Abstract
In ordinary gravitational theories, any local bulk operator in an entanglement wedge is accompanied by a long-range gravitational dressing that extends to the asymptotic part of the wedge. Islands are the only known examples of entanglement wedges that are disconnected from the asymptotic region of spacetime. In this paper, we show that the lack of an asymptotic region in islands creates a potential puzzle that involves the gravitational Gauss law, independently of whether or not there is a non-gravitational bath. In a theory with long-range gravity, the energy of an excitation localized to the island can be detected from outside the island, in contradiction with the principle that operators in an entanglement wedge should commute with operators from its complement. In several known examples, we show that this tension is resolved because islands appear in conjunction with a massive graviton. We also derive some additional consistency conditions that must be obeyed by islands in decoupled systems. Our arguments suggest that islands might not constitute consistent entanglement wedges in standard theories of massless gravity where the Gauss law applies.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
G. Penington, Entanglement Wedge Reconstruction and the Information Paradox, JHEP 09 (2020) 002 [arXiv:1905.08255] [INSPIRE].
A. Almheiri, R. Mahajan, J. Maldacena and Y. Zhao, The page curve of Hawking radiation from semiclassical geometry, JHEP 03 (2020) 149 [arXiv:1908.10996] [INSPIRE].
A. Almheiri, R. Mahajan and J. E. Santos, Entanglement islands in higher dimensions, SciPost Phys. 9 (2020) 001 [arXiv:1911.09666] [INSPIRE].
A. Almheiri, T. Hartman, J. Maldacena, E. Shaghoulian and A. Tajdini, Replica Wormholes and the Entropy of Hawking Radiation, JHEP 05 (2020) 013 [arXiv:1911.12333] [INSPIRE].
A. Almheiri, N. Engelhardt, D. Marolf and H. Maxfield, The entropy of bulk quantum fields and the entanglement wedge of an evaporating black hole, JHEP 12 (2019) 063 [arXiv:1905.08762] [INSPIRE].
G. Penington, S. H. Shenker, D. Stanford and Z. Yang, Replica wormholes and the black hole interior, arXiv:1911.11977 [INSPIRE].
A. Karch and L. Randall, Locally localized gravity, JHEP 05 (2001) 008 [hep-th/0011156] [INSPIRE].
A. Karch and L. Randall, Open and closed string interpretation of SUSY CFT’s on branes with boundaries, JHEP 06 (2001) 063 [hep-th/0105132] [INSPIRE].
M. Rozali, J. Sully, M. Van Raamsdonk, C. Waddell and D. Wakeham, Information radiation in BCFT models of black holes, JHEP 05 (2020) 004 [arXiv:1910.12836] [INSPIRE].
H. Liu and S. Vardhan, A dynamical mechanism for the Page curve from quantum chaos, JHEP 03 (2021) 088 [arXiv:2002.05734] [INSPIRE].
J. Sully, M. V. Raamsdonk and D. Wakeham, BCFT entanglement entropy at large central charge and the black hole interior, JHEP 03 (2021) 167 [arXiv:2004.13088] [INSPIRE].
R. Emparan, A. M. Frassino and B. Way, Quantum BTZ black hole, JHEP 11 (2020) 137 [arXiv:2007.15999] [INSPIRE].
H. Liu and S. Vardhan, Entanglement entropies of equilibrated pure states in quantum many-body systems and gravity, P. R. X. Quantum. 2 (2021) 010344 [arXiv:2008.01089] [INSPIRE].
Y. Ling, Y. Liu and Z.-Y. Xian, Island in Charged Black Holes, JHEP 03 (2021) 251 [arXiv:2010.00037] [INSPIRE].
J. Kumar Basak, D. Basu, V. Malvimat, H. Parihar and G. Sengupta, Islands for entanglement negativity, SciPost Phys. 12 (2022) 003 [arXiv:2012.03983] [INSPIRE].
E. Caceres, A. Kundu, A. K. Patra and S. Shashi, Warped information and entanglement islands in AdS/WCFT, JHEP 07 (2021) 004 [arXiv:2012.05425] [INSPIRE].
