Abstract
“Virtual water,” water needed for crop production, is now being mainstreamed in the water policy world. Relying on virtual water in the form of food imports is increasingly recommended as good policy for water-scarce areas. Virtual water globalizes discussions on water scarcity, ecological sustainability, food security and consumption. Presently the concept is creating much noise in the water and food policy world, which contributes to its politicization. We will argue that the virtual water debate is also a “real water” and food and agricultural policy debate and hence has political effects. Decisions about food strategies and resource allocation play out on the national political economy, benefiting some while harming others. Therefore, a policy choice for virtual water is not politically neutral. “Real␣water” interventions are, likewise, inspired by economic as well as political considerations like control of the countryside, geopolitical strategy, and food sovereignty (independence from international political conditionality and market uncertainties). To illustrate these ideas, we look into case studies of Egypt and the State of Punjab in India. In India, a debate on the merits and demerits of a virtual water strategy is now emerging. In Egypt, which switched to food imports in the early 1970s, a long-standing taboo on debating virtual water is now being relaxed.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Allan, J. A. (1997). “‹Virtual water’, a long term solution for water short Middle Eastern economies?” Occasional paper no. 3. London, UK: School of Oriental and Asian Studies (SOAS), Water Issues Study Group, University of London. Retrieved from http://www.soas.ac.uk/waterissues/occasionalpapers/OCC03.PDF on November 5, 2006
Allan J. A. (1998). Virtual water: A strategic resource. Global solutions to regional deficits. Ground water 36: 545–546
Allan J. A. (2001). The Middle East water question: Hydropolitics and the global economy. London, UK: IB Tauris
Allan J. A. (2002). Water resources in semi-arid regions: Real deficits and economically invisible and politically silent solutions. In A. Turton and R. Henwood (eds.), Hydropolitics in the Developing World. A Southern African Perspective (pp. 23–33). Pretoria, South Africa: African Water Issues Research Unit, Centre for International Political Studies (CIPS), University of Pretoria
Allan J. A. (2003). Virtual water – The water, food, and trade nexus. Useful concept or misleading metaphor? Water International 28: 4–11
Beblawi H., G. Luciani (1987). The Rentier State. London, UK: Croom Helm for Istituto Affari Internazionali, Rome
Beyene, Z. and I. L. Wadley (2004). “Common goods and the common good: Transboundary natural resources, principled cooperation, and the Nile Basin initiative.” In Breslauer Symposium on Natural Resource Issues in Africa. Berkeley, CA: University of California, Berkeley, Center for African Studies
Bhatt, R. (2005). “Focus: Punjab. Interview with Chief Minister Amarinder Singh.” Frontline 22: April 9–22, 2005
Boelens R., M. Zwarteveen, D. Roth (2005). Legal complexity in the analysis of water rights and water resources management. In D. Roth, R. Boelens, M. Zwarteveen (eds.), Liquid Relations. Contested Water rights and Legal Complexity (pp. 1–20). Piscataway, NJ: Rutgers University Press
Brown L. R. (2006). Rescuing a Planet Under Stress and a Civilization in Trouble. New York, NY: W.W. Norton & Co
Bush, R. (2004). “Civil society and the uncivil state: Land tenure reform in Egypt and the crisis of rural livelihoods.” United Nations Research Institute for Social Development Paper 9. Retrieved from http://www.unrisd.org/unrisd/website/document.nsf/(httpPublications)/752BA19D99154FF1C 1256EC300429549?OpenDocument on November 5, 2006
Bush R. (2005). Mubarak’s Legacy for the Poor: Returning Land to Landowners. The Hague, Netherlands: Institute of Social Studies
Cai X., M. Rosegrant (2005). Water management and food production in China and India. Water Policy 7: 643–663
