares several features among all in vivo animal models used. The gold standard to assess the hemodynamic properties of the (loaded) RV is pressure–volume analysis, which allows measurement of several parameters that quantify systolic and diastolic function regardless of loading conditions.
The primary response of the RV to match increased afterload is increased contractility, which is defined as end-systolic elastance (Ees) (Table 2). Contractility increases proportionally with increased arterial elastance (Ea, reflecting afterload) to maintain stroke volume (Fig. 1a, b: typical example of PV loops in response to pressure load). When end-systolic elastance increases less than arterial elastance, the Ees/Ea ratio decreases leading to ventricular–arterial uncoupling, which is regarded a physiological sign of RV failure. Indeed, beneficial pharmacological effects in the pressure-loaded RV are not seldom accompanied by a restoration of Ees/Ea ratio [16, 33, 34].
In chronic pressure load induced by pulmonary artery constriction or experimental PH, increased contractility [35] is accompanied by ventricular dilatation (Fig. 1b; [8, 16, 17, 32, 36–38]). This suggests that also the Frank–Starling mechanism contributes to the RV adaptation to chronic pressure load. Indeed, in most animal models of chronic increased pressure load, ventricular dilatation is associated with decreased Ees/Ea ratio, with the exception of mild monocrotaline-induced PH [36] and 3-month duration of flow-induced PH [39]. Unfortunately, ventricular dilatation leads to increased wall stress [8, 40] and is proposed as a hallmark of the failing ventricle [5], rather than an adaptive response. Improvement of the RV–PA coupling ratio does universally lead to reduction in RV dilatation (Table 3) and wall stress.
Evidence is accumulating that RV failure due to chronic pressure load is characterized by both enhanced systolic function and progressive deterioration of diastolic function [16, 31, 34]. Sparse clinical data show that in PH patients, higher right atrial pressure (an indirect measure of RV diastolic function) is associated with worse outcome. This could indicate that diastolic dysfunction contributes to RV failure in patients. From experimental models [41–44] using PAB as afterload (Table 2), it is clear that diastolic dysfunction is an inherent component of increased RV afterload (Fig. 1c, d; [17]). In dogs with a PAB, the diastolic dysfunction of the RV is partly compensated for right atrial adaptation, i.e., right atrial contractility increases, and the right atrium dilates to serve as a reservoir [41]. In a recent study in rats with a PAB separating those with clinical signs of severe RV failure from those without clinical signs but with RV dysfunction, clinical signs of RV failure were associated with a further deterioration of diastolic function despite increased systolic function [31]. These observations are confirmed by studies on isolated myocytes from patients with end-stage RV failure due to PH [45]. Intriguingly, in a recent study in which the RV was subjected to isolated volume load (pulmonary valve regurgitation), diastolic dysfunction was described without changes in Ees [46]. Deterioration of diastolic function might thus play a central role in the transition from compensation to failure (Fig. 1).
Diastolic function has a passive and an active component. The RV (compared to the LV) has been suggested to be particularly vulnerable to disturbed active relaxation, possibly due to insufficient expression of the sodium-calcium exchanger (NCX) [47]. Indeed, in experimental MCT-induced PH, active relaxation is increasingly disturbed with increasing MCT dose [36], while passive stiffness has been reported as normal [17, 36] or increased [48]. Chronic PAB invariably leads to diastolic dysfunction, with disturbances in both active relaxation and passive stiffness [16, 17, 41, 42].
Studies without pressure–volume analysis
Interpretation of the data in the literature is hampered by the lack of pressure–volume analysis in many studies. The alternatives, CMR-derived RV volumes or echocardiographic parameters for systolic function, only indirectly relate to contractility and are dependent on pre- and/or afterload. Systolic displacement of the lateral tricuspid annulus along the base-apex axis (TAPSE) is decreased in chronic pressure load. This reflects reduced longitudinal movement of the RV, but does not relate to RV pumping function, i.e., shifting volume at a certain pressure [49]. Fractional shortening of the RV outflow tract [29] and change in surface area [50] are also reported, but their significance in the setting of abnormal RV loading is unknown. CMR, the gold standard for RV function in clinical practice, has the advantage of being noninvasive, but without simultaneous pressure measurements, only yields load-dependent variables [8, 51, 52]. RV ejection fraction (EF), another outcome parameter, is generally reduced before overt RV failure ensues, although this parameter is of limited value as it is preload dependent [8, 36]. As described above, PV analysis characterizes the initial RV response as increased contractility and ventricular dilatation, two processes that have opposite effects on EF. Depending on the relative size of changes, EF may thus be increased, decreased or remain unchanged. Recently, Vanderpool et al. [53] suggested RV stroke volume divided by the end-systolic volume as an alternative, less preload dependent parameter.
Proximal- versus peripheral-type pressure load
Whether the type of pressure load (PAB vs. PH) determines the RV response is a matter of debate as conflicting data have been reported. Echocardiographic data suggest that at similar levels of pressure overload, the RV is less dilated and has superior function in patients with pulmonary stenosis compared with those with PAH. In contrast, a recent experimental comparison between rats with PAB and PH [17] showed that the PAB rats with moderate RV dysfunction (assessed by exercise and clinical signs and symptoms) had more severe RV dilatation in response to afterload than rats subjected to MCT-induced PH.
Interaction with LV function
The RV and LV functionally interact via shared fibers and the interventricular septum [11]. Interaction of the pressure-loaded RV with LV function has been noted in patients and animal models with PH [54, 55]. In a study in isolated hearts from rats with MCT-PH, pacing improved RV function and reduced interference in the diastolic phase [56]. Also, studies in isolated hearts suggested that the LV contributes to 65 % of the work of the normal RV [57]. In a PAB rabbit model of moderate RV dysfunction, increasing LV afterload via aortic constriction improved systolic RV function [58]. End-diastolic elastance tended to increase, but this effect was not significant.
The increased knowledge on the functional characterization of RV response to increased afterload leads to the question: Can we manipulate this response to support the failing RV? To answer this question, the hemodynamic adaptation has to be coupled to the pathobiology.
Pathobiology of RV failure
In the pressure-loaded RV, a myriad of cellular changes takes place that may initially serve as adaptive remodeling, but are also present in the failing RV (Fig. 2). Rather than caused by a single ‘malignant’ pathway, RV failure is the resultant of many biological changes, both adaptive and maladaptive. The interpretation of these changes is influenced by the state of RV dysfunction assessed by clinical signs and hemodynamic measurements as well as the trigger inducing the afterload (e.g., MCT or PAB). Some of these changes resemble those found in LV remodeling in adaptation to stress [40, 59].
RV hypertrophy, isoform switch and fibrosis
RV hypertrophy is an adaptive response to reduce wall stress and improve contractility. In the LV, hypertrophy is a strong predictor for outcome [59], but in experimental RV failure, this relation is less clear. In all studies in experimental animals, RV hypertrophy is present but this is not related to functional adaptation [16, 17, 26, 28]. In one study, RV hypertrophy was more severe in a PH model than in a PAB model [28], in other studies it was not, possibly due to differences in the degree of loading [14, 17, 26]. This is important to note, as some authors compare different models using the degree of RV hypertrophy to classify the state of adaptation, which may yield contradictory results [15].