E. Caceres, A. Kundu, A. K. Patra and S. Shashi, Page Curves and Bath Deformations, arXiv:2107.00022 [INSPIRE].
F. Deng, J. Chu and Y. Zhou, Defect extremal surface as the holographic counterpart of Island formula, JHEP 03 (2021) 008 [arXiv:2012.07612] [INSPIRE].
A. Karlsson, Concerns about the replica wormhole derivation of the island conjecture, arXiv:2101.05879 [INSPIRE].
R.-X. Miao, Codimension-n holography for cones, Phys. Rev. D 104 (2021) 086031 [arXiv:2101.10031] [INSPIRE].
C. Bachas and V. Papadopoulos, Phases of Holographic Interfaces, JHEP 04 (2021) 262 [arXiv:2101.12529] [INSPIRE].
A. May and D. Wakeham, Quantum tasks require islands on the brane, Class. Quant. Grav. 38 (2021) 144001 [arXiv:2102.01810] [INSPIRE].
K. Kawabata, T. Nishioka, Y. Okuyama and K. Watanabe, Probing Hawking radiation through capacity of entanglement, JHEP 05 (2021) 062 [arXiv:2102.02425] [INSPIRE].
A. Bhattacharya, A. Bhattacharyya, P. Nandy and A. K. Patra, Islands and complexity of eternal black hole and radiation subsystems for a doubly holographic model, JHEP 05 (2021) 135 [arXiv:2103.15852] [INSPIRE].
W. Kim and M. Nam, Entanglement entropy of asymptotically flat non-extremal and extremal black holes with an island, Eur. Phys. J. C 81 (2021) 869 [arXiv:2103.16163] [INSPIRE].
L. Aalsma and W. Sybesma, The Price of Curiosity: Information Recovery in de Sitter Space, JHEP 05 (2021) 291 [arXiv:2104.00006] [INSPIRE].
D. Neuenfeld, The Dictionary for Double Holography and Graviton Masses in d Dimensions, arXiv:2104.02801 [INSPIRE].
H. Geng, S. Lüst, R. K. Mishra and D. Wakeham, Holographic BCFTs and Communicating Black Holes, jhep 08 (2021) 003 [arXiv:2104.07039] [INSPIRE].
V. Balasubramanian, A. Kar and T. Ugajin, Entanglement between two gravitating universes, arXiv:2104.13383 [INSPIRE].
C. F. Uhlemann, Islands and Page curves in 4d from Type IIB, JHEP 08 (2021) 104 [arXiv:2105.00008] [INSPIRE].
D. Neuenfeld, Double Holography as a Model for Black Hole Complementarity, arXiv:2105.01130 [INSPIRE].
K. Kawabata, T. Nishioka, Y. Okuyama and K. Watanabe, Replica wormholes and capacity of entanglement, JHEP 10 (2021) 227 [arXiv:2105.08396] [INSPIRE].
J. Chu, F. Deng and Y. Zhou, Page curve from defect extremal surface and island in higher dimensions, JHEP 10 (2021) 149 [arXiv:2105.09106] [INSPIRE].
J. Kruthoff, R. Mahajan and C. Murdia, Free fermion entanglement with a semitransparent interface: the effect of graybody factors on entanglement islands, SciPost Phys. 11 (2021) 063 [arXiv:2106.10287] [INSPIRE].
I. Akal, Y. Kusuki, N. Shiba, T. Takayanagi and Z. Wei, Holographic moving mirrors, Class. Quant. Grav. 38 (2021) 224001 [arXiv:2106.11179] [INSPIRE].
J. Kumar Basak, D. Basu, V. Malvimat, H. Parihar and G. Sengupta, Page curve for entanglement negativity through geometric evaporation, SciPost Phys. 12 (2022) 004 [arXiv:2106.12593] [INSPIRE].
Y. Lu and J. Lin, Islands in Kaluza-Klein black holes, arXiv:2106.07845 [INSPIRE].
H. Omiya and Z. Wei, Causal Structures and Nonlocality in Double Holography, arXiv:2107.01219 [INSPIRE].
A. Manu, K. Narayan and P. Paul, Cosmological singularities, entanglement and quantum extremal surfaces, JHEP 04 (2021) 200 [arXiv:2012.07351] [INSPIRE].
