Abstract
In this paper, we present stable carbon and oxygen isotope analyses of fauna tooth enamel from Garba IVD (1.95 Ma) and Gombore IB (1.66 Ma), two Early Acheulean sites of Melka Kunture (Upper Awash, Ethiopia), and discuss faunal taxonomy and fossil pollen. Our aim is to infer the diet and habitat of the fossil fauna, as well as the environment of both sites, in order to provide a broader paleoecological reconstruction. During the Pleistocene, the vegetation of the highlands of Ethiopia belonged to the Dry evergreen Afromontane Forest and grassland complex, which is distinct from the savanna of lower elevations in eastern Africa. Our carbon isotopic results indicate that all the analyzed faunal taxa were grazers consuming C4 plants, whereas oxygen isotopic results discriminate the taxa according to their semiaquatic or terrestrial habitats. These results are consistent with the taxonomic composition of the faunal assemblages and the palynological results, suggesting extended mountain grasslands in the landscape at Garba IVD. In contrast, the carbon isotopic results do not totally agree with the pollen paleoenvironmental reconstruction at Gombore IB, where the open vegetation was interrupted by forests and bushy vegetation. Stable isotope and pollen data provide different outcomes (feeding strategies vs. nearby plants) and have different temporal and spatial resolutions. This is relevant when reconstructing past environments by using independent proxies. Furthermore, isotopic comparisons with other Early Pleistocene paleontological and archaeological sites from eastern Africa indicate that all the analyzed taxa in common fed on C4 plants and that their dietary strategies were not affected by variations linked to the difference in elevations.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Introduction
Multiple proxies, such as stable isotopes, dental wear, faunal abundance and taxonomy, fossil pollen and phytolith analysis, geomorphological studies, skeletal morphometrics, and ichnology, provide insights into mammalian diet, behavior, habitat, and environment, which provide a wealth of information for ancient ecological reconstructions.
To date, most environmental and ecological evidence derives from eastern African archaeological and paleontological sites at medium and low altitudes (Harris et al., 2008; van der Merwe, 2013; Ascari et al., 2018; Rivals et al., 2018; Uno et al., 2018; Negash et al., 2020) although few archaeological contexts are known at higher elevations (≥2000 m a.s.l.), such as Melka Kunture, Gadeb, and Melka Wakena in Ethiopia; Kilombe in Kenya; and Isimila in Tanzania. The occupation of the highland of Ethiopia has been interpreted in some case studies (Hovers et al., 2021). Based on the analysis of the lithic tools from Gadeb site, Clark and Kurashina (1979) hypothesized a seasonal movement of humans from the Rift to the highlands over long distances (>100 km) to exploit raw material. Subsequently, Clark (1987) suggested that humans explored the highlands to expand their ecological niche, with implications regarding diet and environmental resources. Recently, Mussi et al. (2016) used a multi-proxy approach to analyze the sequence of Gombore II site (Melka Kunture), suggesting that, at ~800–700 ka, the occupation of the Ethiopian highlands by Homo erectus occurred during warm climate phases.
The present study couples and crosschecks faunal taxonomy, fossil pollen, and new stable carbon and oxygen isotope analysis on faunal teeth from Early Acheulean Level D at Garba IV (Garba IVD) and level B at Gombore I (Gombore IB) to investigate the related paleoecology at 1.95 Ma and 1.66 Ma, respectively. The sites are part of the Melka Kunture cluster of prehistoric deposits, located on the highlands of Ethiopia at ~2000–2200 m above sea level. Due to the elevation, the vegetation belonged to the Afromontane complex (Bonnefille et al., 2018), which greatly differs from the savanna vegetation of many Pleistocene African sites at lower altitudes. Pollen analysis documents open vegetation with extended high-elevation grasslands in the paleolandscape of Garba IVD, whereas Gombore IB was marked by a rather forested mountain environment (Bonnefille et al., 2018). The taxonomic composition of the fauna did not significantly differ between the two sites, indicating a preference for open habitats (Geraads et al., 2004, 2022). Given the known faunal assemblages and paleoenvironmental differences between the two layers, our aim is to determine if and how this is reflected in the stable carbon and oxygen isotope composition of the fauna tooth enamel. Accordingly, the objectives of this paper are to (1) provide information on the diet and habitat of the fossil fauna; (2) assess whether the different local vegetation (grassland and forest) influenced the dietary selection of Pleistocene animals; (3) refine the paleoecological characteristics of both Early Acheulean archaeological levels; and (4) evaluate the outcome of different approaches in paleoenvironmental reconstructions.
Archaeological background
The Garba IVD and Gombore IB archaeological layers are part of the multistratified Garba IV and Gombore I sites within the Melka Kunture deposits (8° 42 N, 38° 36 E). They are located approximately 50 km southwest of Addis Ababa, on the western shoulder of the Main Ethiopian Rift, between 2000 and 2200 m a.s.l. (Fig. 1). The Ethiopian plateau is part of a wide region of highly anomalous topography (African Superswell) resulting from strong uplift during the Tertiary period at approximately 30 Ma (Pik et al., 2003; Kieffer et al., 2004; Gani et al., 2007; Corti, 2009). Furthermore, since the Early Pleistocene, the vegetation of Melka Kunture has been of the Afromontane complex, currently developing at 1800–3000 m a.s.l. (Bonnefille et al., 2018). Thus, the altitude of the sites did not change much since their formation compared to the present time.
