Abstract
Consumption of food grown in contaminated soils may be a significant human exposure pathway to pollutants, including toxic elements. This study aimed to investigate the pollution level of trace elements in farmland soil and crops collected in orchards from Ponce Enriquez, one of the Ecuador’s most important gold mining areas. The concentration of arsenic (As), cadmium (Cd), chrome (Cr), copper (Cu), nickel (Ni), lead (Pb), and zinc (Zn) was analyzed in soil and crop samples (celery, chives, corn, herbs, lettuce, turnips, green beans, cassava, and carrots). In addition, a probabilistic human health risk assessment, in terms of hazard quotients (HQ) and cancer risk (CR), was conducted to assess the potential risk related to local crop ingestion. The contents of As, Cr, Cu, and Ni in soils exceeded the Ecuadorian quality guidelines for agricultural soils. The trace elements concentration in local crops was higher than the maximum permissible levels set by the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). The HQ and CR of local crop ingestion were several orders higher than the safe exposure threshold, mainly for lettuce, chives, and turnips. Our results revealed that inhabitants of the study area are exposed to developing carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic effects due to long-term food consumption with high trace elements. This study sheds light on the need to assess further the quality of agricultural soils and crops grown in mining areas with signs of contamination to guarantee consumer food safety.
Similar content being viewed by others
Explore related subjects
Discover the latest articles, news and stories from top researchers in related subjects.Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Introduction
Food safety is a primary public health concern since food is the main source of human nutrition. However, consuming food grown in contaminated soils may be a major human exposure pathway to pollutants, including trace elements (Haque et al., 2021). As a result, trace elements pollution in the food system is a growing concern worldwide (Wang et al., 2019a, 2019b, 2019c). Furthermore, the intake of trace elements through the food chain is considered the main route of toxic metal pollution for humans and animals, leading to various diseases, including cancer, gastrointestinal disorders, and neurological problems (Kumar et al., 2022).
Agricultural products can absorb contaminants from the soil and have high concentrations of trace elements (Haque et al., 2021). Food crops, particularly vegetables, are susceptible to soil pollution with trace elements. Leafy vegetables have been reported to be more likely to absorb, transport, and accumulate trace elements in their edible parts (Atikpo et al., 2021).
Trace elements can appear in agricultural soils naturally (i.e., atmospheric deposition, weathering, parent rock, or erosion) as well as through anthropogenic activities developed in the vicinity of these soils and by the same agricultural practices that incorporate various contaminants into the soil (Kumar et al., 2022). Among anthropogenic activities, mining is considered an important source of trace elements pollution since, when not carried out properly, it can release potentially toxic elements into the surrounding environment (González-Valoys et al., 2021; Jiménez-Oyola et al., 2021a, 2021b; Wang et al., 2019a, 2019b, 2019c; Xu et al., 2013).
Several studies have reported the presence of trace elements on farmland and foods grown near mining areas (Zhou et al., 2023). In countries like China, severe contamination of crops with trace elements in the neighborhood of mining areas has been reported (Wang et al., 2001; Zhang et al., 2015). Pollutants such as As, Cd, Cu, Hg, Pb, and Zn are transported by precipitation or flooding from contaminated mining sites to nearby farmlands and streams, causing environmental and human health risks (Li et al., 2014; Wang et al., 2019a, 2019b, 2019c). For example, in the city of Tongling, China, high concentrations of Cd, Cr, and Pb were detected in corn (Zea mays) grains, rice (Oryza sativa) grains, and vegetables near mining areas, exceeding China’s food safety limits (Wang et al., 2019a, 2019b, 2019c). Similarly, in crops around the Dabaoshan mine, the concentration of trace elements in rice soils exceeds the maximum concentrations allowed by Chinese legislation (Zhuang et al., 2009a, 2009b). In addition, the health risk assessment derived from the consumption of vegetables and rice by local inhabitants shows risk levels higher than the permissible limits of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) (Zhuang et al., 2009a, 2009b). In other mining regions of China, such as the Shaoguan, Shandong, and Shaanxi Provinces, concentrations of trace elements were higher than the reference levels in agricultural soils (Li et al., 2018a, 2018b; Sun et al., 2018; Zhu et al., 2018). For example, in Nigeria, in the mining region of Enyigba, high concentrations of Cd, Cr, Pb, and Zn were found in tubers, vegetables, and fruits such as lemon (Citrus limon) and pumpkin (Cucurbita pepo) (Obiora et al., 2016). In this sense, there is ample evidence that crop areas near mining areas are vulnerable to contamination; food grown in these areas may pose a potential risk to consumers.
Ponce Enriquez is one of the most important gold mining fields in Ecuador. In addition to mining, this area has significantly developed its agricultural activity (MAE-PRAS, 2015). However, the previous studies in this place have shown the high content of trace elements in different environmental matrices such as water, soil, and sediment (Carling et al., 2013; Escobar-Segovia et al., 2021; Jiménez-Oyola et al., 2021a, 2021b; Tarras-Wahlberg, 2002). Furthermore, considering that rivers are used for irrigation of agricultural lands, their potential high content of trace elements could enhance non-essential toxic elements in the soils where plants are to be grown (Kumar et al., 2022; Yu et al., 2022).