Increased afterload of the RV induces a switch in myosin heavy chain (MHC) isoform composition from the fast alpha-MHC to the slower but energetically favorable beta-MHC in the RV myocardium [8, 16, 17, 27]. This response is not related to the degree of RV dysfunction. The hypertrophic response is induced by similar pathways as in the LV, e.g., the calcineurin−NFAT pathway [8], which may render the RV a putative target for calcineurin interference or other therapeutic strategies that have been shown to target LV hypertrophy [20].
RV fibrosis in response to increased afterload has been reported in some PH models [28, 34, 60] as well as in PAB models [17, 28], although there is a wide variation in the amount of collagen measured across models and the timeframe in which it develops. Given the putative relation between fibrosis and diastolic dysfunction, fibrosis may be a therapeutic target. However, a recent study shows there was no relation between the amount of (interstitial myocardial) fibrosis and the degree of RV dysfunction [17]. One may hypothesize that RV fibrosis is a by-product of the (mal)adaptive RV response to pressure load and has limited pathophysiological significance. Either way, fibrosis can be reduced with several interventions, i.e., beta-blockade [34], ROS scavenger [51], prostacyclin [60], but whether this is a direct effect or secondary to afterload reduction is unclear. Interestingly, an effective strategy to target specifically fibrosis (in LV failure) did not reduce fibrosis nor improve RV function in experimental RV failure [43]. Fibrosis may thus have ventricular-specific characteristics that require further exploration of its pathophysiological significance and therapeutic amenability in RV failure.
RV capillary formation/RV oxygen supply
Capillary rarefaction can play an important role in the development of RV failure. In the unstressed RV, coronary perfusion is present throughout the cardiac cycle [10], but in patients with PH, the coronary perfusion occurs primarily during diastole [61]. Because RV oxygen consumption also increases; a chronic oxygen demand–supply mismatch may be an underlying mechanism in the transition to failure. Coronary flow has not been measured yet in experimental models, but capillary density was reduced in several PH models [28, 34, 60]. Recently, two studies in various pressure load-induced disease states, i.e., MCT [14] and PAB [31], reported increased capillary density in compensated RV hypertrophy and pseudo-normalized density in decompensated RV hypertrophy. Further support for the significance of insufficient myocardial perfusion comes from the observation that prostacyclin therapy in rats with PH improves both capillary density and survival in the absence of beneficial effects on pulmonary hemodynamics or vascular remodeling [60]. Given its putative importance in the pathophysiology of RV failure, it is questioned which cellular processes are most affected by reduced myocardial perfusion. Candidate pathways are substrate metabolism, mitochondrial function and calcium handling.
Cardiac metabolism
In the LV, significant shifts in myocardial metabolism have been reported during the transition from adaptation to failure. Fatty acids are the main substrate for the adult heart under normal conditions, but under stress, a switch in substrate use occurs toward glucose and lactate [62]. In addition, glucose metabolism shifts from complete oxidation via the Krebs cycle to glycolysis only, which yields less ATP but also uses less oxygen per ATP molecule. Metabolic shifts are also observed in the pressure-loaded RV. Fatty acid oxidation (FAO) is reduced in PH patients, but only in those with severe hypertrophy [63]. Also, in rats with MCT-induced PH, the expression of CPT-1b (a rate limiting enzyme in the uptake of long-chain fatty acids [64]) was reduced [65, 66]. A reduction in the use of fatty acids seems to be an adaptive mechanism, since preventive inhibition via trimetazidine (which inhibits an essential step in oxidation of FA), increased cardiac output measured by echocardiography in a model of mild RV dysfunction due to a PAB [15].
In addition to the reduction in FAO, patients with PH have an increased uptake of the glucose analog 18FDG in the RV [67]. Also, in rats with MCT-induced PH, the expression of glycolysis-related genes is increased [68] as well as the enzymatic rates of glycolysis [69]. Increased expression of glycolysis-related genes has been shown in rats with MCT-PH [69], hypoxic-PH [70], Fawn-Hooded rats [71] and rats with a PAB [15, 69, 72], but none of the rats in these experimental studies had clinical symptoms of RV failure. Similarly, upregulation of pyruvate dehydrogenase kinase (PDK), which uncouples glycolysis from the Krebs cycle, has been shown in both PH and PAB models of adaptive RV remodeling [71]. Inhibition of PDK has been shown to increase RV O2 consumption and improve RV function, although a concomitant reduction in RV systolic pressure in the setting of fixed afterload (PAB model) in this study complicated the interpretation of these results [71]. Further evaluation of these effects in models of more severe RV dysfunction is needed since this therapy has also been shown to reverse pulmonary vascular remodeling in experimental PH [73], which could indicate a therapeutic strategy that may benefit both the RV and pulmonary vasculature.
Mitochondrial function
Mitochondria are the “powerhouses” of the cardiomyocyte, but also regulate many processes involved in the response to stress: formation of oxygen radicals, oxygen sensing, induction of apoptosis and inflammation [74]. The first notion that the RV in PH may be subjected to increased “oxidative stress” came from observations in rats with MCT-induced PH. These rats had increased myocardial activity of complex II and oxygen radicals, and also increased production of radical scavengers [37]. Treatment with a radical scavenger (EUK-134) improved RV systolic function but did not affect diastolic dysfunction [51]; however, in this study, pulmonary vascular resistance was also decreased after EUK-134 treatment, which may have contributed to the beneficial RV effects [75]. In another PH model (SUGEN + hypoxia), treatment with protandim (a plant extract inducing nrf2 expression) increased cardiac output, suggesting that at least in PH rats, increasing defense mechanisms against oxidative stress may be beneficial [28]. These pathways have not been tested in PAB models, i.e., independent from the pulmonary circulation.
Apoptosis and inflammation
Apoptosis and inflammation, both important mechanisms in the vascular pathology of PH [76–78], have not been explored in detail in the myocardium of models of RV pressure load. However, cardiomyocyte apoptosis and inflammation have been reported in both PH and PAB models [58, 79–81]. Pressure load is linked to apoptosis in multiple ways (mechanic damage, oxidative stress and neurohumoral signaling) and even mildly increased rates of apoptosis can contribute to heart failure [40]. Inflammation, marked by the presence and activation of immune cells and increased activity of inflammatory cytokines also connects pressure load and apoptosis. In addition, in LV pressure, mediators such as TNF-alpha and interleukins interact with neurohumoral signaling, induce fibrosis and affect contractile function and myocardial gene expression [40]. Data on the functional importance of inflammation in the development of RV failure are lacking.