Garba IVD and Gombore IB are located on the right bank of the Upper Awash River, at a short geographic and stratigraphic distance from each other (Chavaillon and Piperno, 2004; Piperno et al., 2009; Mussi et al., 2022, 2023). Both levels yielded a high-density assemblage of Early Acheulean lithic artifacts, faunal remains, and unworked pebbles (Gallotti, 2013; Gallotti and Mussi, 2017, 2018; Mussi et al., 2022). 40Ar/39Ar analysis formerly suggested an age of ~1.6 Ma for Garba IVD, which stratigraphically lies on the “Grazia tuff” (<1.719 ± 0.199 Ma). Gombore IB had been estimated to be close in age based on geo-stratigraphic correlations (Raynal and Kieffer, 2004). However, recent magnetostratigraphic analyses established an older chronology, assessing Garba IVD at 1.95 Ma and Gombore IB at 1.66 Ma. Thus, level D of Garba IV contains the earliest Acheulean technocomplex discovered so far (Perini et al., 2021).
Paleontological background
The fauna recovered from Garba IVD is dominated by large hippos (Hippopotamus cf. amphibius), grazing bovids (mostly Alcelaphini: Connochaetes gentryi leptoceras, Damaliscus strepsiceras, and Antilopini, with a Gazella close to G. rufifrons, and Antidorcas), and equids (Hipparion s.l., and Equus). The suids include Kolpochoerus and Metridiochoerus. The baboon Theropithecus, a rare genus at Melka Kunture, is represented by a single specimen (Geraads et al., 2004). The same open country alcelaphins dominate the mammalian collection of both sites; the fauna from Gombore IB includes three species of equids, two species of suids, and two hippos (H. cf. amphibius, and a dwarf hippo, resembling H. cf. aethiopicus) (Table 1). Both faunal assemblages point to a preference for open habitats (Geraads et al., 2004, 2022; Mussi et al., in press). A left distal humerus (Gombore IB-7594) attributed to Homo cf. erectus was found in situ at Gombore IB (Di Vincenzo et al., 2015). An H. erectus child mandible was also discovered at Garba IV in level E, associated with an Oldowan technocomplex. At ~2 Ma, it predates the overlying level Garba IVD (Le Cabec et al., 2021; Perini et al., 2021).
Palaeobotanical data
The pollen samples collected at Garba IVD (samples G133 and G393 in Bonnefille et al., 2018) record extensive development of high-elevation grasslands, evidenced by a high percentage of grass pollen (Plantago and various species of Asteraceae) and the shrub Myrsine africana. The assemblages also include some Podocarpus and Dodonaea viscosa pollen, pointing to limited wooded vegetation either locally or at a distance from the site since these pollen types are known to be easily dispersed. In contrast, the pollen sample from Gombore IB (samples Gomb IB in Bonnefille et al., 2018) records a high amount of Juniperus (>20%) and more taxa of present-day mountain forests (such as Podocarpus, Olea, and Myrica). As Juniperus disperses pollen not far from the tree, a juniper-dominated forest was developing nearby (a few hundred meters). The finding of a fossilized forest climber (liana) (Chavaillon and Koeniguer, 1970) also confirms this environmental interpretation. However, the large percentage of grass pollen of Poaceae (>63%) attests that grazing land was also available. The open vegetation was interrupted by the forest, probably near the river (Fig. 2) (Bonnefille et al., 2018).
Stable carbon and oxygen isotope analysis of tooth enamel
The analysis of stable carbon and oxygen isotopic abundances in tooth enamel provides direct evidence of the dietary patterns, ecology, and habitat since the isotopic signal is related to the plants consumed and the water ingested during the formation of the analyzed tissue. Tooth enamel is the most suitable fossilized material for preserving stable isotopic signatures since it is almost entirely inorganic (hydroxyapatite) and less susceptible to alteration due to diagenesis (Wang and Cerling, 1994; Schoeninger et al., 2003). The stable isotopic results are typically expressed with the following standard δ-notation: X = [(Rsample / Rstandard) − 1] ∗ 1000, where X is referred to as δ13C and δ18O values and R represents 13C/12C or 18O/16O, respectively.
The carbon isotope ratio in tooth enamel is an average of the diet related to the plants eaten by the animals during the period of enamel mineralization. Terrestrial plants are generally divided into C3 and C4 plants according to their different photosynthesis pathways, leading to different carbon isotopic fractionation during CO2 fixation processes (Edwards and Walker, 1983). The C3 photosynthetic pathway (Calvin-Benson cycle) occurs in almost all tree and bush species, shrubs, and grasses in humid and shady areas in hot environments and temperate/cold or high-altitude herbaceous monocots (Vogel, 1978; Blondel et al., 2018). The C3 plants have a modal δ13C value of −27‰ (ranging from −35‰ to −22‰). The C4 photosynthetic pathway (Hatch-Slack cycle) occurs in grasses, sedges, and non-grassy herbaceous typical of drier and warmer environments and some shrubs in very dry environments (e.g., Amaranthaceae). The C4 plants have δ13C values ranging from −19‰ to −9‰, showing a modal value of −13‰ (Smith and Epstein, 1971; O’Leary, 1988). The abundance of C4 plants generally suggests a relatively open grassy environment, whereas C3 plants point to more woody vegetation under more humid climatic conditions (Farquhar et al., 1989; Cerling and Harris, 1999).
The oxygen isotope composition in mammalian tooth enamel reflects the isotopic composition of the body water, which is determined by the drinking water and ingested food. Mammals are generally classified into two groups: evaporation sensitive (ES) and evaporation insensitive (EI). ES taxa (e.g., giraffids, oryx, dik-dik, Grant’s gazelle, and buffalo) are those that ingest evaporated waters, showing a significant increase in δ18O values between tooth enamel and meteoric water as a response to increasing aridity. In contrast, EI taxa (e.g., hippopotamus, bush pig, elephant, rhinoceros, warthog, zebra, impala, and baboon) ingest relatively unevaporated waters and show a strong correlation between enamel and meteoric water δ18O values (Levin et al., 2006).