Chapagain A. K., A. Y. Hoekstra, H. H. G. Savenije (2005). Saving Water Through Global Trade. Delft, Netherlands: Unesco-IHE Institute for Water Education
Chief Minister’s Advisory Committee on Agriculture Policy and Restructuring (2002). Agricultural Production Pattern Adjustment Programme in Punjab for Productivity and Growth. A Report Submitted to the Government of Punjab
Craswell, E. T. (2005). “Water and poverty in Southeast Asia. The research agenda from a global perspective.” In Proceedings of the SEARCA Regional Conference on Water Governance and Poverty. Manila, Philippines: The SEAMEO Regional Center for Graduate Study and Research in Agriculture (SEARCA)
Crush J. (1995). The Power of Development. London, UK: Routledge
de Fraiture C., X. Cai, U. Amarasinghe, M. Rosegrant, D. Molden (2004). Does International Cereal Trade Save Water? The Impact of Virtual Water Trade on Global Water Use. Comprehensive Assessment Research Report 4. Colombo, Sri Lanka: International Water Management Institute
Donahue J. M., B. R. Johnston (eds.) (1998). Water, Culture, and Power. Local Struggles in a Global Context. Washington, DC: Island Press
Donahue J. M., B. R. Johnston (eds.) (2001). Water, Culture, and Power. Local Struggles in a Global Context. Washington, DC: Island Press
Fishelson G. (1994). The allocation of marginal value product of water in Israeli agriculture. In J. Isaac, H. Shuval (eds.), Water and Peace in the Middle East (pp. 427–440). Amsterdam, Netherlands: Elsevier Science
Gill, P. P. S. and P. Batth (2004). “SYL: Farmers endorse all steps taken by Amarinder.” The Tribune online edition, August 2, 2004. Retrieved from http://www.tribuneindia.com/2004/20040802/punjab.htm on December 5, 2006
Gilpin R., Gilpin J. M. (2003) Global Political Economy: Understanding the International Economic Order. New Delhi, India: Orient Longman
Hakimian, H. (2003). “Water scarcity and food imports: An empirical investigation of the ‹Virtual Water’ hypothesis in the MENA region.” Occasional Paper No. 46. London, UK: School of Oriental and Asian Studies (SOAS), Water Issues Study Group, University of London. Retrieved from http://www.soas.ac.uk/waterissues/occasionalpapers/OCC46.pdf on November 3, 2006
Hoekstra A. Y. (2003). “Virtual water: An introduction.” In A. Y. Hoekstra (ed.). Virtual Water Trade. Proceedings of the International Expert Meeting on Virtual Water Trade (pp. 13–23). Value of water research report series No. 12. Delft, Netherlands: International Institute for Hydraulics, Engineering, and Environment (IHE)
Hoekstra, A. Y. and P. Q. Hung (2003). “Virtual water trade: a quantification of virtual water flows between nations in relation to international crop trade.” In A. Y. Hoekstra (ed.), Virtual Water Trade. Proceedings of the International Expert Meeting on Virtual Water Trade (pp. 25–47). Value of water research report series No. 12. Delft, Netherlands: International Institute for Hydraulics, Engineering, and Environment (IHE)
Homer-Dixon T. F. (1994). Environmental scarcities and violent conflict: Evidence from cases. International Security 19(1): 5–40
Kumar M. D., O. P. Singh (2005). Virtual water in global food and water policy making: Is there a need for rethinking? Water Resources Management 19: 759–789
Leach M., R. Mearns (1996). Environmental change and policy: challenging received wisdom in Africa. In M. Leach, R. Mearns (eds.), The Lie of the Land: Challenging Received Wisdom on the African Continent (p. 23). London, UK: Villiers Publications
Merrett S. (2003). Virtual water and the Kyoto consensus. A water forum contribution. Water International 28: 540–542
Mitchell T. (1995). The object of development: America’s Egypt. Power of development. In J. Crush (ed.), Power of Development (pp. 129–157). London, UK: Routledge
Molden D., C. de Fraiture (2004). Investing in water for food, ecosystems and livelihoods. Colombo, Sri Lanka: International Water Management Institute