PKG−PDE5 pathway
The importance of the protein kinase G (PKG) and phosphodiesterase 5 (PDE5) pathway in LV remodeling was shown in mice with transverse aortic constriction [82]. PDE5 catabolizes cGMP, which activates PKG and generally suppresses proliferative pathways. Hence, PDE5 inhibitors (e.g., sildenafil) may enhance the protective effects of PKG. Patients with increased RV afterload showed increased PDE5 expression [83], but only few studies in rat report data on PDE5 expression or PKG activity. PKG activity is not uniformly lowered in all models of experimental RV afterload [16]. Therefore, currently little is known about the importance of this pathway in RV failure. Positive results of intervention studies targeting this pathway (see Treatment of RV failure below) underline the importance of more detailed exploration of the PKG−PDE5 pathway in the RV as it may provide new treatment options for RV failure.
Other pathways
What are the consequences of the unique embryologic origin of the RV for the response to stress [8, 84]? In a rat model of PAB, the expression of dHand, an RV-specific precursor, as well as GATA-4, MEF2 and NKX2.5 were increased [85]. On the other hand, also signaling pathways involved in LV remodeling, such as the calcineurin pathway, have been shown to be activated in a murine model of PAB [8]. However, suppression of calcineurin activation in transgenic mice induced RV dilatation even without pressure load [20]. Similarly, inhibitors of histone deacytelases, which reduce adverse remodeling and improve function in experimental LV pressure load, worsen RV function in rats with a PAB [86]. Such incidental reports suggest that the regulation of adaptation to stress is indeed (partly) chamber specific.
The use of microarrays yields divergent results on genes and pathways possibly involved in the development of RV failure [31, 38, 65, 72, 87]. This may be due to the differences in models used (e.g., MCT vs. PAB), species differences (rat, mouse and rabbit) and different degrees of RV adaptation (compensated vs. decompensated). Additionally, array studies have provided evidence for chamber specificity of gene expression. Table 4 provides a summary of differences in signals between RV and LV in response to increased afterload.
A study in mice, comparing pressure load of the RV via PAB with pressure load of the LV via aortic constriction, showed differences between the two ventricles in expression of genes involved in (1) extracellular matrix proteins, (2) proteases and inhibitors and (3) developmentally regulated proteins [38]. In a similar study, four microRNAs were upregulated in the pressure-loaded RV, but these were all located in the non-myocyte fraction of the RV [80]. Gain/loss of function studies is the next step to determine the functional relevance of these findings.
Treatment of RV failure
Currently, no RV-specific medical treatment strategies exist. Reports of experimental RV drugs (Table 3) fall into one of three categories: (1) treatment strategies for LV failure (e.g., beta-adrenergic blockade, RAAS inhibition), (2) drugs that target the pulmonary vasculature in PH (e.g., PDE5 inhibitors, endothelin antagonists) and (3) proof-of-concept studies with experimental treatments.
Beta-adrenergic blockade and RAAS inhibition
The cornerstones of treatment of LV failure are inhibition of the beta-adrenergic receptors and the renin−angiotensin aldosterone system (RAAS). Clinicians are reluctant to prescribe beta blockers to patients with failing RVs in the setting of PH because of their negative inotropic effects, but preclinical studies have shown beneficial effects on RV remodeling. In the hypoxia + SUGEN model of PH, carvedilol, a non-selective beta blocker with also alpha-1-receptor blocking effects, reduced the development of hypertrophy, fibrosis, capillary rarefaction and attenuated reduction in cardiac output and TAPSE [88]. After treatment with Metoprolol, a selective beta blocker, similar effects were observed, although these can be attributed to reduction in the pulmonary vascular remodeling [88]. In the MCT model, bisoprolol (another selective beta blocker) does not prevent hypertrophy or capillary rarefaction, but prevents fibrosis along with delaying the decline in cardiac output and TAPSE [34]. Interestingly, bisoprolol increased phosphorylation of myocardial titin, suggesting a direct RV effect. In conclusion, beta blockers have variable effects in PH models. Unfortunately, no data are published on beta-blockade in the failing RV due to stenosis-type pressure overload, which might elucidate the direct protective effects of beta-blockade on the RV.
Clinical data in PH suggest that the RAAS is activated in at least a subgroup of patients. There are also suggestions that the RAAS system is active in congenital heart disease, and that combinations of RAAS-inhibiting drugs that are used in the standard care for LV failure patients (such as angiotensin receptor blockers + eplerenone) might potentiate the effect and target oxidative stress, fibrosis and improve diastolic dysfunction like in the LV. However, recently no effect of RAAS inhibition was shown in a rat model of PAB [43], in accordance with the results from a study in patients with a systemic RV in CHD [89].
PDE5 inhibitors
PDE5 inhibition would be an excellent therapeutic approach for RV failure in PH, as it also reduces pulmonary vasculature resistance [90]. However, the first two studies reporting on PDE5 inhibition in the PAB model showed no prevention or reduction in hypertrophy and fibrosis [27, 50]. In these studies, the functional analysis was limited to thermodilution-measured cardiac output and echocardiography. Using pressure–volume analysis, it was shown that preventive sildenafil increases contractility, reduces dilatation and attenuates the decline of spontaneous exercise, but leaves diastolic function unchanged [16], whereas in established RV pressure load, sildenafil treatment predominantly improved diastolic dysfunction, with a small effect on contractility [44]. The differences between the first and the latter studies may be due to differences in the severity of the loading condition, as in the LV it was shown that the effects of PDE5 inhibition are dependent upon the severity of the loading condition [91].
The mechanisms by which sildenafil exerts its effects are pleiotropic, incompletely known and not limited to the PDE5−PKG system. Mechanistically, sildenafil inhibits PDE5, increases compartmentalized cGMP and thereby activates PKG-1, which in turn has inhibitory effects on pathways of pathological remodeling [92]. PKG-1 also phosphorylates titin, thereby reducing stiffness [93]. In the pressure-loaded RV, sildenafil treatment as a preventive strategy increased fibrosis [16, 27, 50]. However, when given in a later stage of established pressure load, sildenafil reduced fibrosis and reduced ventricular stiffness [44], supporting the concept that timing and loading severity determines cardiac response (Fig. 3). Sildenafil also stimulates the PDE3−PKA pathway and targets mitochondrial (k)ATP channels, mitochondria and inflammation [94]. Other pharmacological approaches to manipulate the PDE5−PKG-1 axis include stimulation of soluble guanylate cyclase by riociguat, but results so far indicate effects on the pulmonary vasculature, rather than direct beneficial RV effects [95].
Endothelin receptor antagonists
Endothelin receptor antagonists (ERA) have an anti-hypertrophic and anti-fibrotic effect on the RV in PH [96]. It is unclear whether this is a direct effect on the RV or a consequence of the vasodilatation and anti-proliferative effect on the pulmonary vasculature. Unfortunately, no studies have addressed this issue. Endothelin-1 increases contractility in mouse RV cardiomyocytes via an increase in intracellular Ca2+ transients through activation of the Endothelin Receptor-A and the Na+–Ca2+ exchanger [97]. Upregulation of endothelin-1 in RV myocardium of patients and models of compensated hypertrophy [98] suggests a potential rationale for ERAs. However, isolated heart studies showed that ERAs suppress both contractility and relaxation in the hypertrophic RV [98] which might explain the negative outcomes of preclinical studies on ERAs in RV pressure load without pulmonary vascular remodeling [99]. Intriguingly, the negative inotropic effect of ERAs is absent in LV failure, which may be due to differences in endothelin-1 activation. It may even be possible that ERAs have contrasting therapeutic effects in compensated and failing RVs, but so far, this has not been studied.