Due to evaporation, the δ18O values in plant leaves are higher than those in meteoric water. This means that herbivores that get most of their water from consumed leaves have higher oxygen isotopic values than those drinking abundant meteoric water (Kohn, 1996; Kohn et al., 1998), allowing us to distinguish browsers from grazers. Thus, δ18O values will enable us to determine the so-called “obligate drinkers”, who obtain water from the rivers or lakes (δ18O of meteoric water), from the other “non-obligate drinkers” that get most of their water from leaves, showing higher δ18O values. The oxygen isotopic composition can also be affected by habitat differences: for semiaquatic mammals such as hippos, the δ18O values are lower compared to those of terrestrial herbivores (Bocherens et al., 1996; Clementz and Koch, 2001; Clementz et al., 2008; Harris et al., 2008). Furthermore, many other aspects can play a relevant role in the variation in oxygen isotope composition, such as precipitation, continentality, seasonality, latitude, and altitude (Pederzani and Britton, 2019).
Materials and methods
We analyzed the stable carbon and oxygen isotopic compositions of 18 fossil teeth (5 enamel samples from Garba IVD (Fig. 3) and 13 enamel samples from Gombore IB) (Fig. 4). We further added 9 samples published by Bocherens et al. (1996) (6 samples from Garba IVD and 3 samples from Gombore IB). Overall, we discuss 27 enamel samples (Table 2) from fossil teeth taxonomically identified by one of us (Geraads et al., 2004, 2022). The specimens include Artiodactyla (Hippopotamidae, Bovidae, Suidae) and Perissodactyla (Equidae) (Table S1). The enamel samples were collected in November 2019 at the National Museum of Ethiopia (Addis Ababa), where the paleontological collection is stored. Each specimen is labeled with the acronym of the archaeological area (MLK = Melka Kunture), followed by a progressive number (i.e., MLK 15, MLK 16, etc.). Briefly, 12–15 mg of enamel was pretreated with NaOCl followed by buffer acetic acid-calcium acetate; then, 2.5–3 mg of powdered enamel was analyzed at the Biogeology Research Group (Department of Geosciences, University of Tübingen) using a MultiFlow-Geo interface with the Elementar IsoPrime 100 IRMS (Supplementary Text A and B).
Results
The δ 13C and δ 18O values from Garba IVD
The δ13C values of tooth enamel samples from Garba IVD range from −4.7 ‰ to + 2.7 ‰, covering the range of mixed C3-C4 and C4 plant consumers (Table S1) (Fig. 5). Notably, the δ13C values of hippopotamids (n = 8) varied from −4.7 ‰ to + 2.6 ‰ (median = +0.4 ‰), indicating a C4 diet. Only a single δ13C value (−4.7 ‰) was lower compared with the other values, indicating a mixed C3-C4 diet for this hippo. A bovid (n = 1), equid (n = 1), and suid (n = 1) with δ13C values of + 1.9 ‰, + 2.7 ‰, and + 0.6 ‰, respectively, consumed C4 plants. The δ18O values ranged from + 21.2 ‰ to + 31.7 ‰. The δ18O values were lower for the hippos (n = 8; median = + 24.9 ‰) than for the fully terrestrial animals such as a suid (n = 1; + 25.9 ‰), equid (n = 1; + 30.9 ‰), and bovid (n = 1; + 31.7 ‰), reflecting distinct physiologies, behaviors, and habitats (Mann-Whitney U-test, p = 0.0294).
The δ 13C and δ 18O values from Gombore IB
At Gombore IB, the δ13C values of tooth enamel ranged from −2.4 ‰ to + 3.4 ‰, suggesting a pure C4 diet for herbivores (Table S1) (Fig. 6). The hippopotamid (n = 6) δ13C values ranged from −1.2 ‰ to + 0.8 ‰ (median = −0.3 ‰), and the bovids (n = 5) had a δ13C median of +2.9 ‰, with δ13C values ranging from −0.6 ‰ to + 3.4 ‰. The δ13C values of suids (n = 4) varied from −2.4 ‰ to + 1.3 ‰ (median = + 0.3 ‰), whereas the δ13C value of the single equid sample (Hipparion) was + 0.1 ‰. The δ18O values for all analyzed mammals ranged from + 19.2 ‰ to + 33.1 ‰. As for the Garba IVD, the hippopotamids had lower δ18O values (n = 6; median = + 23.6 ‰), whereas those of bovids (n = 5; median = + 27.7 ‰), equid (n = 1; + 26.5 ‰), and suids (n = 4; median = + 27.5 ‰) were higher, consistent with the expected difference between aquatic and terrestrial habitats (Mann-Whitney U-test, p = 0.0169).
Discussion
Dietary and paleoenvironmental reconstruction
The carbon and oxygen isotopic results reflect ecological conditions based on faunal lifestyles and preferred habitats. This is evidenced by the δ18O values from Garba IVD (1.95 Ma) and Gombore IB (1.66 Ma), which discriminate the taxa according to their semiaquatic or terrestrial habitats. The δ13C values from both sites/levels suggest that all the analyzed faunal taxa fed mostly on C4 plants. Only a hippo δ13C value from Garba IVD indicates a mixed C3-C4 isotopic signal that could be interpreted as consuming C3 cool-season grass, C3 browse, including fruits, or a mix of C3 grass and C3 browse. Indeed, Melka Kunture is located at the elevation where grasslands would include mostly C4 grasses but also some C3 grasses that become dominant above 2000 m of elevation (Tieszen et al., 1979).
The isotopic results are consistent with the faunal taxonomy that suggests environments characterized by open grasslands (Geraads et al., 2022). Our carbon isotopic data also agree with the palynological results at Garba IVD, where extended mountain grasslands are documented. In contrast, isotopic results do not totally agree with the paleoenvironmental reconstruction by fossil pollen at Gombore IB, where the open landscape was interrupted by forests and bushy woodland of which the fossil fauna and isotopic analyses provide no evidence. The possibility that the C4 isotopic signal could indicate the movement of fossil fauna from lower to higher elevation grasslands and woodlands is in contrast with the development of endemic animal species and subspecies, such as Damaliscus strepsiceras and Connochaetes gentryi leptoceras, pointing to some degree of isolation of the Ethiopian highlands (Mussi et al., in press). Another possibility is that the sample does not depict the whole faunal signal or that taxa relying more on C3 resources were not sampled.