Food production in contaminated lands can pose a potential risk to consumers since toxic contaminants such as As, Cd, and Pb, among others, can enter the human body through the food chain (Khan et al., 2015). In Ecuador, several studies have evaluated soil quality in agricultural areas. For example, Chavez et al. (2015) and Argüello et al. (2019) reported an accumulation of Cd in the soils of cocoa (Theobroma cacao) production in southern Ecuador. In addition, Barraza et al. (2018) identified high concentrations of trace elements in farmland in an oil extraction area of the Ecuadorian Amazon, and Dinter et al. (2021) studied the trace elements content in agricultural soils of the Galápagos Islands. However, no previous studies have evaluated the quality of agricultural soils and the content of trace elements in crops from mining areas with signs of pollution in Ecuador. For this reason, this study aims to: (a) assess the quality of the cultivation soil in agricultural orchards located in the Ponce Enriquez gold mining field, Azuay Province, Ecuador; (b) evaluate the presence of trace elements in locally grown foods; and (c) calculate the health risk to consumers of locally grown products.
Materials and methods
Study area
The study area is in the Canton of Camilo Ponce Enriquez, located in the Azuay Province, southern Ecuador (Fig. 1a). It is a semi-humid area with an average annual rainfall of 1567 mm and a mean annual temperature of 24.8 °C (INAMHI, 2022). The population is 21,998 inhabitants (INEC, 2010). Ponce Enriquez is one of the Ecuador’s oldest gold mining areas, with massive mining operations since the 1980s (Appleton et al., 2001). A large part of the mining operations is developed in the Bella Rica sector, where deposits are rich in sulfide and arsenic with common minerals such as pyrrhotite, arsenopyrite, chalcopyrite, galena, cuprite, chalcocite, covellite, and malachite (PRODEMINCA, 1998; Rivera-Parra et al., 2021). The extraction of gold is conducted by cyanidation and flotation. However, amalgamation with mercury is still used illicitly in the area. Other important socioeconomic activities in Ponce Enriquez are livestock (MAE-PRAS, 2015) and agriculture (coffee (Coffea sp.), cocoa, and plantain for exportation). This study focuses on local orchards managed by the Association of Jancheras (women mine-rock waste collectors) “Unión y Progreso” (Fig. 1b, c).
Sampling collection and analyses
The data correspond to local crop samples (n = 9) and farmland soil samples (n = 8) collected from agricultural orchards in the Ponce Enriquez gold mining area in June 2021. The seven target elements (As, Cd, Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb, and Zn) were analyzed in both soils and food samples. The soil analysis was carried out in the Analytical Chemistry Department of the Mexican Geological Service, Mexico, and the food analysis was carried out in the Plant Nutrition Laboratory of the Escuela Superior Politécnica del Litoral, Ecuador. The soil samples were taken from 5 to 20 cm depth with a shovel. Multiple samples were taken at each sampling point to obtain composite samples. The composite samples were air-dried, disaggregated, homogenized, quartered, grounded, and passed through a 2-mm sieve before their analyses. While the concentration of Cd, Ni, and Pb in soils was determined by Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometer (ICP-MS) Agilent 7700x, the concentration of As, Cr, Cu, and Zn was determined using an optical emission spectrometer (Inductively Coupled Plasma Optical Emission Spectrometry) from Perkin–Elmer®, model AVIO 500 (Meier et al., 1994). Soil sample digestion was performed with four ultra-pure fatty acids (2.5HNO3-4HCl-HClO4-3HF), gradually heating on a hot plate (grill) from 70 to 160°C. The sample recovery stage is carried out with HCl and HNO3 to obtain the elements in an acid solution, either chlorides or nitrates, for subsequent quantification by ICP-OES or ICP-MS. During the analysis, reference materials NCS DC 73303 Rock and NCS DC 73507 Ore were used for quality control. The CCVs used are calibration curve verification standards, composed of the mixture of two high-purity liquid CRMs SP-928462712CHP and SP-928470213B, whose nominal value after preparation is 1 ppm. The percentage of recovery varied between 76 and 97%. The limit of detection (LoD) in mg kg-1 for the analyzed elements in soils was as follows: As = 4, Cd = 0.01, Cr = 3.33, Cu = 2.67, Ni = 0.01, Pb = 0.02, and Zn = 0.41. In addition, the pH was measured in deionized water (liquid/solid = 5/1) using a pH meter (Thermo Scientific Orion Star A215), and the organic matter (OM) content in soil samples was determined with a C/N analyzer (Vario MAX CN Macro Elemental Analyzer) (Chavez et al., 2015).
Crop samples were collected from the same sites where the soil samples were taken and included the main crops grown in the area: celery (Apium graveolens), chives (Allium schoenoprasum), corn, herbs (Coriandrum sativum), lettuce (Lactuca sativa), turnips (Brassica rapa), green beans (Phaseolus vulgaris), cassava (Manihot esculenta), and carrots (Daucus carota sativus). The food samples were washed with distilled water to eliminate soil and dirt particles. The edible part was cut into small pieces and was lyophilized, crushed, and homogenized. Then, 0.5 g of ground food samples were digested with 7 mL of concentrated nitric acid (HNO3) and 1 mL 30% H2O2 at 70 °C (90 mi) and 110 °C (up to 1 mL), and three replicates were digested per sample. The digesters were diluted to 25 mL with nano-pure distilled water and filtered through a 0.45-µm membrane filter prior to trace elements analysis (Chavez et al., 2015). The concentrations of trace elements were determined by triplicate using Inductively Coupled Plasma Optical Emission Spectrometry (ICP-OES) from Perkin–Elmer®, model OPTIMA 5300DV. The LoDs in mg kg−1 were as follows: As = 0.2, Cd = 0.004, Cr = 0.01, Cu = 0.04, Ni = 0.2, Pb = 0.1, and Zn = 0.1. Quality control was conducted by employing duplicates and certified reference material: NIST Standard Tomato Leaves 1573a.