Mollinga P. P., and C. J. M. van Straaten (1996). “The politics of water distribution.” Proceedings of the International Conference on Water Policy, Cranfield University, 1996 (pp. 243–250). London, UK: E & F. N. Spon
Naredo, J. (1999). “El agua y la solidaridad. Ciudades para un futuro más sostenible.” El Boletin de la Biblioteca 11
Neubert S. (2001). Wasser- und Ernährungssicherheit. Problemlagen und Reformoptionen. Politik und Zeitgeschichte 48–49: 13–22
Pandher, S. (2006). “Crop diversification no solution to farm crisis.” The Hindu, July, 31, 2006. Retrieved from http://www.hindu.com/2006/07/31/stories/200607311114 0500.htm on November 5, 2006
Prakash A. (2005). The Dark Zone. Groundwater Irrigation, Politics and Social Power in North Gujarat. New Delhi, India: Wageningen University Water Resources Series. Orient Longman
Reddy, Y. R. K. (2005). “Time to promote virtual water measures.” The Financial Express, October 15, 2005
Reisner M. (1986). Cadillac Desert: The American West and Its Disappearing Water. New York, NY: Penguin Books
Richards A. (2003). Modernity and economic development. The ‹new’ American messianism. Middle East Policy 10: 56–78
Richards A., J. Waterbury (1996). A Political Economy of the Middle East, 2/e. London, UK: Croom Helm
Rosegrant M. W., X. Cai, S. A. Cline (2002). Global Water Outlook to 2025. Averting an Impending Crisis. Washington, DC: International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI) and Colombo, Sri Lanka: International Water Management Institute (IWMI)
Sarkar, R. (2004). “The return of the native. With a unique contract farming experiment, Punjab is trying to develop a diversified portfolio of crops that can compete with wheat and paddy.” Businessworld, February 9, 2004. Retrieved from http://www.businessworldindia.com/feb0904/indepth01_a.asp on November 7, 2006
Sen A. (1980). Famines. World Development 8: 913–621
Sen A. (1981). Poverty and Famines. An Essay on Entitlement and Deprivation. Oxford, UK: Clarendon Press
Sharma, S. (2003a). “Rooted in paddy.” India Together. Retrieved from http://www.indiatogether.org/2003/nov/agr-paddy.htm on November 5, 2006
Sharma, S. (2003b). “Stopping virtual water trade.” India Together. Retrieved from http://www.indiatogether.org/2003/sep/env-virtual.htm on November 5, 2006
Sharma, S. (2004). “Throwing away the problem with water.” Deccan Herald. Retrieved from http://www.iwmi.cgiar.org/Press/iwmi_siwi/deccanherald2704.pdf on November 11, 2006
Sharma, S. (2006). “Signing the wrong contract.” Infochange. Retrieved from http://www.infochangeindia.org/agenda6_10.jsp on November 3, 2006
Shergill, H. S. (2005). “Punjab should stick to wheat, paddy. Farm incomes will fall with new crops.” The Tribune online edition, February 18, 2005. Retrieved from http://www.tribuneindia.com/2005/20050218/edit.htm on November 5, 2006
Shiva, V. (2005). Water Privatization and Water Wars. Retrieved from http://www.zmag.org/Sustainers/ Content/2005–07/12shiva.cfm on November 5, 2006
Sivakumar, S. K. (2004). “It’s called ‹virtual water’...” The Hindu, June 6, 2004. Retrieved from http://www.hindu.com/thehindu/mag/2004/06/06/stories/2004060600150200.htm on November 5, 2006
Swami P. (2004). “A canal crisis.” Frontline 21, August 13, 2004
Tafesse, T. (2000). “The Hydro-Political Perspective of the Nile Question.” Proceedings of the VIII Nile Conference. Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: Nile-2000
Tribune News Service. (2005). “Scrap Sec 5 of termination of agreements Act: SAD.” The Tribune online edition, March 24, 2005. Retrieved from http://www.tribuneindia.com/2005/20050324/punjab1.htm on November 7, 2006
Turton, A. R. (1999). “Precipitation, people, pipelines and power: Towards a ‹Virtual Water’ based political ecology discourse.” MEWREW Occasional Paper No. 11. London, UK: School of Oriental and Asian Studies (SOAS), Water Issues Study Group, University of London. Retrieved from http://www.soas.ac.uk/waterissues/occasionalpapers/OCC11. PDF on November 7, 2006