A distinct environment at Garba IVD and Gombore IB is not surprising, given the different ages. The wet-dry climate variability on the timescale of 20,000 years of processional monsoon cycles could easily cause a significant change in vegetation cover (Bonnefille and Riollet, 1988). We emphasize that at Melka Kunture, even in the relatively open landscape of Garba IVD, grassland and wooded areas were always available in various percentages at a short distance. The animals were likely to be selective when feeding. Their diet was likely based on preferred plants rather than immediately available vegetation. Modern hippos are notably known to regularly travel some kilometers to forage at night on preferred grass spots whenever they are not available close to the body of water where they spend the daytime (Eltringham, 1999). At Melka Kunture, there is direct evidence of a hippo trail produced by H. cf. amphibius, which predates 0.7 Ma (Altamura et al., 2017).
When reconstructing the paleoenvironment, stable isotope and pollen analyses are better understood as complementary proxies. The stable isotope composition of the tooth enamel does not record diet at the time of death of the individuals but over a long period (several months to years) or a shorter period, depending on the sampling strategies. They are also related to each individual’s feeding strategies and behavior, including the selection of the preferred vegetation. Fossil pollen analysis registers local plants and wind-pollinated plants located at some distance from the deposit. Thus, isotopes and pollen record different temporal and spatial aspects.
The δ 13C and δ 18O comparison from tooth enamel in eastern Africa
We selected 284 isotopic results (δ13C and δ18O values) from the fauna tooth enamel of eastern African archaeological and paleontological areas of the Early Pleistocene age (Olduvai Gorge, and several sites of the Lake Turkana Basin) to compare our results and interpretations from a broader regional perspective. Overall, we discuss 308 isotopic results, including data from Melka Kunture. The selected archaeological sites are located at medium and low elevations, between ~1400 and 336 m a.s.l., whereas Melka Kunture is the only site at ~2000 m a.s.l. The isotopic dataset includes four faunal family groups: Hippopotamidae, Bovidae, Equidae, and Suidae. Only isotopic values from specimens dated between ~2.0–1.95 Ma and ~1.6 Ma were selected (Table S3).
Hippopotamidae
The fossil hippopotamids (n = 59) from Melka Kunture, Lake Turkana Basin, and Olduvai Gorge belong to Hippopotamus cf. amphibius, Hippopotamus gorgops, aff. Hippopotamus aethiopicus, aff. Hippopotamus karumensis, and other hippopotamids (Fig. 7). The median δ13C value is −0.3 ‰ with minimum and maximum values of −7.2 ‰ and + 2.6 ‰, respectively. The carbon isotopic data suggest that the hippopotamids had a C4-dominated diet. However, some δ13C values from Shungura Formation, within the Lake Turkana Basin, and Melka Kunture point to a mixed C3-C4 diet. This is consistent with other isotopic studies (Morgan et al., 1994; Bocherens et al., 1996; Zazzo et al., 2000; Cerling et al., 2003; Boisserie et al., 2005; Levin et al., 2008; Souron et al., 2012), showing opportunistic feeding strategies for hippos, which sampled the available vegetation within long and short distances from their aquatic shelter. The δ18O values show a median of + 26.5 ‰ with a range from + 19.2 ‰ to + 31 ‰ (Bocherens et al., 1996; Harris et al., 2008; van der Merwe, 2013; Ascari et al., 2018; Rivals et al., 2018; Uno et al., 2018; Negash et al., 2020).
We note that the hippopotamids from Melka Kunture show lower δ18O values (median = + 24.5 ‰) than those of mid- and low-altitude sites (median = + 27 ‰) (t-test, p = 0.0168). However, the δ18O median of hippos from Shungura Formation (Lake Turkana Basin) is + 23.9 ‰ which is lower than the δ18O median of the same specimens from Upper Burgi Member (+ 27 ‰) (Lake Turkana Basin) and those from Olduvai Gorge (+ 27.1 ‰). This could be explained by the different states of evaporation of the water in which the animals shelter. In contrast, we explain the lower δ18O values from Melka Kunture with the altitude effect. The water condensation that continues throughout a storm, along a mountain slope, or across a continent, select heavier isotopes, and the remaining vapor becomes depleted in heavy isotopes. Consequently, δ18O values are lower in high-altitude precipitation and higher in low-altitude precipitation (Dansgaard, 1964; Gat, 2000; Pederzani and Britton, 2019). This could also have implications for the past temperature, indicating colder climatic conditions in the mountain environment at Melka Kunture. Currently, in Ethiopia, the “big rains” (June–September) are sourced by moist south-westerlies and westerlies from the Atlantic Ocean, whereas the shorter rainy season (March–May) is associated with the southeastern monsoon from the Indian Ocean (Griffiths, 1972; Gamachu, 1977; Vizy and Cook, 2003; Bedaso and Wu, 2021). This is confirmed by isotopic data and model simulations indicating that δ18O in eastern African rainfall is closely related to the Indian Ocean Zonal Mode (Vuille et al., 2005). The maximum rainfall at Melka Kunture is recorded during the long rainy season, although some variability exists. The Boneja meteorological station (20 km north of Melka Kunture) recorded a mean annual rainfall of 860 mm. During 1974–2012, a wide rainfall variability was recorded, with a minimum value of 388 mm and a maximum of 1419 mm (Bonnefille et al., 2018). The mean maximum temperature is 17.2 °C, and the mean minimum is 8 °C (meteorological station from Addis Ababa) (Fekadu, 2012). Therefore, lower δ18O values provided in this study confirm the high-elevation environment attested by the pollen study (Bonnefille et al., 2018).