Apart from medical intervention, exercise training may be beneficial for the pressure-loaded RV. In patients with a pressure-loaded RV, exercise training induces a modest increase in exercise capacity [100]. In rats with MCT-induced PH; however, exercise training was beneficial in mild PH and deleterious in severe PH [101]. Exercise training has not been tested yet in other models of RV load.
Conclusion
Since the Working Group Statement, progress has been made in understanding the pathophysiological and pathobiological mechanisms of RV failure due to chronic abnormal loading conditions, specifically increased afterload. The RV adaptation to increased afterload is characterized by increased contractility, dilatation and hypertrophy, whereas clinical RV failure is associated with progressive diastolic deterioration and despite increased contractility, disturbed ventricular−arterial coupling. The pathobiology of the failing RV has several characteristic features. An important factor seems to be the lack of adequate increase in capillary density leading to a hypoxic environment and oxidative stress. Additionally, there is a metabolic switch from FA to glucose utilization in the process of RV adaptation, but the role of this switch in RV failure is yet unclear. So far, therapies aiming to specifically improve RV function have had limited success. The use of beta blockers and sildenafil may hold some promise, but new therapies have to be developed. Finally, a lot of insight has been gained with regard to the specific values and limitations of the different models of RV pressure load and the methods used to define and characterize RV function and failure. In the future, this may aid in the understanding of the pathobiology of RV failure and development of new therapeutic strategies.
Abbreviations
- CHD:
-
Congenital heart diseases
- Ees:
-
End-systolic elastance
- Eed:
-
End-diastolic elastance
- ERA:
-
Endothelin receptor antagonists
- FAO:
-
Fatty acid oxidation
- LV:
-
Left ventricle
- MCT:
-
Monocrotaline
- PAB:
-
Pulmonary artery banding
- PDE5:
-
Phosphodiesterase 5
- PDK:
-
Pyruvate dehydrogenase kinase
- PKG:
-
Protein kinase G
- PH:
-
Pulmonary hypertension
- RAAS:
-
Renin−angiotensin aldosterone system
- RV:
-
Right ventricle
References
Norozi K, Wessel A, Alpers V, Arnhold JO, Geyer S, Zoege M, Buchhorn R (2006) Incidence and risk distribution of heart failure in adolescents and adults with congenital heart disease after cardiac surgery. Am J Cardiol 97:1238–1243
van Wolferen SA, Marcus JT, Boonstra A, Marques KM, Bronzwaer JG, Spreeuwenberg MD, Postmus PE, Vonk-Noordegraaf A (2007) Prognostic value of right ventricular mass, volume, and function in idiopathic pulmonary arterial hypertension. Eur Heart J 28:1250–1257
Meyer P, Filippatos GS, Ahmed MI, Iskandrian AE, Bittner V, Perry GJ, White M, Aban IB, Mujib M, Dell’Italia LJ, Ahmed A (2010) Effects of right ventricular ejection fraction on outcomes in chronic systolic heart failure. Circulation 121:252–258
Naeije R, Brimioulle S, Dewachter L (2014) Biomechanics of the right ventricle in health and disease (2013 Grover Conference series). Pulm Circ 4:395–406
Voelkel NF, Quaife RA, Leinwand LA, Barst RJ, McGoon MD, Meldrum DR, Dupuis J, Long CS, Rubin LJ, Smart FW, Suzuki YJ, Gladwin M, Denholm EM, Gail DB (2006) Right ventricular function and failure: report of a National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute working group on cellular and molecular mechanisms of right heart failure. Circulation 114:1883–1891
Haddad F, Doyle R, Murphy DJ, Hunt SA (2008) Right ventricular function in cardiovascular disease, part II: pathophysiology, clinical importance, and management of right ventricular failure. Circulation 117:1717–1731
Zaffran S, Kelly RG, Meilhac SM, Buckingham ME, Brown NA (2004) Right ventricular myocardium derives from the anterior heart field. Circ Res 95:261–268
Bartelds B, Borgdorff MA, Smit-van Oosten A, Takens J, Boersma B, Nederhoff MG, Elzenga NJ, van Gilst WH, De Windt LJ, Berger RM (2011) Differential responses of the right ventricle to abnormal loading conditions in mice: pressure vs. volume load. Eur J Heart Fail 13:1275–1282
Bartelds B, Berger RMF (2014) The right ventricle in congenital heart diseases. In: Gaine SP, Naeije R, Paecock AJ (eds) The right heart. Springer, Berlin, p 131
Zong P, Tune JD, Downey HF (2005) Mechanisms of oxygen demand/supply balance in the right ventricle. Exp Biol Med (Maywood) 230:507–519
Friedberg MK, Redington AN (2014) Right versus left ventricular failure: differences, similarities, and interactions. Circulation 129:1033–1044
Sagawa K, Maughan L, Suga H, Sunagawa K (1988) Cardiac contraction and the pressure–volume relationship. Oxford University Press, New York
Vonk-Noordegraaf A, Haddad F, Chin KM, Forfia PR, Kawut SM, Lumens J, Naeije R, Newman J, Oudiz RJ, Provencher S, Torbicki A, Voelkel NF, Hassoun PM (2013) Right heart adaptation to pulmonary arterial hypertension: physiology and pathobiology. J Am Coll Cardiol 62:D22–D33
Sutendra G, Dromparis P, Paulin R, Zervopoulos S, Haromy A, Nagendran J, Michelakis ED (2013) A metabolic remodeling in right ventricular hypertrophy is associated with decreased angiogenesis and a transition from a compensated to a decompensated state in pulmonary hypertension. J Mol Med 91:1315–1327
Fang YH, Piao L, Hong Z, Toth PT, Marsboom G, Bache-Wiig P, Rehman J, Archer SL (2012) Therapeutic inhibition of fatty acid oxidation in right ventricular hypertrophy: exploiting Randle’s cycle. J Mol Med 90:31–43
Borgdorff MA, Bartelds B, Dickinson MG, Boersma B, Weij M, Zandvoort A, Sillje HH, Steendijk P, de Vroomen M, Berger RM (2012) Sildenafil enhances systolic adaptation, but does not prevent diastolic dysfunction, in the pressure-loaded right ventricle. Eur J Heart Fail 14:1067–1074
Borgdorff MA, Bartelds B, Dickinson MG, Steendijk P, de Vroomen M, Berger RM (2013) Distinct loading conditions reveal various patterns of right ventricular adaptation. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 305:H354–H364
Gomez-Arroyo JG, Farkas L, Alhussaini AA, Farkas D, Kraskauskas D, Voelkel NF, Bogaard HJ (2012) The monocrotaline model of pulmonary hypertension in perspective. Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol 302:L363–L369