Statistical analysis
The data were statistically analyzed using the R-free software (R Core Team, 2020). Descriptive statistics were used to assess the trends of the data. The relationships among the metal(loid)s in both soil and food samples were evaluated through Spearman’s correlation coefficient. Furthermore, principal component analysis (PCA) was applied to investigate sources of contamination, anthropogenic activities, or geogenic sources (Yuswir et al., 2015).
Exposure assessment and risk characterization
The main pathway of human exposure to trace elements is consuming contaminated food (Romero-Estévez et al., 2023). In the agricultural setting, other routes of exposure are accidental ingestion of soil and skin-to-soil contact during planting and harvesting activities; however, these routes do not significantly contribute to human health risks (Haque et al., 2021; Y. Zhou et al., 2018). In this study, the human health risk through ingestion of polluted local crops was quantified in terms of hazard quotients (HQ) and carcinogenic risk (CR), following the standard model of human health risk assessment recommended by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA). The assessment was performed for both adults and children. The average daily dose (ADD) was estimated using Eq. (1) proposed by the USEPA (2001, 2004).
where C is the concentration of each trace element in food (mg kg−1, FW) on fresh weight; EF is the annual exposure frequency (days year−1); IRc is the ingestion rate of local crops (kg day−1); ED is the exposure duration (years); AT is the averaging time (days); and BW is the body weight (kg).
The non-carcinogenic risk was calculated in terms of hazard quotients (HQ) using Eq. (2), and the Hazard Index (HI), which represents the cumulative non-carcinogenic risk, was estimated by the sum of the HQs. The carcinogenic risk (CR) was calculated according to Eq. (3), and the sum of the CRs estimated the cumulative carcinogenic risk or total cancer risk (TCR). The safe exposure threshold is exceeded for HI above one and TCR above 10−5 (USEPA, 2004).
The values of reference dose (RfD) and slope factor (SF) were collected from the Risk Assessment Information System website (RAIS, 2022). RfD and SF were chosen assuming a conservative scenario. Therefore, the cancer risk was assessed only for As and Cr, which SF reported.
The probabilistic risk estimation was performed using a Monte Carlo simulation (MCS), a recognized method to determine the variabilities and uncertainties of human health risk-based evaluation (Saha et al., 2017). The probabilistic carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic risks were calculated using Oracle Crystal Ball. Ten thousand iterations were carried out for each simulation. The input variables annual exposure frequency (EF), exposure duration (ED), and body weight (BW) were introduced as a probability distribution function. On the other hand, trace elements concentration (Ci), ingestion rate (IRc), average time (AT), reference dose (RfD), and slope factor (SF) were introduced in the risk model as a point estimate. Table 1 shows the distributions and point values used in the risk assessment through the ingestion of local crops for both adult and children receptors.
Results
Trace elements content in soil samples
The physicochemical parameters measured in the agricultural soils of the study area are shown in Table S1 and Fig. 2. The pH in soils from Ponce Enriquez varied between 6.27 and 7.58, within the recommended limits for agricultural soils (6 < pH < 8) according to Ecuadorian regulations (TULSMA, 2015). The organic matter (OM) content ranged from 1 to 6% (Table S1), with five samples in the category of rich in OM (OM > 3%) and three samples with poor to acceptable OM content (1% < OM < 3%) (Ibarra et al., 2006).
The 50th percentile of the trace elements content in soils was in the decreasing order of Zn > As > Cu > Cr > Ni > Pb > Cd. The concentration of trace elements varied significantly between the samples in the following range: As (23.54–421.74 mg kg−1), Cd (1.06–1.94 mg kg−1), Cr (77.24–101.04 mg kg−1), Cu (100.91–215.59 mg kg−1), Ni (50.21–67.58 mg kg−1), Pb (8.69–15.16 mg kg−1), and Zn (150.52–220.06 mg kg−1). Considering the Ecuadorian quality guidelines (EQG) for agricultural soils, As, Cr, Cu, and Ni were above the recommended concentration (As = 12, Cr = 65, Cu = 63, and Ni = 50 mg kg−1) in all farmland samples. Zn was above the EQG (Zn = 200 mg kg−1) in 50% of the samples, but Cd and Pb were below the EQG (Cd = 2 and Pb = 60 mg kg−1) in all samples. Based on the results, trace elements pose a high potential ecological risk to the agricultural soil in the Ponce Enriquez mining areas. Similar findings were informed by Zhu et al. (2018) in agricultural soil in three mining areas in China.
The concentrations of Cd and Zn from Ponce Enriquez were in the range reported by Orellana Mendoza et al. (2021) in areas influenced by mining activity in the central region of Peru; yet, the content of Pb (72.11 ± 15.43 mg kg−1) was lower in our study. In contrast, the As concentration in the previously mentioned research (20.85 ± 5.79 mg kg–1) was several times lower than ours. Furthermore, the concentrations of Cd, Cr, Cu, and Pb measured in our study were found in residential areas (Jiménez-Oyola et al., 2021a, 2021b) from Ponce Enriquez, with values of concentration (p50) of Cd = 0.96 mg kg−1, Cr = 74.32 mg kg−1, Cu = 83.81 mg kg−1, and Pb = 11.12 mg kg−1. However, in the study above, low concentrations of As (p50 = 4.28 mg kg−1) and high contents of Ni (p50 = 176 mg kg−1) were also reported. Similar results were reported by Kumar et al. (2022) in agricultural soil samples from India, with contents of As (0.39–56.35 mg kg−1) lower than those detected in farmland soils from Ponce Enriquez. This research shows that the high content of trace elements in the agricultural soils from the Ponce Enriquez mining area can pose a risk for inhabitants who consume locally grown food. These results highlight the need to monitor the quality of agricultural soils and crops in potentially polluted mining areas.