Bovidae
This group comprises several bovids (n = 158) of Alcelaphini, Antilopini, Bovini, Hippotragini, Reduncini, Tragelaphini, and other bovids from Melka Kunture, Lake Turkana Basin, and Olduvai (Fig. 8). Overall, the δ13C values (median = + 0.5 ‰) suggest that the diverse tribes of bovids had a wide range of feeding strategies, including a significant C4 component in their diet but also feeding on mixed C3-C4 resources. Some bovids from Shungura Formation (Lake Turkana Basin) and Olduvai Gorge show lower δ13C values, indicating a mixed C3-C4 diet (Bocherens et al., 1996; van der Merwe, 2013; Ascari et al., 2018; Rivals et al., 2018; Uno et al., 2018; Negash et al., 2020). The δ18O values record a wide range, reflecting the different drinking habits of these bovid tribes.
Equidae
The fossil equids (n = 33) from Melka Kunture and Olduvai Gorge are Equus oldowayensis, Hipparion, and other equids (Fig. 9). The δ13C values range from −1.8 ‰ to + 3 ‰ (median = + 0.9 ‰), indicating a dominant C4 diet. The δ18O values are homogeneous with a median value of + 30.4 ‰ and values ranging from + 25.3 ‰ to + 31.9 ‰ (Bocherens et al., 1996; van der Merwe, 2013; Rivals et al., 2018; Uno et al., 2018).
Suidae
The suid group (n = 61) consists of Kolpochoerus, Kolpochoerus limnetes, Kolpochoerus majus, Kolpochoerus cf. olduvaiensis, Kolpochoerus paiceae, Metridiochoerus, Metridiochoerus compactus, Notochoerus, Phacochoerus modestus, and other suids from Melka Kunture, Lake Turkana Basin, and Olduvai Gorge (Fig. 10). The δ13C values indicate diets dominated by C4 plants for all genera, ranging from −3.1 ‰ to + 1.5 ‰ (median = −0.3 ‰). In contrast, only some lower δ13C values indicate a mixed C3-C4 feeding strategy. The δ18O values have a median of + 29.4 ‰, ranging from + 23.6 ‰ to + 37.1 ‰ (van der Merwe, 2013; Ascari et al., 2018; Rivals et al., 2018; Uno et al., 2018; Negash et al., 2020).
Overall, the isotopic comparisons indicate that Hippopotamidae, Bovidae, Equidae, and Suidae were grazing and fed primarily on C4 plants, including a mix of C3-C4 resources. Accordingly, C4 plants were an important part of the mammalian diet, and the ungulate’s feeding strategies were overall not affected by variations linked to differences at low, medium, and high altitudes. Moreover, the oxygen isotopic data of Melka Kunture’s hippos point to a cooler temperature than elsewhere at lower elevations.
Conclusions
The analysis of stable isotopes on faunal tooth enamel from the Early Acheulean layers of Garba IVD (1.95 Ma) and Gombore IB (1.66 Ma) was used to reconstruct the diet and habitat of the Pleistocene fauna. The carbon isotopic data indicate a C4-dominated diet for all the analyzed taxa. The oxygen isotopic data show a clear distinction between semiaquatic and terrestrial habitats. Our isotopic results are consistent with the faunal analysis, indicating an extended C4 landscape in the vegetation. However, at Garba IVD, pollen documents a mountain grassland, whereas a relatively forested environment is also recorded at Gombore IB. This complementary information helps track the feeding strategies of mammals and the paleoenvironment. The paleovegetation changed over time, whereas isotopic studies of the fossil fauna showed more or less constant feeding habits on C4 plants.
Comparisons with isotopic results from eastern African sites do not allow to identify variations in feeding strategies at high, medium, and low altitudes, even though at Melka Kunture is recorded the Dry evergreen Afromontane Forest and grassland complex, a distinct mountain vegetation that does not include any of the species of the lowland savannas. The vegetation changed over approximately 300,000 years, between 1.95 Ma (Garba IVD) and 1.66 Ma (Gombore IB), whereas the dietary strategies of the fauna were scarcely modified. This has implications for environmental reconstructions based exclusively on fauna isotopic studies.
Reconstructing the environment using more than a single method of analysis produces sounder results, which is especially important if the development of grasslands and open landscapes is used as a proxy for aridification. At Melka Kunture, H. erectus definitely made Early Acheulean technocomplexes in mixed upland habitats that were quite different from the lowland savanna ones.
Data availability
Not applicable.
Code availability
Not applicable.
