Abstract
Multiple motors are used to drive long scraper conveyors or the wire section of paper machines, mainly to make long chains and long belts evenly stressed. This type of system does not have the problem of optimal switching of the number of drive motors. However, the system has the problem of how to distribute the load so that the system operates efficiently.
You have full access to this open access chapter, Download chapter PDF
Multiple motors are used to drive long scraper conveyors or the wire section of paper machines, mainly to make long chains and long belts evenly stressed. This type of system does not have the problem of optimal switching of the number of drive motors. However, the system has the problem of how to distribute the load so that the system operates efficiently.
19.1 A Scraper Conveyor Driven by Two Different Motors
In coal mines, many scraper conveyors are very long, some exceeding 300 m. Most scraper conveyors are driven by more than one motor at the same time to ensure uniform force on the scraper conveyor. Scraper conveyors driven by two different motors are common. It has a traditional structure as shown in Fig. 19.1.
In Fig. 19.1, two different motors drive the scraper conveyor to ensure uniform force on the long scraper conveyor. There is a way to accomplish the same task that consumes the least amount of energy. In other words, there is a way to maximize the overall efficiency. However, there has not yet been a common conclusion on the efficiency optimization of such systems [1].
To achieve minimum energy, we should determine how much load each motor in the system carries.
This issue is becoming increasingly important with the increasing awareness of environmental protection and the need for energy-saving systems. Currently, optimization research on various scraper conveyors has been extensively studied [2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9]. Almost all such optimization methods require the establishment of an accurate model of the system. However, since accurate models of actual scraper conveyors are difficult to establish, these optimization methods quickly become difficult to apply in real systems. Solutions that avoid these complications would be highly beneficial, especially for business and industry.
By assuming a fixed total load, we propose an optimal control method similar to traditional static optimization [10], which does not rely on an accurate model of the scraper conveyor and is only based on the shape of the efficiency function. By varying the total load, we also propose a method similar to traditional dynamic optimization [11], which only relies on the efficiency function of the device at constant output. These methods can be used for systems consisting of the same type of motor and gear and having the same energy efficiency function.
However, in industrial applications, there are still a large number of scraper conveyors, and all of their motors do not have the same model. To address the optimization problem of such systems, we extend the discussion presented in [10, 11]. This chapter defines the normalized energy efficiency function of the motor and the scraper conveyor driven by multiple motors with the same normalized energy efficiency function. We can find the functional expression of the scraper conveyor power consumption and its minimum value. When the normalized efficiency function of each motor is the same, our approach can still be adopted [10, 11]. The minimum power consumption and optimal switching point of this type of scraper conveyor are determined by using a normalized energy efficiency function.
19.1.1 Characteristics of a Scraper Conveyor
In general, the efficiency function of a motor at constant speed n0 (rpm) is shown in Fig. 19.2. By exploiting the shape of the efficiency function, we are able to determine the total power consumption of a scraper conveyor.
In Fig. 19.2, M is torque (N m), and η (M) is the efficiency function, Me is the torque at ηe which is the maximum efficiency. For a given motor, ηe and Me are constants. η (M) can be considered approximately a concave non-negative function through the origin, and we have
and
Approximately, η (M) becomes
where
It follows that
The motor’s power has the form
and
where P(M) is the power consumption, M is the output torque, η (M) is the efficiency at point (M, n0), and P0 is the ideal work.
If a scraper conveyor consists of two motors which are running, the total power consumption function has the form
and
where Pt(M) is the total power consumption function, Mi is the i-th motor’s output torque, ηi (Mi) is the ith motor’s efficiency at point (Mi, ni), Mt is the total load torque, and ni is the speed of the i-th motor.
In order to ensure the long scraper conveyor stress evenly, we should have
If two motors are the same model in the scraper conveyor, their efficiency are the same, and the output speed of two motors is the same n0. The ηi (Mi) becomes η (Mi), We have the following optimal conclusion [10].
The optimal control method is to keep
The minimal value of the total power consumption is
where P0 is the ideal work, it has the form
The total optimal efficiency is
19.1.2 Scraper Conveyor with Similar Efficiency
We define the torque rate γ as
We define ηN(γ) as the normalized efficiency function of a motor. The normalized efficiency function ηN(γ) has a shape shown in Fig. 19.3.