H. Geng and A. Karch, Massive islands, JHEP 09 (2020) 121 [arXiv:2006.02438] [INSPIRE].
C. Krishnan, Critical Islands, JHEP 01 (2021) 179 [arXiv:2007.06551] [INSPIRE].
A. Almheiri, T. Hartman, J. Maldacena, E. Shaghoulian and A. Tajdini, The entropy of Hawking radiation, Rev. Mod. Phys. 93 (2021) 035002 [arXiv:2006.06872] [INSPIRE].
H. Geng et al., Information Transfer with a Gravitating Bath, SciPost Phys. 10 (2021) 103 [arXiv:2012.04671] [INSPIRE].
A. Laddha, S. G. Prabhu, S. Raju and P. Shrivastava, The Holographic Nature of Null Infinity, SciPost Phys. 10 (2021) 041 [arXiv:2002.02448] [INSPIRE].
K. Ghosh and C. Krishnan, Dirichlet baths and the not-so-fine-grained Page curve, JHEP 08 (2021) 119 [arXiv:2103.17253] [INSPIRE].
H. Geng, Y. Nomura and H.-Y. Sun, Information paradox and its resolution in de Sitter holography, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021) 126004 [arXiv:2103.07477] [INSPIRE].
K. Langhoff and Y. Nomura, Ensemble from Coarse Graining: Reconstructing the Interior of an Evaporating Black Hole, Phys. Rev. D 102 (2020) 086021 [arXiv:2008.04202] [INSPIRE].
J. M. Maldacena, The large N limit of superconformal field theories and supergravity, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 2 (1998) 231 [hep-th/9711200] [INSPIRE].
S. S. Gubser, I. R. Klebanov and A. M. Polyakov, Gauge theory correlators from noncritical string theory, Phys. Lett. B 428 (1998) 105 [hep-th/9802109] [INSPIRE].
E. Witten, Anti-de Sitter space and holography, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 2 (1998) 253 [hep-th/9802150] [INSPIRE].
C. Chowdhury, O. Papadoulaki and S. Raju, A physical protocol for observers near the boundary to obtain bulk information in quantum gravity, SciPost Phys. 10 (2021) 106 [arXiv:2008.01740] [INSPIRE].
S. Raju, Lessons from the information paradox, Phys. Rept. 943 (2022) 2187 [arXiv:2012.05770] [INSPIRE].
O. Aharony, O. DeWolfe, D. Z. Freedman and A. Karch, Defect conformal field theory and locally localized gravity, JHEP 07 (2003) 030 [hep-th/0303249] [INSPIRE].
S. Ryu and T. Takayanagi, Holographic derivation of entanglement entropy from AdS/CFT, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96 (2006) 181602 [hep-th/0603001] [INSPIRE].
S. Ryu and T. Takayanagi, Aspects of Holographic Entanglement Entropy, JHEP 08 (2006) 045 [hep-th/0605073] [INSPIRE].
V. E. Hubeny, M. Rangamani and T. Takayanagi, A covariant holographic entanglement entropy proposal, JHEP 07 (2007) 062 [arXiv:0705.0016] [INSPIRE].
M. Porrati, Higgs phenomenon for the graviton in AdS space, Mod. Phys. Lett. A 18 (2003) 1793 [hep-th/0306253] [INSPIRE].
M. Porrati, Mass and gauge invariance 4. Holography for the Karch-Randall model, Phys. Rev. D 65 (2002) 044015 [hep-th/0109017] [INSPIRE].
M. Porrati and A. Starinets, On the graviton selfenergy in AdS4, Phys. Lett. B 532 (2002) 48 [hep-th/0201261] [INSPIRE].
M. Headrick, V. E. Hubeny, A. Lawrence and M. Rangamani, Causality & holographic entanglement entropy, JHEP 12 (2014) 162 [arXiv:1408.6300] [INSPIRE].
A. Hamilton, D. N. Kabat, G. Lifschytz and D. A. Lowe, Local bulk operators in AdS/CFT: A boundary view of horizons and locality, Phys. Rev. D 73 (2006) 086003 [hep-th/0506118] [INSPIRE].