References
Altamura F, Melis RT, Mussi M (2017) A Middle Pleistocene hippo tracksite at Gombore II-2 (Melka Kunture, Upper Awash, Ethiopia). Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 470:122–131. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.palaeo.2017.01.022
Ascari SH, Njau JK, Sauer PE, Polly PD, Peng Y (2018) Fossil herbivores and crocodiles as paleoclimatic indicators of environmental shifts from Bed I and Bed II times of the Olduvai Gorge, Tanzania. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 511:550–557. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.palaeo.2018.09.021
Bedaso Z, Wu S (2021) Linking precipitation and groundwater isotopes in Ethiopia – implications from local meteoric water lines and isoscapes. Journal of Hydrology 596:126074. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2021.126074
Blondel C, Rowan J, Merceron G, Bibi F, Negash E, Barr WA, Boisserie J-R (2018) Feeding ecology of Tragelaphini (Bovidae) from Shungura Formation, Omo Valley, Ethiopia: contribution of dental wear analyses. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 496:103–120. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.palaeo.2018.01.027
Bocherens H, Koch PL, Mariotti A, Geraads D, Jaeger J-J (1996) Isotopic biogeochemistry (13C, 18O) of mammalian enamel from African Pleistocene hominid sites. Palaios 11:306–318. https://doi.org/10.2307/3515241
Boisserie JR, Zazzo A, Merceron G, Blondel C, Vignaud P, Likius A, Mackaye HT, Brunet M (2005) Diets of modern and late Miocene hippopotamids: evidence from carbon isotope composition and micro-wear of tooth enamel. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 221:153–174. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.palaeo.2005.02.010
Bonnefille R, Riollet G (1988) The Kashiru pollen sequence (Burundi). Palaeoclimatic implications for the last 40,000 yr B.P. in Tropical Africa. Quaternary Research 30:19–35
Bonnefille R, Melis RT, Mussi M (2018) Variability in the mountain environment at Melka Kunture Archaeological Site, Ethiopia, during the Early Pleistocene (~1.7 Ma) and the Mid-Pleistocene transition (0.9–0.6 Ma). In: Gallotti R, Mussi M (eds) The emergence of the Acheulean in East Africa and beyond. Contributions in honor of Jean Chavaillon. Springer, London, pp 93–114. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-75985-2_5
Cerling TE, Harris JM (1999) Carbon isotope fractionation between diet and bioapatite in ungulate mammals and implications for ecological and paleoecological studies. Oecologia 120:347–363. https://doi.org/10.1007/s004420050868
Cerling TE, Harris JM, Leakey MG (2003) Isotope paleoecology of the Nawata and Nachukui Formations at Lothagam, Turkana Basin, Kenya. In: Leakey MG, Harris JM (eds) Lothagam: the dawn of humanity in Eastern Africa. Columbia University Press, New York, pp 605–624
Chavaillon J, Koeniguer J-C (1970) Découverte d’un fragment de liane dans le sol oldowayen de Melka Konturé (Ethiopie). Comptes Rendus de l’Académie des Sciences, Paris, D 270:1969–1972
Chavaillon, J., Piperno, M., 2004. Studies on the Early Paleolithic site of Melka Kunture, Ethiopia, Origines, Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protostoria, Florence.
Clark JD (1987) Transitions: Homo erectus and the Acheulian: the Ethiopian sites of Gadeb and the Middle Awash. Journal of Human Evolution 16:809–826
Clark JD, Kurashina H (1979) Hominid occupation of the east-central highlands of Ethiopia in the Plio-Pleistocene. Nature 282:33–39
Clementz MT, Koch PL (2001) Differentiating aquatic mammal habitat and foraging ecology with stable isotopes in tooth enamel. Oecologia 129:461–472. https://doi.org/10.1007/s004420100745
Clementz MT, Holroyd PA, Koch PL (2008) Identifying aquatic habits of herbivorous mammals through stable isotope analysis. Palaios 23(9):574–585. https://doi.org/10.2110/palo.2007.p07-054r
Corti G (2009) Continental rift evolution: from rift initiation to incipient break-up in the Main Ethiopian Rift, East Africa. Earth-Science Reviews 96:1–53. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.earscirev.2009.06.005
Dansgaard W (1964) Stable isotopes in precipitation. Tellus 16:436–468
Di Vincenzo F, Rodriguez L, Carretero JM, Collina C, Geraads D, Piperno M, Manzi G (2015) The massive fossil humerus from the Oldowan horizon of Gombore I, Melka Kunture (Ethiopia, > 1.39 Ma). Quaternary Science Reviews 122:207–221. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.quascirev.2015.05.014
Edwards G, Walker DA (1983) C3, C4: mechanisms, and cellular and environmental regulation, of photosynthesis, vol 6 No.11. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford
Eltringham SK (1999) The Hippos. Academic Press, London
Farquhar GD, Ehleringer JR, Hubick KT (1989) Carbon isotope discrimination and photosynthesis. Annual Review of Plant Biology 40:503–537. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.pp.40.060189.002443
Fekadu M (2012) Floristic composition and diversity analysis of vegetation of Awash Melka Kunture prehistoric archaeological site, Ethiopia. Master’s thesis,. Addis Ababa University
Gallotti R (2013) An older origin for the Acheulean at Melka Kunture (Upper Awash, Ethiopia): techno-economic behaviors at Garba IVD. Journal of Human Evolution 65:594–620. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhevol.2013.07.001
Gallotti R, Mussi M (2017) Two Acheuleans, two humankind: from 1.5 to 0.85 Ma at Melka Kunture (Upper Awash, Ethiopian highlands). Journal of Archaeological Sciences 95:1–46. https://doi.org/10.4436/JASS.95001
Gallotti R, Mussi M (2018) Before, during, and after the early Acheulean at Melka Kunture (Upper Awash, Ethiopia): a techno-economic comparative analysis. In: Gallotti R, Mussi M (eds) The Emergence of the Acheulean in East Africa and Beyond. Contributions in honor of Jean Chavaillon. Springer, London, pp 53–92. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-75985-2_4
Gamachu, D., 1977. Aspects of climate and water budget in Ethiopia, 71 pp., Addis Ababa Univ. Press, Addis Ababa.
Gani ND, Abdelsalam MG, Gani MR (2007) Blue Nile incision on the Ethiopian Plateau: pulsed plateau growth, Pliocene uplift, and hominin evolution. GSA Today 17:4–11
Gat JR (2000) Atmospheric water balance - the isotopic perspective. Hydrological Processes 14(8):1357–1369. https://doi.org/10.1002/1099-1085(20000615)14:8<1357::AIDHYP986>3.0.CO;2-7
Geraads, D., Eisenmann, V., Petter, G., 2004. The large mammal fauna of the Oldowan sites of Melka Kunture, in: Chavaillon, J., Piperno, M., (Eds.), Studies on the Early Paleolithic site of Melka Kunture, Ethiopia, Origines, Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protostoria, Firenze, pp. 169-192.
Geraads, D., Gallotti, R., Raynal, J.-P., Bonnefille, R., Mussi, M., 2022. Melka Kunture, Ethiopia: Early Pleistocene faunas of the Ethiopian highlands, in: Reynolds, S.C., Bobe, R., (Eds.), African paleoecology and human evolution, Cambridge University Press & Assessment, 978-1-107-07403-3.