Trace elements content in food samples
The concentration of the trace elements in local crop samples (mg/kg, FW) on fresh weight is shown in Table 2. The trace elements concentration (p50) followed a decreasing order as Zn > Cu > Ni > As > Cr > Cd (Fig. 3). Pb was below the detection limit of 0.10 mg kg−1 in all samples. The results obtained in this study show significant variations in trace element concentration among food samples. These differences may be due to the variation in the absorption and accumulation capacities of the investigated species (Islam et al., 2014).
The results obtained in this study were compared with the maximum permissible levels (MPL) set by the FAO/WHO (2021). For As, 67% of the samples exceeded the limit of 0.10 mg kg−1, with the highest values in lettuce (12.50 mg kg−1) and chives (8.42 mg kg−1), which suggests that As might cause toxic effects through the consumption of these crops. Cd was above the recommended FAO/WHO safe limit in 78% of the samples; only corn and green beans reported values of Cd below the MPL. Cr exceeded the MPL of 2.30 mg kg−1 only in lettuce. Zn concentration was lower than the MPL of 20 mg kg−1 in corn and cassava samples. Cu and Ni were within the FAO/WHO guideline values in all food samples.
Considering the food safety standards, As and Cd were the pollutants of most significant concern since it was up to 120 times higher than the permissible level recommended by the FAO/WHO in the lettuce sample, which indicates that it is unsafe for human consumption. Turnips and chives were the food samples with the highest content of Cd, with values of 1.64 mg kg−1 and 1.01 mg kg−1, respectively, exceeding the recommended value (0.05 mg kg−1) by more than 20 times.
Several studies have reported the presence of potentially toxic elements on agricultural soils and foods grown near mining areas. For example, Hayford et al. (2009) reported a high concentration of trace elements in cassava and plantain samples collected from gold mining communities in Ghana. Liu et al. (2019) informed about Tl pollution in farmlands and vegetables in a pyrite mining area in China. Svoboda et al., (2006), and Zhuang et al., (2009a, 2009b), reported elevated trace elements in agricultural soils and crops from mining areas in the Czech Republic and China, respectively. Similar findings were informed in areas influenced by mining activity in the central region of Peru, where the mean concentration of Cd (0.32 ± 0.23 mg kg−1) and Pb (0.20 ± 0.12 mg kg−1) in Lepidium meyenii Walpers (maca) samples exceeded the values established by the FAO/WHO guideline (Orellana Mendoza et al., 2021). In contrast, Marrugo-Madrid et al. (2022) determined trace element contents below the threshold established in the regulations in fruits and tubers collected in the gold mining area of Colombia. Therefore, the degree of contamination will depend on the type of mining, geogenic conditions, and environmental factors that favor the release and mobility of pollutants.
Spearman correlation and principal component analysis
Spearman correlation analysis provides information regarding associations of trace elements in each medium. For soil samples, strong positive correlations (r ≥ 0.8) were found between As–Cu and Ni–Cr, and high positive correlations (r ≥ 0.7) between As–Zn and Cu–Zn. High negative correlations (r ≥ 0.8) were found between Cd–Cr and Cd–Ni (Table 3). For crop samples, there was a strong positive correlation (r ≥ 0.8) between Cr and Cu and moderate positive correlations (r ≥ 0.6) between As–Cd, As–Cr, As–Cu, and Cu–Zn. The statistical analysis did not include Pb in food samples because its concentration was below the LoD of 0.10 mg kg−1. The higher correlations among trace elements might indicate similar pollution levels and familiar sources of those elements in farmland soils.
For soil and food samples, two principal components (PC) were extracted with eigenvalues > 1 (Table 4). For soils, PC1 and PC2 explained 96.40% of the variance (PC1 = 49.80% and PC2 = 46.59%). Cu and Ni had significant loading on PC1, while Cr and Ni had significant loading on PC2. For food samples, 74.60% of the variance was explained by PC1 (48.46%) and PC2 (26.148%). As, Cr, and Cu had significant loading on PC1 and Zn and Ni in PC2. The PCA outputs suggest that Ni, Cu, Cr, and As are the primary contaminants of farmland soil because of anthropogenic sources, which is consistent with the previous studies by Jiménez-Oyola et al., (2021a, 2021b), who reported high contents of Cr, Cu, and Ni in soils from Ponce Enriquez.
Human health risk
The human health risk from exposure to trace elements through ingestion of polluted local crops was assessed for both local adults and children. Figure 4 shows the Hazard Index (HI) and the total carcinogenic (TCR) indexes. The USEPA above the safe exposure limit recommended the risk outcomes by probabilistic methods for both receptors for the 95th percentile for non-carcinogenic and carcinogenic risk (Tables S2 and S3, respectively).