T. Faulkner and A. Lewkowycz, Bulk locality from modular flow, JHEP 07 (2017) 151 [arXiv:1704.05464] [INSPIRE].
N. Engelhardt and A. C. Wall, Quantum Extremal Surfaces: Holographic Entanglement Entropy beyond the Classical Regime, JHEP 01 (2015) 073 [arXiv:1408.3203] [INSPIRE].
T. Faulkner, A. Lewkowycz and J. Maldacena, Quantum corrections to holographic entanglement entropy, JHEP 11 (2013) 074 [arXiv:1307.2892] [INSPIRE].
M. Headrick, General properties of holographic entanglement entropy, JHEP 03 (2014) 085 [arXiv:1312.6717] [INSPIRE].
D. L. Jafferis, A. Lewkowycz, J. Maldacena and S. J. Suh, Relative entropy equals bulk relative entropy, JHEP 06 (2016) 004 [arXiv:1512.06431] [INSPIRE].
X. Dong, D. Harlow and A. C. Wall, Reconstruction of Bulk Operators within the Entanglement Wedge in Gauge-Gravity Duality, Phys. Rev. Lett. 117 (2016) 021601 [arXiv:1601.05416] [INSPIRE].
R. Haag, Local quantum physics: Fields, particles, algebras, Springer, (1992).
H. Casini, M. Huerta and J. A. Rosabal, Remarks on entanglement entropy for gauge fields, Phys. Rev. D 89 (2014) 085012 [arXiv:1312.1183] [INSPIRE].
S. Ghosh, R. M. Soni and S. P. Trivedi, On The Entanglement Entropy For Gauge Theories, JHEP 09 (2015) 069 [arXiv:1501.02593] [INSPIRE].
B. S. DeWitt, The quantization of geometry, in Gravitation: an introduction to current research, L. Witten, ed., John Wiley & Sons, (1963).
K. Kuchar, The problem of time in canonical quantization, in Conceptual Problems of Quantum Gravity, A. Ashtekar and J. Stachel, eds., Birkhauser, (1991).
S. B. Giddings, D. Marolf and J. B. Hartle, Observables in effective gravity, Phys. Rev. D 74 (2006) 064018 [hep-th/0512200] [INSPIRE].
T. Jacobson, Boundary unitarity and the black hole information paradox, Int. J. Mod. Phys. D 22 (2013) 1342002 [arXiv:1212.6944] [INSPIRE].
T. Jacobson and P. Nguyen, Diffeomorphism invariance and the black hole information paradox, Phys. Rev. D 100 (2019) 046002 [arXiv:1904.04434] [INSPIRE].
T. Banks, M. R. Douglas, G. T. Horowitz and E. J. Martinec, AdS dynamics from conformal field theory, hep-th/9808016 [INSPIRE].
S. de Haro, S. N. Solodukhin and K. Skenderis, Holographic reconstruction of space-time and renormalization in the AdS/CFT correspondence, Commun. Math. Phys. 217 (2001) 595 [hep-th/0002230] [INSPIRE].
A. Almheiri, X. Dong and D. Harlow, Bulk Locality and Quantum Error Correction in AdS/CFT, JHEP 04 (2015) 163 [arXiv:1411.7041] [INSPIRE].
K. Papadodimas and S. Raju, State-Dependent Bulk-Boundary Maps and Black Hole Complementarity, Phys. Rev. D 89 (2014) 086010 [arXiv:1310.6335] [INSPIRE].
A. Almheiri, R. Mahajan and J. Maldacena, Islands outside the horizon, arXiv:1910.11077 [INSPIRE].
R. Bousso and E. Wildenhain, Gravity/ensemble duality, Phys. Rev. D 102 (2020) 066005 [arXiv:2006.16289] [INSPIRE].
S. El-Showk and K. Papadodimas, Emergent Spacetime and Holographic CFTs, JHEP 10 (2012) 106 [arXiv:1101.4163] [INSPIRE].
K. Papadodimas and S. Raju, Remarks on the necessity and implications of state-dependence in the black hole interior, Phys. Rev. D 93 (2016) 084049 [arXiv:1503.08825] [INSPIRE].