Griffiths, J.F., 1972. Climates of Africa. 604 pp., Elsevier, Amsterdam.
Harris JM, Cerling TE, Leakey MG, Passey BH (2008) Stable isotope ecology of fossil hippopotamids from the Lake Turkana Basin of East Africa. Journal of Zoology 275:323–331. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-7998.2008.00444.x
Hovers E, Gossa T, Asrat A, Niespolo EM, Resom A, Renne PR, Ekshtain R, Herlinger G, Ketema N, Martínez-Navarro B (2021) The expansion of the Acheulian to the Southeastern Ethiopian Highlands: Insights from the new early Pleistocene site-complex of Melka Wakena. Quat Sci Rev 253:106763. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.quascirev.2020.106763
Kieffer B, Arndt N, Lapierre H, Bastien F, Bosch D, Pecher A, Yirgu G, Ayalew D, Weis D, Jerram DA, Keller F, Meugniot C (2004) Flood and shield basalts from ethiopia: magmas from the African superswell. J Petrol 45:793–834. https://doi.org/10.1093/petrology/egg112
Kohn MJ (1996) Predicting animal 18O: accounting for diet and physiological adaptation. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 60:4811–4829. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0016-7037(96)00240-2
Kohn MJ, Schoeninger MJ, Valley JW (1998) Variability in oxygen isotope compositions of herbivore teeth. Chemical Geology 152:97–112
Le Cabec A, Colard T, Charabidze D, Chaussain C, Di Carlo G, Gaudzinski-Windheuser S, Hublin J-J, Melis RT, Pioli L, Ramirez-Rozzi F, Mussi M (2021) Insights into the palaeobiology of an early Homo infant: multidisciplinary investigation of the GAR IVE hemi-mandible. Scientific Reports, Melka Kunture, Ethiopia. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-02462-1
Levin, N.E., Cerling, T.E., Passey, B.H., Harris, J.M., Ehleringer, J.R., 2006 A stable isotope aridity index for terrestrial environments. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science, 11201-11205, www.pnas.orgcgi 10.1073pnas.0604719103.
Levin NE, Simpson SW, Quade J, Cerling TE, Frost SR (2008) Herbivore enamel carbon isotopic composition and the environmental context of Ardipithecus at Gona, Ethiopia. In: Wynn JG (ed) Quade, J. The Geology of Early Humans in the Horn of Africa, Geological Society of America, pp 215–234. https://doi.org/10.1130/2008.2446(10)
Morgan ME, Kingston JD, Marino BD (1994) Carbon isotopic evidence for the emergence of C4 plants in the Neogene from Pakistan and Kenya. Nature 367:162–165. https://doi.org/10.1038/367162a0
Mussi M, Altamura F, Bonnefille R, De Rita D, Melis RT (2016) The environment of the Ethiopian highlands at the Mid Transition: fauna, flora, and hominins in the 850-700 ka sequence at Gombore II (Melka Kunture). Quaternary Science Reviews 149:259–268. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.quascirev.2016.07.033
Mussi M, Méndez-Quintas E, Panera J, Altamura F, Di Bianco L, Bonnefille R, Briatico G, Brunelli E, Geraads D, Mutri G, Piarulli F, Rubio Jara S, Ruta G, Sánchez-Dehesa Galán S, Serodio Domínguez A, Melis RT (2022) Une vue d’ensemble sur Melka Kunture, grand complexe de sites pléistocènes dans la vallée supérieure de l’Awash (Ethiopie). L’Anthropologie. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.anthro.2022.102999
Mussi, M., Méndez-Quintas, E., Panera, J., Altamura, F., Di Bianco, L., Briatico, G., Mutri, G., Piarulli, F., Rubio Jara, S., Ruta, G., Sánchez-Dehesa Galán, S., Serodio Domínguez, A., Melis, R.T., 2023. Melka Kunture (Alto Awash, Etiopía) entre 2.000.000 y 5.000 años. Salduie, 26754/ojs_salduie/sald.202318553.
Mussi, M., Altamura, F., Di Bianco, L., Bonnefille, R., Gaudzinski-Windheuser, S., Geraads, D., Melis, R.T., Panera, J., Piarulli, F., Pioli, L., Ruta, G., Sánchez-Dehesa Galán, S., Méndez-Quintas, E., in press. After the emergence of the Acheulean at Melka Kunture (Upper Awash, Ethiopia): from Gombore IB (1.6 Ma) to Gombore Ig (1.4 Ma), Gombore Id (1.3 Ma) and Gombore II OAM Test Pit C (1.2 Ma). Quaternary International, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.quaint.2021.02.031.
Negash EW, Alemseged Z, Bobe R, Grine F, Sponheimer M, Wynn JG (2020) Dietary trends in herbivores from Shungura Formation, southwestern Ethiopia. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 1-6. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2006982117
O’Leary MH (1988) Carbon isotopes in photosynthesis. BioScience 38:328–336. https://doi.org/10.2307/1310735
Pederzani S, Britton K (2019) Oxygen isotopes in bioarchaeology: principles and applications, challenges and opportunities. Earth-Science Reviews 188:77–107. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.earscirev.2018.11.005
Perini S, Muttoni G, Monesi E, Melis RT, Mussi M (2021) Magnetochronology and age models of deposition of the Melka Kunture stratigraphic sequence (Upper Awash, Ethiopia) and age assessments of the main archeological levels therein contained. Quaternary Science Reviews 274:107259. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.quascirev.2021.107259
Pik R, Marty B, Carignan J, Lavé J (2003) Stability of the Upper Nile drainage network (Ethiopia) deduced from (U–Th)/He thermochronometry: implications for uplift and erosion of the Afar plume dome. Earth and Planetary Science Letters 215:73–88. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0012-821X(03)00457-6
Piperno M, Collina C, Gallotti R, Raynal J-P, Kieffer G, Le Bourdonnec F-X, Poupeau G, Geraads D (2009) Obsidian exploitation and utilization during the Oldowan at Melka Kunture (Ethiopia). In: Hovers E, Braun DR (eds) Interdisciplinary Approaches to the Oldowan. Springer, Dordrecht, pp 111–128. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4020-9060-8_10
Raynal, J.P., Kieffer, G., 2004. Lithology, dynamism, and volcanic successions at Melka Kunture (Upper Awash, Ethiopia), in: Chavaillon, J., Piperno, M., (Eds.), Studies on the Early Paleolithic site of Melka Kunture, Ethiopia, Origines, Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protostoria, Firenze, pp. 111-135.