Turton, A. R., and L. Ohlsson (1999). “Water scarcity and social stability. Towards a deeper understanding of the key concepts needed to manage water scarcity in developing countries.” London, UK: School of Oriental and Asian Studies (SOAS), Water Issues Study Group, University of London. Retrieved from http://www.soas.ac.uk/waterissues/occasionalpapers/OCC17.PDF on November 5, 2006
United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) (2002). Vital Water Graphics. An Overview of the State of the World’s Fresh and Marine Waters. New York, NY: United Nations Environment Programme
United Nations Educational Scientific, Cultural Organization (UNESCO) (2006). Water: a Shared Responsibility. The United Nations World Water Development Report. New York, NY: United Nations Educational Scientific and Cultural Organization and Berghahn Books
Venkatesan, J. (2004). “SYL canal row: Haryana seeks rejection of Presidential reference.” The Hindu, September 21, 2004. Retrieved from http://www.hindu.com/2004/09/21/stories/2004092107971200.htm on November 7, 2006
Warner, J. (2003). “Virtual water, virtual benefits? Scarcity, distribution, security and conflict reconsidered.” In A. Y. Hoekstra (ed.). Virtual Water Trade. Proceedings of the international expert meeting on virtual water trade (pp. 125–135). Value of water research report series No. 12. Delft: IHE. Delft, Netherlands: International Institute for Hydraulics, Engineering, and Environment (IHE)
Warner J. (2005). “Mending the GAP: Hydro-Hegemonic. stability in the Euphrates-Tigris basin.” In Wirkus Lars (ed.) Water, Development and Cooperation. Comparative Perspective: Euphrates-Tigris and Southern Africa (pp. 184–215). BICC Paper 46, Bonn, Germany: Zentrum für Entwicklungs-Fragen (ZEFF-Bonn) and the Bonn International Centre for Conversion (BICC)
Warner, J. and C. Johnson (2007). “Virtual water, real people. Useful concept or prescriptive tool?” Water International 32(4) (forthcoming)
Waterbury J., D. Whittington (1999). Playing chicken on the Nile? The implications of microdam development in the Ethiopian highlands and Egypt’s New Valley project. Yale, F & ES Bulletin 103: 150–167
Weber M. (1964). The Theory of Social and Economic Organisation. New York, NY: Free Press
Wichelns D. (2001). The role of ‹virtual water’ in efforts to achieve food security and other national goals, with an example from Egypt. Agricultural Water Management 49: 131–151
Wichelns D. (2004). The policy relevance of virtual water can be enhanced by considering comparative advantages. Agricultural Water Management 66: 49–63
Wichelns D. (2005). The virtual water metaphor enhances policy discussions regarding scarce resources. Water International 30: 428–437
Williams, P. A. (2003). “The security politics of enclosing transboundary river water resources.” Proceedings of the International Conference on Resource Politics and Security in a Global Age, University of Sheffield, UK, June 2003. Retrieved from http://www.shef.ac.uk/uni/academic/N-Q/perc/resourcepol/papers/williams.pdf on May 1, 2006
World Water Council (ed.). (2004). E-conference Synthesis: Virtual Water Trade – Conscious Choices. 4th World Water Forum. Marseille, France: World Water Forum
Worster D. (1992). Rivers of Empire. New York, NY: Oxford University Press
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank Sudhirendar Sharma, Kai Wegerich, the participants of the ‹Natural Resources and Food Security’ workshop organized by the Law and Governance Group of Wageningen University and Research Centre, and three anonymous reviewers of AHUM for valuable comments and suggestions.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Open Access This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License ( https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.0 ), which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
About this article
Cite this article
Roth, D., Warner, J. Virtual water: Virtuous impact? The unsteady state of virtual water. Agric Hum Values 25, 257–270 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10460-007-9096-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10460-007-9096-7