Bartelds B, Borgdorff MAJ, Berger RMF (2014) Right ventricular adaptation in congenital heart diseases. J Cardiovasc Dev Dis 1:83
Bartelds B, Borgdorff MA, Boersma B, Takens J, Smit-van Oosten A, De Windt LJ, Berger RMF (2011) Right ventricular adaptation to pressure load in mice is improved after blockade of calcineurin activation. Eur Heart J 31(suppl):305
Reddy S, Zhao M, Hu DQ, Fajardo G, Katznelson E, Punn R, Spin JM, Chan FP, Bernstein D (2013) Physiologic and molecular characterization of a murine model of right ventricular volume overload. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 304:H1314–H1327
Dickinson MG, Bartelds B, Borgdorff MA, Berger RM (2013) The role of disturbed blood flow in the development of pulmonary arterial hypertension: lessons from preclinical animal models. Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol 305:L1–L14
Stenmark KR, Meyrick B, Galie N, Mooi WJ, McMurtry IF (2009) Animal models of pulmonary arterial hypertension: the hope for etiological discovery and pharmacological cure. Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol 297:L1013–L1032
Stenmark KR, Fagan KA, Frid MG (2006) Hypoxia-induced pulmonary vascular remodeling: cellular and molecular mechanisms. Circ Res 99:675–691
Ghobadi G, Bartelds B, van der Veen SJ, Dickinson MG, Brandenburg S, Berger RM, Langendijk JA, Coppes RP, van Luijk P (2012) Lung irradiation induces pulmonary vascular remodelling resembling pulmonary arterial hypertension. Thorax 67:334–341
Faber MJ, Dalinghaus M, Lankhuizen IM, Steendijk P, Hop WC, Schoemaker RG, Duncker DJ, Lamers JM, Helbing WA (2006) Right and left ventricular function after chronic pulmonary artery banding in rats assessed with biventricular pressure–volume loops. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 291:H1580–H1586
Schafer S, Ellinghaus P, Janssen W, Kramer F, Lustig K, Milting H, Kast R, Klein M (2009) Chronic inhibition of phosphodiesterase 5 does not prevent pressure-overload-induced right-ventricular remodelling. Cardiovasc Res 82:30–39
Bogaard HJ, Natarajan R, Henderson SC, Long CS, Kraskauskas D, Smithson L, Ockaili R, McCord JM, Voelkel NF (2009) Chronic pulmonary artery pressure elevation is insufficient to explain right heart failure. Circulation 120:1951–1960
Urashima T, Zhao M, Wagner R, Fajardo G, Farahani S, Quertermous T, Bernstein D (2008) Molecular and physiological characterization of RV remodeling in a murine model of pulmonary stenosis. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 295:H1351–H1368
LekanneDeprez RH, van den Hoff MJ, de Boer PA, Ruijter PM, Maas AA, Chamuleau RA, Lamers WH, Moorman AF (1998) Changing patterns of gene expression in the pulmonary trunk-banded rat heart. J Mol Cell Cardiol 30:1877–1888
Borgdorff MA, Koop AM, Bloks VW, Dickinson MG, Steendijk P, Sillje HH, van Wiechen MP, Berger RM, Bartelds B (2015) Clinical symptoms of right ventricular failure in experimental chronic pressure load are associated with progressive diastolic dysfunction. J Mol Cell Cardiol 79:244–253
Piao L, Fang YH, Parikh KS, Ryan JJ, D’Souza KM, Theccanat T, Toth PT, Pogoriler J, Paul J, Blaxall BC, Akhter SA, Archer SL (2012) GRK2-mediated inhibition of adrenergic and dopaminergic signaling in right ventricular hypertrophy: therapeutic implications in pulmonary hypertension. Circulation 126:2859–2869
Brimioulle S, Wauthy P, Naeije R (2005) Single-beat evaluation of right ventricular contractility. Crit Care Med 33:917–918
de Man FS, Handoko ML, van Ballegoij JJ, Schalij I, Bogaards SJ, Postmus PE, van der Velden J, Westerhof N, Paulus WJ, Vonk-Noordegraaf A (2012) Bisoprolol delays progression towards right heart failure in experimental pulmonary hypertension. Circ Heart Fail 5:97–105
de Vroomen M, Cardozo RH, Steendijk P, van Bel F, Baan J (2000) Improved contractile performance of right ventricle in response to increased RV afterload in newborn lamb. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 278:H100–H105
Hessel MH, Steendijk P, den Adel B, Schutte CI, van der Laarse A (2006) Characterization of right ventricular function after monocrotaline-induced pulmonary hypertension in the intact rat. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 291:H2424–H2430
Redout EM, Wagner MJ, Zuidwijk MJ, Boer C, Musters RJ, van Hardeveld C, Paulus WJ, Simonides WS (2007) Right-ventricular failure is associated with increased mitochondrial complex II activity and production of reactive oxygen species. Cardiovasc Res 75:770–781
Kreymborg K, Uchida S, Gellert P, Schneider A, Boettger T, Voswinckel R, Wietelmann A, Szibor M, Weissmann N, Ghofrani AH, Schermuly R, Schranz D, Seeger W, Braun T (2010) Identification of right heart-enriched genes in a murine model of chronic outflow tract obstruction. J Mol Cell Cardiol 49:598–605
Rondelet B, Dewachter L, Kerbaul F, Dewachter C, Hubloue I, Fesler P, Franck S, Remmelink M, Brimioulle S, Naeije R (2010) Sildenafil added to sitaxsentan in overcirculation-induced pulmonary arterial hypertension. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 299:H1118–H1123
Bogaard HJ, Abe K, Noordegraaf AV, Voelkel NF (2009) The right ventricle under pressure: cellular and molecular mechanisms of right-heart failure in pulmonary hypertension. Chest 135:794–804
Gaynor SL, Maniar HS, Bloch JB, Steendijk P, Moon MR (2005) Right atrial and ventricular adaptation to chronic right ventricular pressure overload. Circulation 112:I212–I218
Leeuwenburgh BP, Steendijk P, Helbing WA, Baan J (2002) Indexes of diastolic RV function: load dependence and changes after chronic RV pressure overload in lambs. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 282:H1350–H1358
Borgdorff MA, Bartelds B, Dickinson MG, Steendijk P, Berger RM (2013) A cornerstone of heart failure treatment is not effective in experimental right ventricular failure. Int J Cardiol 169:183–189
Borgdorff MA, Bartelds B, Dickinson MG, van Wiechen MP, Steendijk P, de Vroomen M, Berger RM (2014) Sildenafil treatment in established right ventricular dysfunction improves diastolic function and attenuates interstitial fibrosis independent from afterload. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 307:H361–H369