Rivals F, Uno KT, Bibi F, Pante MC, Njau J, de la Torre I (2018) Dietary traits of the ungulates from the HWK EE site at Olduvai Gorge (Tanzania): diachronic changes and seasonality. Journal of Human Evolution 120:203–214. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhevol.2017.08.011
Schoeninger MJ, Hallin K, Reeser H, Valley JW, Fournelle J (2003) Isotopic alteration of mammalian tooth enamel. International Journal of Osteoarchaeology 13:11–19. https://doi.org/10.1002/oa.653
Smith BN, Epstein S (1971) Two categories of 13C/12C ratios for higher plants. Plant Physiology 47:380–384. https://doi.org/10.1104/pp.47.3.380
Souron A, Balasse M, Boisserie JR (2012) Intra-tooth isotopic profiles of canines from extant Hippopotamus amphibius and late Pliocene hippopotamids (Shungura Formation, Ethiopia): insights into the seasonality of diet and climate. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 342-343:97–110. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.palaeo.2012.05.007
Tieszen LL, Senyimba MM, Imbamba SK, Troughton JH (1979) The distribution of C3 and C4 grasses and carbon isotope discrimination along an altitudinal and moisture gradient in Kenya. Oecologia 37:337–350
Uno KT, Rivals F, Bibi F, Pante M, Njau J, de la Torre I (2018) Large mammal diets and paleoecology across the Oldowan-Acheulean transition at Olduvai Gorge, Tanzania from stable isotope and tooth wear analyses. Journal of Human Evolution 1-16. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhevol.2018.01.002
Van der Merwe NJ (2013) Isotopic ecology of fossil fauna from Olduvai Gorge at ca 1.8 Ma, compared with modern fauna. South African Journal of Science 109:11–12. https://doi.org/10.1590/sajs.2013/20130105
Vizy EK, Cook KH (2003) Connections between the summer east African and Indian rainfall regimes. Journal of Geophysical Research 108(D16):4510. https://doi.org/10.1029/2003JD003452
Vogel JC (1978) Isotopic assessment of the dietary habits of ungulates. South African Journal of Science 74:298–301
Vuille M, Werner M, Bradley RS, Chan RY, Keimig F (2005) Stable isotopes in East African precipitation record Indian Ocean zonal mode. Geophysical Research Letters 32:L21705. https://doi.org/10.1029/2005GL023876
Wang Y, Cerling TE (1994) A model of fossil tooth and bone diagenesis: implications for paleodiet reconstruction from stable isotopes. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 107:281–289. https://doi.org/10.1016/0031-0182(94)90100-7
Zazzo A, Bocherens H, Brunet M, Beauvilain A, Billiou D, Mackaye HT, Vignaud P, Mariotti A (2000) Herbivore paleodiet and paleoenvironmental changes in Chad during the Pliocene using stable isotope ratios of tooth enamel carbonate. Paleobiology 26:294–309. https://doi.org/10.1666/0094-8373(2000)026<0294:HPAPCI>2.0.CO;2
Acknowledgements
We thank the Authority for Research and Conservation of Cultural Heritage (ARCCH) and the National Museum of Ethiopia (Addis Ababa) for the permission to sample the paleontological collection and export the enamel samples. We are grateful to the museum staff for helping in many ways and facilitating the lab activities. We acknowledge support from the Open Access Publication Fund of the University of Tübingen (Germany). Finally, we thank the Editor, Joachim Burger, and two anonymous reviewers for their constructive comments that greatly improved the article.
Funding
Open Access funding enabled and organized by Projekt DEAL. This paper is part of the Ph.D. project of G.B. supported by Sapienza Università di Roma (3-year scholarship) in co-tutorship with Eberhard Karls University of Tübingen. This research was further funded by the Deutscher Akademischer Austauschdienst (DAAD) (grant number 57552336) and by Sapienza Università di Roma (grant number 0044296), both awarded to G.B. The stable isotope analyses were funded by the Biogeology Research Group (Department of Geosciences, University of Tübingen).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
GB conceived the ideas and designed the paper with the supervision of MM. GB collected, performed, and elaborated the isotopic data. GB led the writing of the manuscript with the support of MM and the contribution of all the authors (HB, RB, DG). All authors read and approved the manuscript and agree with its submission to the journal.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Ethics approval
Not applicable.
Consent to participate
Not applicable.
Consent for publication
Not applicable.
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Highlights
• The 1.95–1.66 Ma fossil fauna from Garba IVD and Gombore IB was dominated by grazers and fed on C4 plants.
• The 1.95–1.66 Ma Early Acheulean at Melka Kunture occurred in both open and closed environments in an Afromontane vegetation complex.
• The variable local vegetation did not impact on the feeding habits of the fossil fauna.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Briatico, G., Bocherens, H., Bonnefille, R. et al. Isotopic insights into the Early Acheulean (1.95 Ma–1.66 Ma) high-elevation paleoenvironments at Melka Kunture (Upper Awash Valley, Ethiopia). Archaeol Anthropol Sci 15, 184 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12520-023-01879-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12520-023-01879-1