K. Papadodimas, A class of non-equilibrium states and the black hole interior, arXiv:1708.06328 [INSPIRE].
T. J. Hollowood, S. P. Kumar, A. Legramandi and N. Talwar, Islands in the stream of Hawking radiation, JHEP 11 (2021) 067 [arXiv:2104.00052] [INSPIRE].
X. Wang, R. Li and J. Wang, Page curves for a family of exactly solvable evaporating black holes, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021) 126026 [arXiv:2104.00224] [INSPIRE].
X. Wang, R. Li and J. Wang, Islands and Page curves of Reissner-Nordström black holes, JHEP 04 (2021) 103 [arXiv:2101.06867] [INSPIRE].
T. Takayanagi, Holographic Dual of BCFT, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107 (2011) 101602 [arXiv:1105.5165] [INSPIRE].
D. Gaiotto and E. Witten, Supersymmetric Boundary Conditions in N = 4 Super Yang-Mills Theory, J. Statist. Phys. 135 (2009) 789 [arXiv:0804.2902] [INSPIRE].
T. Hartman and J. Maldacena, Time Evolution of Entanglement Entropy from Black Hole Interiors, JHEP 05 (2013) 014 [arXiv:1303.1080] [INSPIRE].
O. Aharony, A. B. Clark and A. Karch, The CFT/AdS correspondence, massive gravitons and a connectivity index conjecture, Phys. Rev. D 74 (2006) 086006 [hep-th/0608089] [INSPIRE].
H. van Dam and M. J. G. Veltman, Massive and massless Yang-Mills and gravitational fields, Nucl. Phys. B 22 (1970) 397 [INSPIRE].
V. I. Zakharov, Linearized gravitation theory and the graviton mass, JETP Lett. 12 (1970) 312 [INSPIRE].
R. L. Arnowitt, S. Deser and C. W. Misner, The dynamics of general relativity, Gen. Rel. Grav. 40 (2008) 1997 [gr-qc/0405109] [INSPIRE].
K. Kuchar, Ground state functional of the linearized gravitational field, J. Math. Phys. 11 (1970) 3322 [INSPIRE].
J. Corvino and R. M. Schoen, On the asymptotics for the vacuum Einstein constraint equations, J. Diff. Geom. 73 (2006) 185 [gr-qc/0301071] [INSPIRE].
K. Hinterbichler, Theoretical Aspects of Massive Gravity, Rev. Mod. Phys. 84 (2012) 671 [arXiv:1105.3735] [INSPIRE].
A. S. Goldhaber and M. M. Nieto, Photon and Graviton Mass Limits, Rev. Mod. Phys. 82 (2010) 939 [arXiv:0809.1003] [INSPIRE].
B. S. DeWitt, Quantum Theory of Gravity. 1. The Canonical Theory, Phys. Rev. 160 (1967) 1113 [INSPIRE].
C. Chowdhury, V. Godet, O. Papadoulaki and S. Raju, Holography from the Wheeler-DeWitt equation, arXiv:2107.14802 [INSPIRE].
S. W. Hawking and G. T. Horowitz, The Gravitational Hamiltonian, action, entropy and surface terms, Class. Quant. Grav. 13 (1996) 1487 [gr-qc/9501014] [INSPIRE].
V. Balasubramanian and P. Kraus, A stress tensor for Anti-de Sitter gravity, Commun. Math. Phys. 208 (1999) 413 [hep-th/9902121] [INSPIRE].
T. Hartman, Y. Jiang and E. Shaghoulian, Islands in cosmology, JHEP 11 (2020) 111 [arXiv:2008.01022] [INSPIRE].
V. Balasubramanian, A. Kar and T. Ugajin, Entanglement between two disjoint universes, JHEP 02 (2021) 136 [arXiv:2008.05274] [INSPIRE].
L. Anderson, O. Parrikar and R. M. Soni, Islands with gravitating baths: towards ER = EPR, JHEP 21 (2020) 226 [arXiv:2103.14746] [INSPIRE].
S. Fallows and S. F. Ross, Islands and mixed states in closed universes, JHEP 07 (2021) 022 [arXiv:2103.14364] [INSPIRE].
A. Miyata and T. Ugajin, Evaporation of black holes in flat space entangled with an auxiliary universe, arXiv:2104.00183 [INSPIRE].