Rain S, Handoko ML, Trip P, Gan CT, Westerhof N, Stienen GJ, Paulus WJ, Ottenheijm CA, Marcus JT, Dorfmuller P, Guignabert C, Humbert M, Macdonald P, Dos Remedios C, Postmus PE, Saripalli C, Hidalgo CG, Granzier HL, Vonk-Noordegraaf A, van der Velden J, de Man FS (2013) Right ventricular diastolic impairment in patients with pulmonary arterial hypertension. Circulation 128(2016–25):1–10
Bove T, Vandekerckhove K, Bouchez S, Wouters P, Somers P, Van Nooten G (2014) Role of myocardial hypertrophy on acute and chronic right ventricular performance in relation to chronic volume overload in a porcine model: relevance for the surgical management of tetralogy of Fallot. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 147:1956–1965
Chugh SS, Whitesel S, Turner M, Roberts CT Jr, Nagalla SR (2003) Genetic basis for chamber-specific ventricular phenotypes in the rat infarct model. Cardiovasc Res 57:477–485
Lamberts RR, Caldenhoven E, Lansink M, Witte G, Vaessen RJ, St Cyr JA, Stienen GJ (2007) Preservation of diastolic function in monocrotaline-induced right ventricular hypertrophy in rats. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 293:H1869–H1876
Buechel ERV, Mertens LL (2012) Imaging the right heart: the use of integrated multimodality imaging. Eur Heart J 33:949–960
Andersen A, Nielsen JM, Peters CD, Schou UK, Sloth E, Nielsen-Kudsk JE (2008) Effects of phosphodiesterase-5 inhibition by sildenafil in the pressure overloaded right heart. Eur J Heart Fail 10:1158–1165
Redout EM, van der Toorn A, Zuidwijk MJ, van de Kolk CW, van Echteld CJ, Musters RJ, van Hardeveld C, Paulus WJ, Simonides WS (2010) Antioxidant treatment attenuates pulmonary arterial hypertension-induced heart failure. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 298:H1038–H1047
Kuehne T, Yilmaz S, Steendijk P, Moore P, Groenink M, Saaed M, Weber O, Higgins CB, Ewert P, Fleck E, Nagel E, Schulze-Neick I, Lange P (2004) Magnetic resonance imaging analysis of right ventricular pressure-volume loops: in vivo validation and clinical application in patients with pulmonary hypertension. Circulation 110:2010–2016
Vanderpool RR, Pinsky MR, Naeije R, Deible C, Kosaraju V, Bunner C, Mathier MA, Lacomis J, Champion HC, Simon MA (2015) RV-pulmonary arterial coupling predicts outcome in patients referred for pulmonary hypertension. Heart 101:37–43
Gan C, Lankhaar JW, Marcus JT, Westerhof N, Marques KM, Bronzwaer JG, Boonstra A, Postmus PE, Vonk-Noordegraaf A (2006) Impaired left ventricular filling due to right-to-left ventricular interaction in patients with pulmonary arterial hypertension. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 290:H1528–H1533
Ghobadi G, van der Veen S, Bartelds B, de Boer RA, Dickinson MG, de Jong JR, Faber H, Niemantsverdriet M, Brandenburg S, Berger RM, Langendijk JA, Coppes RP, van Luijk P (2012) Physiological interaction of heart and lung in thoracic irradiation. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 84:e639–e646
Handoko ML, Lamberts RR, Redout EM, de Man FS, Boer C, Simonides WS, Paulus WJ, Westerhof N, Allaart CP, Vonk-Noordegraaf A (2009) Right ventricular pacing improves right heart function in experimental pulmonary arterial hypertension: a study in the isolated heart. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 297:H1752–H1759
Damiano RJ Jr, La Follette P, Jr Cox JL, Lowe JE, Santamore WP (1991) Significant left ventricular contribution to right ventricular systolic function. Am J Physiol 261:H1514–H1524
Apitz C, Honjo O, Humpl T, Li J, Assad RS, Cho MY, Hong J, Friedberg MK, Redington AN (2012) Biventricular structural and functional responses to aortic constriction in a rabbit model of chronic right ventricular pressure overload. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 144:1494–1501
van Berlo JH, Maillet M, Molkentin JD (2013) Signaling effectors underlying pathologic growth and remodeling of the heart. J Clin Invest 123:37–45
van Albada ME, Berger RM, Niggebrugge M, van Veghel R, Cromme-Dijkhuis AH, Schoemaker RG (2006) Prostacyclin therapy increases right ventricular capillarisation in a model for flow-associated pulmonary hypertension. Eur J Pharmacol 549:107–116
Wong YY, Ruiter G, Lubberink M, Raijmakers PG, Knaapen P, Marcus JT, Boonstra A, Lammertsma AA, Westerhof N, van der Laarse WJ, Vonk-Noordegraaf A (2011) Right ventricular failure in idiopathic pulmonary arterial hypertension is associated with inefficient myocardial oxygen utilization. Circ Heart Fail 4:700–706
Bartelds B, Knoester H, Smid GB, Takens J, Visser GH, Penninga L, van der Leij FR, Beaufort-Krol GC, Zijlstra WG, Heymans HS, Kuipers JR (2000) Perinatal changes in myocardial metabolism in lambs. Circulation 102:926–931
Kim Y, Goto H, Kobayashi K, Sawada Y, Miyake Y, Fujiwara G, Chiba H, Okada T, Nishimura T (1997) Detection of impaired fatty acid metabolism in right ventricular hypertrophy: assessment by I-123 beta-methyl iodophenyl pentadecanoic acid (BMIPP) myocardial single-photon emission computed tomography. Ann Nucl Med 11:207–212
Bartelds B, Takens J, Smid GB, Zammit VA, Prip-Buus C, Kuipers JR, van der Leij FR (2004) Myocardial carnitine palmitoyltransferase I expression and long-chain fatty acid oxidation in fetal and newborn lambs. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 286:H2243–H2248
Buermans HP, Redout EM, Schiel AE, Musters RJ, Zuidwijk M, Eijk PP, van Hardeveld C, Kasanmoentalib S, Visser FC, Ylstra B, Simonides WS (2005) Microarray analysis reveals pivotal divergent mRNA expression profiles early in the development of either compensated ventricular hypertrophy or heart failure. Physiol Genomics 21:314–323
Gomez-Arroyo J, Mizuno S, Szczepanek K, Van Tassell B, Natarajan R, dos Remedios CG, Drake JI, Farkas L, Kraskauskas D, Wijesinghe DS, Chalfant CE, Bigbee J, Abbate A, Lesnefsky EJ, Bogaard HJ, Voelkel NF (2013) Metabolic gene remodeling and mitochondrial dysfunction in failing right ventricular hypertrophy secondary to pulmonary arterial hypertension. Circ Heart Fail 6:136–144
Oikawa M, Kagaya Y, Otani H, Sakuma M, Demachi J, Suzuki J, Takahashi T, Nawata J, Ido T, Watanabe J, Shirato K (2005) Increased [18F]fluorodeoxyglucose accumulation in right ventricular free wall in patients with pulmonary hypertension and the effect of epoprostenol. J Am Coll Cardiol 45:1849–1855