In Fig. 19.3, γ is a variable, ηN (γ) is a function of γ, and ηN (γ) has the following relationship with η (M).
If the normalized efficiency functions of two different motors are the same, we have
We define motor 1 and motor 2 as motors with similar efficiency. Scraper conveyors using motors with similar efficiencies are called scraper conveyors with similar efficiencies.
Suppose γi is the i-th motor’s torque rate and has the form
For a scraper conveyor with similar efficiency driven by two motors with the same output speed n0, the total power consumption is of the form
19.1.3 Optimal Control of the Scraper Conveyor with Similar Efficiencies
In this section, we derive the expression for the total power consumption of scraper conveyors with similar efficiencies and determine their minimum power consumption.
Theorem
For the optimization problem of Pt (Mt), the minimization of the total power consumption.
is given by
Proof
There are two variables. We have
where
The objective function Pt (Mt) is expressed as
The optimal condition is given for
We have
It is then easily verified that
is an optimal point.
Checking the second derivative, we see
Therefore, the optimal point is the unique minimum.
The minimum of the total power consumption is then
where P0 is the ideal work.
Remark
If two motors have the same model, then the optimal point is.
The minimum of the total power consumption is
19.1.4 Simulation
If a scraper conveyor is driven by two different motors, A and B, two motors run at the same speed 600 (rpm). The total torque is variable. The output torque of each motor is adjustable.
Motor A is smaller and its efficiency function with respect to torque M at speed 600 (rpm) is given by
where
and
Motor B is larger and its efficiency function with respect to torque M at speed 600 (r.p.m) is
where
and
We see that A and B have the same normalization efficiency function, given by the following
According to our previous conclusion, the optimal control method is to keep motors A and B at the same torque rate
If the total load torque Mt is 360 (N.M), then
19.1.5 Conclusion
The proof of the optimal control method given in this chapter is mainly based on the characteristics of the efficiency function. The efficiency function can be approximately considered as a concave non-negative function passing through the origin. Therefore, the optimal method is independent of the linearity or nonlinearity of the system and does not require a state equation or transfer function of the system. The optimal method has the following characteristics:
-
(1)
Includes linear and nonlinear systems,
-
(2)
No systematic mathematical model is required,
-
(3)
High versatility.
19.2 Wire Sections Driven by Three Different Motors in a Paper Machine
In the wire section of the paper machine, there is usually a very long felt belt. This kind of felt is often driven by multiple motors to ensure uniform felt tension. The structure of a piece of felt driven by three different motors is shown in Fig. 19.4.
In Fig. 19.4, three different motors drive a felt in a paper machine. There is a way to accomplish a task that consumes the least amount of energy, in other words, there is a way that maximizes overall energy efficiency.
The analysis method is basically the same as the idea in the previous section.
19.2.1 Optimal Control of the Wire Section with Similar Efficiencies
Theorem
For the optimization problem of Pt (Mt), the minimization of the total power consumption.
is given by
Proof
We consider two kinds of situation.
-
(1)
n = 2
There are two variables. We have
The objective function Pt is expressed as
The optimal condition is
We have
It is easy to see that
is an optimal point.
The minimal value of the total power consumption is
P0 is the ideal work.
-
(2)
n = 3
There are three variables.
Based on known conditions, we have
Pt expression becomes
Suppose γ1 is the fixed optimal point, only γ2 and γ3 are variables. We have
Based on the above conclusions at n = 2, the optimal point is at
Suppose that γ2 is the fixed optimal point, only γ1 and γ3 are variables. We have
According to the conclusion at n = 2, the optimal point is at
Similarly, assume that γ3 is fixed optimal point, only γ1 and γ2 are variables. We have
According to the conclusion at n = 2, the optimal point is at
Thus, we have the optimal points
The minimum of the total power consumption is
Remark:
If three motors have the same model, then the optimal point is
The minimum of the total power consumption is
19.2.2 Conclusion
The proof of the optimal control method given in this chapter is mainly based on the characteristics of the energy efficiency function, which can be approximated as a concave non-negative function through the origin. Therefore, the optimal method is independent of the linearity or nonlinearity of the system and does not require a state equation or transfer function of the system.
In order to solve the optimization problem of general equipment, the authors have conducted extensive research [11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18]. The conclusions given in this chapter can also be applied to the optimization of pumps, fans, blowers, compressors, etc. We would like to thank Zhang Yanfang from Hebei Automation Company and Yao Bosheng from Beijing IAO Technology Development Company for their valuable help and suggestions during the development and experiment of this theory.