The HQ value exceeded the safe limit of one for adults and children in all the food samples. The HQ of each trace element through local crops consumption decreased in the order of As > Cd > Cu > Cr > Ni > Zn. In this line, As and Cd were the main contributors to the non-carcinogenic risk, with 95% of the Hazard Index (HI). Children were the most vulnerable receptor; the HQ for children was four times higher than the HQ for adults. The non-carcinogenic risk in children and adults increases in the following order: lettuce > chives > turnips > herbs > carrots > celery > corn > cassava > green beans (Fig. 5a). Regarding carcinogenic risk, the acceptable CR value is exceeded by As and Cr in all the food samples, being As the most significant contributor to the cancer risk, with 95% of the TCR. Lettuce and chives were the food samples of major concern (Fig. 5b), with CR values significantly higher than the safe exposure limit. The probabilistic risk assessment revealed that 100% of the consumers of local crops might be exposed to carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic health effects caused by the ingestion of food contaminated with trace elements. Similar findings were reported in mining areas of Panamá (González-Valoys et al., 2021), Peru (Orellana Mendoza et al., 2021), and Central China (Li et al., 2018a, 2018b), where the presence of potentially toxic elements in edible plants exceeded the safe exposure limit for non-carcinogenic and carcinogenic risk related to crop ingestion.
Discussion
Food crops, mainly vegetables, are the primary source of human exposure to trace elements, contributing to about 90% of the total intake (Khan et al., 2015). Therefore, assessing the quality of food grown in contaminated areas is necessary to assure consumer food safety. In our study, local crops are severely polluted with trace elements. The concentration of As, Cd, Cr, and Zn was above the maximum permissible levels set by the FAO/WHO (2021), mainly in chives, turnips, and lettuce, the latter known as a hyperaccumulator of trace elements (Khan et al., 2015; Li et al., 2006).
High concentration of trace elements in agricultural soils has a negative impact on crops (Khan et al., 2015). In Ponce Enriquez, the agricultural soil samples showed extremely high concentrations of As (23.54–421.74 mg kg−1), exceeding up to 35 times the limit established in the Ecuadorian regulations (TULSMA, 2015). In many agricultural areas, contamination and loss of soil quality are often associated with poor quality irrigation water (Romero-Estévez et al., 2023). In Ponce Enriquez, the high concentration of trace elements in the rivers has been widely reported (Appleton et al., 2001; Carling et al., 2013; Escobar-Segovia et al., 2021; Jiménez-Oyola et al., 2021a, 2021b). Therefore, its use for irrigation may contribute to soil and food contamination in the area.
Food safety has been a primary public health concern in recent decades, as food crops may contain trace elements resulting from high levels of environmental pollution (Kumar et al., 2019). Some trace elements such as Cu, Cr, and Zn are essential for humans since they play an important role in different metabolic functions. However, other elements such as As, Cd, and Pb are non-essential and have high toxicity (Khan et al., 2015), showing carcinogenic effects (RAIS, 2022).
The presence of trace elements in crops from the study area showed unacceptable levels of risk to consumers’ health. Lettuce was the crop with the most significant contribution to both non-carcinogenic and carcinogenic risk, which poses a concern since lettuce is a highly consumed vegetable in Ecuador (Romero-Estévez et al., 2020). The human health risk of crops consumption was several orders of magnitude higher than the safe exposure threshold, and the trace elements with the greatest contribution to the risk were As and Cd. Both As and Cd are considered human carcinogens (IARC, 1987), whose effects on human health have been widely reported in the literature. As exposure is associated with elevated cancer risks, i.e., bladder, blood systems, kidney, skin, lung, liver, and colon (Rashid et al., 2019), and Cd ingestion can cause diarrhea, stomach pain, fractures due to bone weakening, reproductive problems, damage to the central nervous system, damage to the immune system, and psychological problems (ATSDR, 2022; RAIS, 2022). In Ponce Enriquez, the probability of an individual developing cancer over a lifetime because of intake of trace elements, mainly As, was higher than acceptable levels (Fig. 6). In this line, policies strategic on reducing exposure to polluted food are needed to avoid the detrimental health effects of consumers.
In recent years, various strategies have been evaluated to reduce the bioavailability of toxic elements from the soil to the plant, including nanotechnological tools (Kumar et al., 2019). Several studies suggest that crop selection could be used to reduce the presence of trace elements in food grown in polluted soils, thus protecting consumers’ health. For example, Cao et al. (2022) found that tomatoes (Solanum lycopersicum), kidney beans, potatoes, and cabbage grown in contaminated soils show lower risks for consumers than other food species. Zeng et al. (2021) reported that fruits, root, and tuber vegetables had lower As accumulation than some leaf vegetables. Rodriguez-Iruretagoiena et al. (2015) concluded that tomato plants grown in soils with high concentrations of trace elements did not show high content of contaminants in their fruits. Therefore, selective planting of species with low levels of trace element accumulation should be implemented in the study area. This study highlights the importance of controlling the quality of agricultural soil and local crops in Ponce Enriquez. Public health and environmental supervision institutions must monitor the impact of anthropogenic activities in the area and adopt effective measures to reduce the risk to human health from exposure to contaminants through the food chain.