W. Israel, Thermo field dynamics of black holes, Phys. Lett. A 57 (1976) 107 [INSPIRE].
J. M. Maldacena, Eternal black holes in anti-de Sitter, JHEP 04 (2003) 021 [hep-th/0106112] [INSPIRE].
W. Donnelly and S. B. Giddings, Observables, gravitational dressing, and obstructions to locality and subsystems, Phys. Rev. D 94 (2016) 104038 [arXiv:1607.01025] [INSPIRE].
S. B. Giddings, Gravitational dressing, soft charges, and perturbative gravitational splitting, Phys. Rev. D 100 (2019) 126001 [arXiv:1903.06160] [INSPIRE].
T. Hartman, E. Shaghoulian and A. Strominger, Islands in Asymptotically Flat 2D Gravity, JHEP 07 (2020) 022 [arXiv:2004.13857] [INSPIRE].
I. Akal, Y. Kusuki, N. Shiba, T. Takayanagi and Z. Wei, Entanglement Entropy in a Holographic Moving Mirror and the Page Curve, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126 (2021) 061604 [arXiv:2011.12005] [INSPIRE].
F. F. Gautason, L. Schneiderbauer, W. Sybesma and L. Thorlacius, Page Curve for an Evaporating Black Hole, JHEP 05 (2020) 091 [arXiv:2004.00598] [INSPIRE].
D. Grumiller, R. McNees, J. Salzer, C. Valcárcel and D. Vassilevich, Menagerie of AdS2 boundary conditions, JHEP 10 (2017) 203 [arXiv:1708.08471] [INSPIRE].
D. Grumiller and R. McNees, Thermodynamics of black holes in two (and higher) dimensions, JHEP 04 (2007) 074 [hep-th/0703230] [INSPIRE].
R. Ruzziconi and C. Zwikel, Conservation and Integrability in Lower-Dimensional Gravity, JHEP 04 (2021) 034 [arXiv:2012.03961] [INSPIRE].
D. Harlow and D. Jafferis, The Factorization Problem in Jackiw-Teitelboim Gravity, JHEP 02 (2020) 177 [arXiv:1804.01081] [INSPIRE].
D. Harlow, Wormholes, Emergent Gauge Fields, and the Weak Gravity Conjecture, JHEP 01 (2016) 122 [arXiv:1510.07911] [INSPIRE].
M. Guica and D. L. Jafferis, On the construction of charged operators inside an eternal black hole, SciPost Phys. 3 (2017) 016 [arXiv:1511.05627] [INSPIRE].
P. Gao, D. L. Jafferis and D. K. Kolchmeyer, An effective matrix model for dynamical end of the world branes in Jackiw-Teitelboim gravity, JHEP 01 (2022) 038 [arXiv:2104.01184] [INSPIRE].
D. Harlow and E. Shaghoulian, Global symmetry, Euclidean gravity, and the black hole information problem, JHEP 04 (2021) 175 [arXiv:2010.10539] [INSPIRE].
K. Papadodimas and S. Raju, An Infalling Observer in AdS/CFT, JHEP 10 (2013) 212 [arXiv:1211.6767] [INSPIRE].
D. Marolf, Comments on Microcausality, Chaos, and Gravitational Observables, Class. Quant. Grav. 32 (2015) 245003 [arXiv:1508.00939] [INSPIRE].
M. Blake, D. Tong and D. Vegh, Holographic Lattices Give the Graviton an Effective Mass, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112 (2014) 071602 [arXiv:1310.3832] [INSPIRE].
W. Donnelly and S. B. Giddings, Diffeomorphism-invariant observables and their nonlocal algebra, Phys. Rev. D 93 (2016) 024030 [Erratum ibid. 94 (2016) 029903] [arXiv:1507.07921] [INSPIRE].
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
ArXiv ePrint: 2107.03390
Rights and permissions
Open Access . This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC-BY 4.0), which permits any use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
About this article
Cite this article
Geng, H., Karch, A., Perez-Pardavila, C. et al. Inconsistency of islands in theories with long-range gravity. J. High Energ. Phys. 2022, 182 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/JHEP01(2022)182
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/JHEP01(2022)182