References
Yao F, Sun H (2012) Efficiency optimal control and dispatching method for General equipment. Machine Press, China
Kusumaningtyas I, Lodewijks G (2007) Toward intelligent power consumption optimization in long high-speed passenger conveyors. In: Intelligent transportation systems conference, 2007. ITSC 2007. IEEE, pp 597–602
Qichen Q, Hao T, Lei Z, Qi J (2013) The optimization control of single conveyor-serviced production station with variable service rate. In: Control conference (CCC), 2013 32nd Chinese, pp. 2180–2184
Zhang S, Tang Y (2011) Optimal control of operation efficiency of belt conveyor. In: Power and energy engineering conference (APPEEC), 2011 Asia-Pacific, pp 1–4
De Beauregard DM, Benthaus B, Conradi A, Kulig S (2013) Electromechanical model of an induction machine driven roller conveyor. In: 2012 13th international conference on optimization of electrical and electronic equipment (OPTIM). pp 1071–1078
Masoudinejad M, Feldhorst S, Javadian F, ten Hompel M (2013) Energy optimized speed regulation of permanent magnet synchronous motors for driving roller conveyors. In: 2013 IEEE 10th international conference on power electronics and drive systems (PEDS). pp 500–505
Lodewijks G (2012) Energy efficient use of belt conveyors in baggage handling systems. In: 2012 9th IEEE international conference on networking, sensing and control (ICNSC). pp 97–102
Pang Y, Lodewijks G (2011) Improving energy efficiency in material transport systems by fuzzy speed control. In: 2011 3rd IEEE International Symposium on Logistics and Industrial Informatics (LINDI). pp 159–164
Prasse C, Kamagaew A, Gruber S, Kalischewski K, Soter S, ten Hompel M (2011) Survey on energy efficiency measurements in heterogenous facility logistics systems. In: 2011 IEEE International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management (IEEM). pp 1140–1144
Yao F, Sun H (2011) Optimal control for a common system. In: 2011 3rd IEEE international conference on information management and motorering (IEEE ICIME 2011), May 21–22, 2011, Zhengzhou, China
Yao F, Sun H (2011) Optimal switch for a common system. In: IEEE power motorering and automation conference (PEAM 2011), September 8–9, 2011 in Wuhan, China
Yao F, Sun H (2011) Optimal control and switch in high speed train. In: The 3rd international conference on computational and information sciences (ICCIS2011), Chengdu, China, from October 21 to 23, 2011
Yao F, Sun H (2011) Optimal control in variable-speed pumping stations. In: The 2011 IEEE international conference on mechatronics and automation (ICMA 2011), August 7–10, 2011, Beijing, China
Yao F, Sun H (2011) Optimal switch in variable-speed pumping stations. In: 2011 IEEE 2nd international conference on computing, control and industrial motorering (CCIE 2011), August 20–21, 2011, Wuhan, China
Yao F, Sun H (2011) Optimal control in variable-speed fan stations. In: IEEE the 18th international conference on industrial monitoring and monitoring management, September 3–5, 2011. Chang Chun, P.R. China
Yao F, Sun H (2011) Optimal switch in variable-speed fan stations. In: 2011 international conference of renewable energy sources and environmental materials, May 20–22, 2011, Shanghai, China
Yao FL, Zhang YF (2009) Electrical energy saving control method and practice. China Electric Power Press, Beijing
Yao FL, Sun H (2011) Frequency-converter and energy-saving control crash course. Publishing House of Electronics Industry
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Open Access This chapter is licensed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license and indicate if changes were made.
The images or other third party material in this chapter are included in the chapter's Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the chapter's Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder.
Copyright information
© 2024 The Author(s)
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Yao, F., Yao, Y. (2024). Efficiency Optimization of Scraper Conveyors and Paper Machines. In: Efficient Energy-Saving Control and Optimization for Multi-Unit Systems. Springer, Singapore. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-97-4492-3_19
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-97-4492-3_19
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Singapore
Print ISBN: 978-981-97-4491-6
Online ISBN: 978-981-97-4492-3
eBook Packages: Intelligent Technologies and RoboticsIntelligent Technologies and Robotics (R0)