Conclusions
This research is the first to determine the content of trace elements in soil and crops from agricultural orchards in the Ponce Enriquez gold mining area and to assess the human health risks through local crop ingestion. The findings of this study revealed that the concentrations of As, Cr, Cu, and Ni in farmland soils exceed the Ecuadorian quality guidelines for agricultural soils in all samples. On the other hand, the concentrations of As, Cd, and Zn in local crops were higher than the maximum permissible levels set by the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). The concentrations of trace elements in the food samples varied significantly as a function of plant species. Lettuce and chives are the crops of most significant concern. The Hazard Index (HI) and the total cancer risk (TCR) values from consuming local crops, mainly lettuce, chives, and turnips, were several orders of magnitude higher than the safe exposure threshold for adults and children. The probabilistic health risk revealed that 100% of consumers in the study area have a significant possibility of suffering carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic health effects caused by consuming crops with high trace elements. Therefore, this study recommends continuous monitoring of the quality of agricultural soils and crops grown in the Ponce Enriquez mining area. Based on the results obtained, it is recommended to prohibit the cultivation of plants that hyperaccumulate potentially toxic elements. It must be considered that even the inedible parts of these foods must be properly treated as waste to prevent these products from being consumed by animals and reaching humans through the food chain. Considering the high concentration of trace elements in agricultural soils, the planting of crops that do not accumulate trace elements in their edible parts is recommended to minimize the risk to the population. The risk outcomes of this study need to be further investigated; population-specific parameters, mainly the ingestion rate of local crops, should be determined locally to obtain more accurate risk outcomes. Overall, further studies are required to evaluate the availability of trace elements in soils and the soil–plant transfer processes. The use of fertilizers that can add potentially toxic elements to the soil should be avoided. In addition, agricultural soil protection and rehabilitation measures must be implemented to reduce the risk of transferring toxic elements to the food chain.
References
Anderson, E., Browne, N., Duletsky, S., Raming, J., & Warn, T. (1985). Development of Statistical Distributions or Ranges of Standard Factors Used in Exposure Assessments. Washington, DC.
Appleton, J. D., Williams, T. M., Orbea, H., & Carrasco, M. (2001). Fluvial contamination associated with artisanal gold mining in the Ponce Enríquez, Portovelo-Zaruma and Nambija areas, Ecuador. Water, Air, and Soil Pollution, 131(1–4), 19–39. https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1011965430757
Argüello, D., Chavez, E., Lauryssen, F., Vanderschueren, R., Smolders, E., & Montalvo, D. (2019). Soil properties and agronomic factors affecting cadmium concentrations in cacao beans: A nationwide survey in Ecuador. Science of the Total Environment, 649, 120–127. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2018.08.292
Atikpo, E., Okonofua, E. S., Uwadia, N. O., & Michael, A. (2021). Health risks connected with ingestion of vegetables harvested from heavy metals contaminated farms in Western Nigeria. Heliyon, 7(8), e07716. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2021.e07716
ATSDR. (2022). Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry. https://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/index.html. Accessed 18 April 2022
Barraza, F., Maurice, L., Uzu, G., Becerra, S., López, F., Ochoa-Herrera, V., et al. (2018). Distribution, contents and health risk assessment of metal(loid)s in small-scale farms in the Ecuadorian Amazon: An insight into impacts of oil activities. Science of the Total Environment, 622–623, 106–120. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2017.11.246
Cao, C., Yang, Y., Kwan, M.-P., Ma, Z.-B., Karthikeyan, R., Wang, J.-J., & Chen, H. (2022). Crop selection reduces potential heavy metal(loid)s health risk in wastewater contaminated agricultural soils. Science of The Total Environment, 819, 152502. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2021.152502
Carling, G. T., Diaz, X., Ponce, M., Perez, L., Nasimba, L., Pazmino, E., et al. (2013). Particulate and dissolved trace element concentrations in three southern ecuador rivers impacted by artisanal gold mining. Water, Air, and Soil Pollution, 224(2). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11270-012-1415-y
Chavez, E., He, Z. L., Stoffella, P. J., Mylavarapu, R. S., Li, Y. C., Moyano, B., & Baligar, V. C. (2015). Concentration of cadmium in cacao beans and its relationship with soil cadmium in southern Ecuador. Science of the Total Environment, 533, 205–214. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2015.06.106
Dinter, T. C., Gerzabek, M. H., Puschenreiter, M., Strobel, B. W., Couenberg, P. M., & Zehetner, F. (2021). Heavy metal contents, mobility and origin in agricultural topsoils of the Galápagos Islands. Chemosphere, 272, 129821. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2021.129821
Escobar-Segovia, K., Jiménez-Oyola, S., Garcés-León, D., Paz-Barzola, D., Chavez, E., Romero-Crespo, P., & Salgado, B. (2021). Heavy Metals in Rivers Affected By Mining Activities in Ecuador: Pollution and Human Health Implications. Sustainable Water Resources Management XI : Effective Approaches for River Basins and Urban Catchments, 1, 61–72. https://doi.org/10.2495/wrm210061
FAO/WHO. (2021). Joint FAO/WHO Food Standards Programme Codex Committee on Contaminants in Foods. CF/14 INF/1. Fourteenth Session. CODEX Alimentarius Commission.
González-Valoys, A. C., Esbrí, J. M., Campos, J. A., Arrocha, J., García-Noguero, E. M., Monteza-Destro, T., et al. (2021). Ecological and health risk assessments of an abandoned gold mine (Remance, Panama): Complex scenarios need a combination of indices. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 18(17). https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph18179369
Haque, M. M., Niloy, N. M., Khirul, M. A., Alam, M. F., & Tareq, S. M. (2021). Appraisal of probabilistic human health risks of heavy metals in vegetables from industrial, non-industrial and arsenic contaminated areas of Bangladesh. Heliyon, 7(2). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2021.e06309
Hayford, E. K., Amin, A., Osae, E. K., & Kutu, J. (2009). Impact of gold mining on soil and some staple foods collected from selected mining communities in and around tarkwa-prestea area. West African Journal of Applied Ecology, 14, 1–12. https://doi.org/10.4314/wajae.v14i1.44708
IARC. (1987). Evaluation of carcinogenic risk for humans. International Agency for Research on Cancer. World Health Organization (Vol. 1 to 42). Lyon.