Drake JI, Bogaard HJ, Mizuno S, Clifton B, Xie B, Gao Y, Dumur CI, Fawcett P, Voelkel NF, Natarajan R (2011) Molecular signature of a right heart failure program in chronic severe pulmonary hypertension. Am J Respir Cell Mol Biol 45:1239–1247
Piao L, Fang YH, Cadete VJ, Wietholt C, Urboniene D, Toth PT, Marsboom G, Zhang HJ, Haber I, Rehman J, Lopaschuk GD, Archer SL (2010) The inhibition of pyruvate dehydrogenase kinase improves impaired cardiac function and electrical remodeling in two models of right ventricular hypertrophy: resuscitating the hibernating right ventricle. J Mol Med 88:47–60
Michelakis ED, McMurtry MS, Wu XC, Dyck JR, Moudgil R, Hopkins TA, Lopaschuk GD, Puttagunta L, Waite R, Archer SL (2002) Dichloroacetate, a metabolic modulator, prevents and reverses chronic hypoxic pulmonary hypertension in rats: role of increased expression and activity of voltage-gated potassium channels. Circulation 105:244–250
Piao L, Marsboom G, Archer SL (2010) Mitochondrial metabolic adaptation in right ventricular hypertrophy and failure. J Mol Med 88:1011–1020
Faber MJ, Dalinghaus M, Lankhuizen IM, Bezstarosti K, Dekkers DH, Duncker DJ, Helbing WA, Lamers JM (2005) Proteomic changes in the pressure overloaded right ventricle after 6 weeks in young rats: correlations with the degree of hypertrophy. Proteomics 5:2519–2530
McMurtry MS, Bonnet S, Wu X, Dyck JR, Haromy A, Hashimoto K, Michelakis ED (2004) Dichloroacetate prevents and reverses pulmonary hypertension by inducing pulmonary artery smooth muscle cell apoptosis. Circ Res 95:830–840
Dromparis P, Michelakis ED (2013) Mitochondria in vascular health and disease. Annu Rev Physiol 75:95–126
Dromparis P, Paulin R, Stenson TH, Haromy A, Sutendra G, Michelakis ED (2013) Attenuating endoplasmic reticulum stress as a novel therapeutic strategy in pulmonary hypertension. Circulation 127:115–125
Bartelds B, van Loon RL, Mohaupt S, Wijnberg H, Dickinson MG, Boersma B, Takens J, van Albada M, Berger RM (2012) Mast cell inhibition improves pulmonary vascular remodeling in pulmonary hypertension. Chest 141:651–660
van Albada ME, Bartelds B, Wijnberg H, Mohaupt S, Dickinson MG, Schoemaker RG, Kooi K, Gerbens F, Berger RM (2010) Gene expression profile in flow-associated pulmonary arterial hypertension with neointimal lesions. Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol 298:L483–L491
Hassoun PM, Mouthon L, Barbera JA, Eddahibi S, Flores SC, Grimminger F, Jones PL, Maitland ML, Michelakis ED, Morrell NW, Newman JH, Rabinovitch M, Schermuly R, Stenmark KR, Voelkel NF, Yuan JX, Humbert M (2009) Inflammation, growth factors, and pulmonary vascular remodeling. J Am Coll Cardiol 54:S10–S19
Rajagopalan V, Zhao M, Reddy S, Fajardo GA, Wang X, Dewey S, Gomes AV, Bernstein D (2013) Altered ubiquitin-proteasome signaling in right ventricular hypertrophy and failure. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 305:H551–H562
Dewachter C, Dewachter L, Rondelet B, Fesler P, Brimioulle S, Kerbaul F, Naeije R (2010) Activation of apoptotic pathways in experimental acute afterload-induced right ventricular failure. Crit Care Med 38:1405–1413
Rondelet B, Dewachter C, Kerbaul F, Kang X, Fesler P, Brimioulle S, Naeije R, Dewachter L (2012) Prolonged overcirculation-induced pulmonary arterial hypertension as a cause of right ventricular failure. Eur Heart J 33:1017–1026
Takimoto E, Champion HC, Li M, Belardi D, Ren S, Rodriguez ER, Bedja D, Gabrielson KL, Wang Y, Kass DA (2005) Chronic inhibition of cyclic GMP phosphodiesterase 5A prevents and reverses cardiac hypertrophy. Nat Med 11:214–222
Nagendran J, Gurtu V, Fu DZ, Dyck JR, Haromy A, Ross DB, Rebeyka IM, Michelakis ED (2008) A dynamic and chamber-specific mitochondrial remodeling in right ventricular hypertrophy can be therapeutically targeted. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 136:168–178
Olson EN (2006) Gene regulatory networks in the evolution and development of the heart. Science 313:1922–1927
Bar H, Kreuzer J, Cojoc A, Jahn L (2003) Upregulation of embryonic transcription factors in right ventricular hypertrophy. Basic Res Cardiol 98:285–294
Bogaard HJ, Mizuno S, Hussaini AA, Toldo S, Abbate A, Kraskauskas D, Kasper M, Natarajan R, Voelkel NF (2011) Suppression of histone deacetylases worsens right ventricular dysfunction after pulmonary artery banding in rats. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 183:1402–1410
Reddy S, Zhao M, Hu DQ, Fajardo G, Hu S, Ghosh Z, Rajagopalan V, Wu JC, Bernstein D (2012) Dynamic microRNA expression during the transition from right ventricular hypertrophy to failure. Physiol Genomics 44:562–575
Bogaard HJ, Natarajan R, Mizuno S, Abbate A, Chang PJ, Chau VQ, Hoke NN, Kraskauskas D, Kasper M, Salloum FN, Voelkel NF (2010) Adrenergic receptor blockade reverses right heart remodeling and dysfunction in pulmonary hypertensive rats. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 182:652–660
van der Bom T, Winter MM, Bouma BJ, Groenink M, Vliegen HW, Pieper PG, van Dijk AP, Sieswerda GT, Roos-Hesselink JW, Zwinderman AH, Mulder BJ (2013) Effect of valsartan on systemic right ventricular function: a double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled pilot trial. Circulation 127:322–330
Archer SL, Michelakis ED (2009) Phosphodiesterase type 5 inhibitors for pulmonary arterial hypertension. N Engl J Med 361:1864–1871
Nagayama T, Hsu S, Zhang M, Koitabashi N, Bedja D, Gabrielson KL, Takimoto E, Kass DA (2009) Pressure-overload magnitude-dependence of the anti-hypertrophic efficacy of PDE5A inhibition. J Mol Cell Cardiol 46:560–567
Hsu S, Nagayama T, Koitabashi N, Zhang M, Zhou L, Bedja D, Gabrielson KL, Molkentin JD, Kass DA, Takimoto E (2009) Phosphodiesterase 5 inhibition blocks pressure overload-induced cardiac hypertrophy independent of the calcineurin pathway. Cardiovasc Res 81:301–309
Bishu K, Hamdani N, Mohammed SF, Kruger M, Ohtani T, Ogut O, Brozovich FV, Burnett JC Jr, Linke WA, Redfield MM (2011) Sildenafil and B-type natriuretic peptide acutely phosphorylate titin and improve diastolic distensibility in vivo. Circulation 124:2882–2891
Nagendran J, Archer SL, Soliman D, Gurtu V, Moudgil R, Haromy A, St Aubin C, Webster L, Rebeyka IM, Ross DB, Light PE, Dyck JR, Michelakis ED (2007) Phosphodiesterase type 5 is highly expressed in the hypertrophied human right ventricle, and acute inhibition of phosphodiesterase type 5 improves contractility. Circulation 116:238–248