Ibarra, D., Ruiz, J., Flores, J., & González, D. (2006). Spatial Distribution of Organic Matter Content in Agricultural Soils of Zapopan , Jalisco. Terra Latinoamericana, 25, 187–194. https://www.terralatinoamericana.org.mx/index.php/terra/article/view/1425
INAMHI. (2022). Instituto Nacional de Meteorología e Hidrología| Ecuador.
INEC. (2010). Censo Ecuador 2010. Inec, 45.
Islam, M. S., Ahmed, M. K., Habibullah-Al-Mamun, M., & Masunaga, S. (2014). Trace metals in soil and vegetables and associated health risk assessment. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 186(12), 8727–8739. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10661-014-4040-y
Israeli, M., & Nelson, C. B. (1992). Distribution and Expected Time of Residence for US Households. Risk Analysis, 12(1), 65–72. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1539-6924.1992.tb01308.x
Jiménez-Oyola, S., García-Martínez, M.-J., Ortega, M., Chavez, E., Romero, P., Garcia-Garizabal, I., & Bolonio, D. (2021b). Ecological and probabilistic human health risk assessment of heavy metal(loid)s in river sediments affected by mining activities in Ecuador. Environmental Geochemistry and Health, 16. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10653-021-00935-w
Jiménez-Oyola, S., Chavez, E., García-Martínez, M.-J., Ortega, M. F., Bolonio, D., Guzmán-Martínez, F., et al. (2021a). Probabilistic multi-pathway human health risk assessment due to heavy metal(loid)s in a traditional gold mining area in Ecuador. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 224(May), 112629. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoenv.2021.112629
Khan, A., Khan, S., Khan, M. A., Qamar, Z., & Waqas, M. (2015). The uptake and bioaccumulation of heavy metals by food plants, their effects on plants nutrients, and associated health risk: A review. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 22(18), 13772–13799. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-015-4881-0
Kumar, S., Prasad, S., Yadav, K. K., Shrivastava, M., Gupta, N., Nagar, S., et al. (2019). Hazardous heavy metals contamination of vegetables and food chain: Role of sustainable remediation approaches - A review. Environmental Research, 179(September), 108792. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envres.2019.108792
Kumar, P., Dipti, Kumar, S., & Singh, R. P. (2022). Severe contamination of carcinogenic heavy metals and metalloid in agroecosystems and their associated health risk assessment. Environmental Pollution, 301(January), 118953. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envpol.2022.118953
Li, F., Li, X., Hou, L., & Shao, A. (2018a). Impact of the Coal Mining on the Spatial Distribution of Potentially Toxic Metals in Farmland Tillage Soil. Scientific Reports, 8(1), 14925. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-33132-4
Li, X., Li, Z., Lin, C.-J.J., Bi, X., Liu, J., Feng, X., et al. (2018b). Health risks of heavy metal exposure through vegetable consumption near a large-scale Pb/Zn smelter in central China. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 161(May), 99–110. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoenv.2018.05.080
Li, Y., Wang, Y. B., Gou, X., Su, Y. B., & Wang, G. (2006). Risk assessment of heavy metals in soils and vegetables around non-ferrous metals mining and smelting sites, Baiyin. China. Journal of Environmental Sciences (china), 18(6), 1124–1134. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1001-0742(06)60050-8
Li, Z., Ma, Z., van der Kuijp, T. J., Yuan, Z., & Huang, L. (2014). A review of soil heavy metal pollution from mines in China: Pollution and health risk assessment. Science of the Total Environment, 468–469, 843–853. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2013.08.090
Liu, J., Li, N., Zhang, W., Wei, X., Tsang, D. C. W., Sun, Y., et al. (2019). Thallium contamination in farmlands and common vegetables in a pyrite mining city and potential health risks. Environmental Pollution, 248, 906–915. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envpol.2019.02.092
MAE-PRAS. (2015). Programa de Reparación Ambiental Y Social - Plan de Reparación Integral de la Zona de Estudio Tenguel - Camilo Ponce Enríquez (Vol. I).
Marrugo-Madrid, S., Pinedo-Hernández, J., Paternina-Uribe, R., Marrugo-Negrete, J., & Díez, S. (2022). Health risk assessment for human exposure to mercury species and arsenic via consumption of local food in a gold mining area in Colombia. Environmental Research, 215(May). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envres.2022.113950
Meier, A. L., Grimes, D. J., & Ficklin, W. H. (1994). Inductively coupled plasma–mass spectrometry: A powerful tool for mineral resource and environmental studies. In L. Carter, M. I. Toth, & W. C. Day (Eds.), USGS Research on Mineral Resources (pp. 67–68). Arizona, USA: US Geological Survey. https://doi.org/10.3133/cir1103A
Obiora, S. C., Chukwu, A., & Davies, T. C. (2016). Heavy metals and health risk assessment of arable soils and food crops around Pb-Zn mining localities in Enyigba, southeastern Nigeria. Journal of African Earth Sciences, 116, 182–189. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jafrearsci.2015.12.025
Orellana Mendoza, E., Cuadrado, W., Yallico, L., Zárate, R., Quispe-Melgar, H. R., Limaymanta, C. H., et al. (2021). Heavy metals in soils and edible tissues of Lepidium meyenii (maca) and health risk assessment in areas influenced by mining activity in the Central region of Peru. Toxicology Reports, 8, 1461–1470. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.toxrep.2021.07.016
PRODEMINCA. (1998). Monitoreo Ambiental de las Áreas Mineras en el Sur de Ecuador 1996 - 1998 (First.). UCP Prodeminca.
R Core Team. (2020). R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. Austria.