Lang M, Kojonazarov B, Tian X, Kalymbetov A, Weissmann N, Grimminger F, Kretschmer A, Stasch JP, Seeger W, Ghofrani HA, Schermuly RT (2012) The soluble guanylate cyclase stimulator riociguat ameliorates pulmonary hypertension induced by hypoxia and SU5416 in rats. PLoS one 7:e43433
Choudhary G, Troncales F, Martin D, Harrington EO, Klinger JR (2011) Bosentan attenuates right ventricular hypertrophy and fibrosis in normobaric hypoxia model of pulmonary hypertension. J Heart Lung Transplant 30:827–833
Nagasaka T, Izumi M, Hori M, Ozaki H, Karaki H (2003) Positive inotropic effect of endothelin-1 in the neonatal mouse right ventricle. Eur J Pharmacol 472:197–204
Nagendran J, Sutendra G, Paterson I, Champion HC, Webster L, Chiu B, Haromy A, Rebeyka IM, Ross DB, Michelakis ED (2013) Endothelin axis is upregulated in human and rat right ventricular hypertrophy. Circ Res 112:347–354
Mouchaers KT, Schalij I, Versteilen AM, Hadi AM, van Nieuw Amerongen GP, van Hinsbergh VW, Postmus PE, van der Laarse WJ, Vonk-Noordegraaf A (2009) Endothelin receptor blockade combined with phosphodiesterase-5 inhibition increases right ventricular mitochondrial capacity in pulmonary arterial hypertension. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 297:H200–H207
Winter MM, van der Bom T, de Vries LC, Balducci A, Bouma BJ, Pieper PG, van Dijk AP, van der Plas MN, Picchio FM, Mulder BJ (2012) Exercise training improves exercise capacity in adult patients with a systemic right ventricle: a randomized clinical trial. Eur Heart J 33:1378–1385
Handoko ML, de Man FS, Happe CM, Schalij I, Musters RJ, Westerhof N, Postmus PE, Paulus WJ, van der Laarse WJ, Vonk-Noordegraaf A (2009) Opposite effects of training in rats with stable and progressive pulmonary hypertension. Circulation 120:42–49
de Man FS, Tu L, Handoko ML, Rain S, Ruiter G, Francois C, Schalij I, Dorfmuller P, Simonneau G, Fadel E, Perros F, Boonstra A, Postmus PE, van der Velden J, Vonk-Noordegraaf A, Humbert M, Eddahibi S, Guignabert C (2012) Dysregulated renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system contributes to pulmonary arterial hypertension. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 186:780–789
Mouchaers KT, Schalij I, de Boer MA, Postmus PE, van Hinsbergh VW, van Nieuw Amerongen GP, Vonk Noordegraaf A, van der Laarse WJ (2010) Fasudil reduces monocrotaline-induced pulmonary arterial hypertension: comparison with bosentan and sildenafil. Eur Respir J 36:800–807
Piao L, Sidhu VK, Fang YH, Ryan JJ, Parikh KS, Hong Z, Toth PT, Morrow E, Kutty S, Lopaschuk GD, Archer SL (2013) FOXO1-mediated upregulation of pyruvate dehydrogenase kinase-4 (PDK4) decreases glucose oxidation and impairs right ventricular function in pulmonary hypertension: therapeutic benefits of dichloroacetate. J Mol Med 91:333–346
Xie YP, Chen B, Sanders P, Guo A, Li Y, Zimmerman K, Wang LC, Weiss RM, Grumbach IM, Anderson ME, Song LS (2012) Sildenafil prevents and reverses transverse-tubule remodeling and Ca(2+) handling dysfunction in right ventricle failure induced by pulmonary artery hypertension. Hypertension 59:355–362
Matori H, Umar S, Nadadur RD, Sharma S, Partow-Navid R, Afkhami M, Amjedi M, Eghbali M (2012) Genistein, a soy phytoestrogen, reverses severe pulmonary hypertension and prevents right heart failure in rats. Hypertension 60:425–430
Nadadur RD, Umar S, Wong G, Eghbali M, Iorga A, Matori H, Partow-Navid R, Eghbali M (2012) Reverse right ventricular structural and extracellular matrix remodeling by estrogen in severe pulmonary hypertension. J Appl Physiol 113:149–158
Umar S, Iorga A, Matori H, Nadadur RD, Li J, Maltese F, van der Laarse A, Eghbali M (2011) Estrogen rescues preexisting severe pulmonary hypertension in rats. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 184:715–723
Umar S, Lee JH, de Lange E, Iorga A, Partow-Navid R, Bapat A, van der Laarse A, Saggar R, Saggar R, Ypey DL, Karagueuzian HS, Eghbali M (2012) Spontaneous ventricular fibrillation in right ventricular failure secondary to chronic pulmonary hypertension. Circ Arrhythm Electrophysiol 5:181–190
Umar S, Nadadur RD, Li J, Maltese F, Partownavid P, van der Laarse A, Eghbali M (2011) Intralipid prevents and rescues fatal pulmonary arterial hypertension and right ventricular failure in rats. Hypertension 58:512–518
Faber MJ, Dalinghaus M, Lankhuizen IM, Bezstarosti K, Verhoeven AJ, Duncker DJ, Helbing WA, Lamers JM (2007) Time dependent changes in cytoplasmic proteins of the right ventricle during prolonged pressure overload. J Mol Cell Cardiol 43:197–209
Okada M, Harada T, Kikuzuki R, Yamawaki H, Hara Y (2009) Effects of telmisartan on right ventricular remodeling induced by monocrotaline in rats. J Pharmacol Sci 111:193–200
Andersen A, Nielsen JM, Holmboe S, Vildbrad MD, Nielsen-Kudsk JE (2013) The effects of cyclic guanylate cyclase stimulation on right ventricular hypertrophy and failure alone and in combination with phosphodiesterase-5 inhibition. J Cardiovasc Pharmacol 62:167–173
Lu B, Yu H, Zwartbol M, Ruifrok WP, van Gilst WH, de Boer RA, Silljé HH (2012) Identification of hypertrophy- and heart failure-associated genes by combining in vitro and in vivo models. Physiol Genomics 44:443–454
Paulin R, Sutendra G, Gurtu V, Dromparis P, Haromy A, Provencher S, Bonnet S, Michelakis ED (2015) A miR-208-Mef2 axis drives the decompensation of right ventricular function in pulmonary hypertension. Circ Res 116:56–69
Acknowledgments
This study was supported by the Sebald foundation and the Netherlands Heart Foundation [Grant #:2006T038; 2007T068].
Conflict of interest
Drs. Borgdorff, Dickinson, Berger and Bartelds have no conflicts of interest or financial ties to disclose.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License which permits any use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and the source are credited.
About this article
Cite this article
Borgdorff, M.A.J., Dickinson, M.G., Berger, R.M.F. et al. Right ventricular failure due to chronic pressure load: What have we learned in animal models since the NIH working group statement?. Heart Fail Rev 20, 475–491 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10741-015-9479-6
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10741-015-9479-6