RAIS. (2022). Toxicity profiles. Risk Assessment Information System. http://rais.ornl.gov. Accessed 2 March 2022
Rashid, A., Khan, S., Ayub, M., Sardar, T., Jehan, S., Zahir, S., et al. (2019). Mapping human health risk from exposure to potential toxic metal contamination in groundwater of Lower Dir, Pakistan: Application of multivariate and geographical information system. Chemosphere, 225, 785–795. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2019.03.066
Rivera-Parra, J. L., Beate, B., Diaz, X., & Ochoa, M. B. (2021). Artisanal and small gold mining and petroleum production as potential sources of heavy metal contamination in ecuador: A call to action. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 18(6), 1–16. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph18062794
Rodriguez-Iruretagoiena, A., Trebolazabala, J., Martinez-Arkarazo, I., De Diego, A., & Madariaga, J. M. (2015). Metals and metalloids in fruits of tomatoes (Solanum lycopersicum) and their cultivation soils in the Basque Country: Concentrations and accumulation trends. Food Chemistry, 173, 1083–1089. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodchem.2014.10.133
Romero-Estévez, D., Yánez-Jácome, G. S., & Navarrete, H. (2023). Journal of Food Composition and Analysis Non-essential metal contamination in Ecuadorian agricultural production : A critical review, 115(August 2022). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfca.2022.104932
Romero-Estévez, D., Yánez-Jácome, G. S., Simbaña-Farinango, K., Vélez-Terreros, P. Y., & Navarrete, H. (2020). Determination of cadmium and lead in tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) and lettuce (Lactuca sativa) consumed in Quito. Ecuador. Toxicology Reports, 7(January), 893–899. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.toxrep.2020.07.008
Saha, N., Rahman, M. S., Ahmed, M. B., Zhou, J. L., Ngo, H. H., & Guo, W. (2017). Industrial metal pollution in water and probabilistic assessment of human health risk. Journal of Environmental Management, 185, 70–78. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2016.10.023
Spence, L. R., & Walden, T. (2001). RISC User's Manual Version 4.0, 463.
Sun, Z., Xie, X., Wang, P., Hu, Y., & Cheng, H. (2018). Heavy metal pollution caused by small-scale metal ore mining activities: A case study from a polymetallic mine in South China. Science of the Total Environment, 639, 217–227. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2018.05.176
Svoboda, L., Havlícková, B., & Kalač, P. (2006). Contents of cadmium, mercury and lead in edible mushrooms growing in a historical silver-mining area. Food Chemistry, 96, 580–585. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodchem.2005.03.012
Tarras-Wahlberg, N. H. (2002). Environmental management of small-scale and artisanal mining: the Portovelo-Zaruma goldmining area , southern Ecuador. Journal of Environmental Management, 165–179. https://doi.org/10.1006/jema.2002
TULSMA. (2015). Texto Unificado de Legislación Secundaria Medio Ambiental. Registro oficial órgano del gobierno del Ecuador.
USEPA. (1996). Proposed Guidelines for Carcinogen Risk Assessment. Environmental Protection Agency (Vol. 79).
USEPA. (2001). Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund (RAGS) Volume III (Part A). Process for Conducting Probabilistic Risk Assessment (Vol. 3). Washington, DC. http://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2015-09/documents/rags3adt_complete.pdf
USEPA. (2004). Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund Volume I: Human Health Evaluation Manual (Part E). Supplemental Guidance for Dermal Risk Assessment. Washington, DC.
Wang, J., Su, J., Li, Z., Liu, B., Cheng, G., Jiang, Y., et al. (2019). Source apportionment of heavy metal and their health risks in soil-dustfall-plant system nearby a typical non-ferrous metal mining area of Tongling Eastern China. Environmental Pollution, 254, 113089. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envpol.2019.113089
Wang, L., Yang, D., Li, Z., Fu, Y., Liu, X., Brookes, P. C., & Xu, J. (2019b). A comprehensive mitigation strategy for heavy metal contamination of farmland around mining areas – Screening of low accumulated cultivars, soil remediation and risk assessment. Environmental Pollution, 245, 820–828. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envpol.2018.11.062
Wang, P., Sun, Z., Hu, Y., & Cheng, H. (2019). Leaching of heavy metals from abandoned mine tailings brought by precipitation and the associated environmental impact. Science of The Total Environment, 695, 133893. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2019.133893
Wang, Q., Qingren, W., Dong, Y., Cui, Y., & Liu, X. (2001). Instances of soil and crop heavy metal contamination in China. Soil and Sediment Contamination, 10(5), 497–510.
Xu, D., Zhou, P., Zhan, J., Gao, Y., Dou, C., & Sun, Q. (2013). Assessment of trace metal bioavailability in garden soils and health risks via consumption of vegetables in the vicinity of Tongling mining area, China. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 90, 103–111. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoenv.2012.12.018
Yu, H., Chen, F., Ma, J., Khan, Z. I., Hussain, M. I., Javaid, I., et al. (2022). Comparative evaluation of groundwater, wastewater and canal water for irrigation on toxic metal accumulation in soil and vegetable: Pollution load and health risk assessment. Agricultural Water Management, 264(January), 107515. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agwat.2022.107515
Yuswir, N. S., Praveena, S. M., Aris, A. Z., Ismail, S. N. S., & Hashim, Z. (2015). Health risk assessment of heavy metal in urban surface soil (Klang District, Malaysia). Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 95(1), 80–89. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00128-015-1544-2
Zeng, X., Bai, L., Gao, X., Shan, H., Wu, C., & Su, S. (2021). Agricultural planning by selecting food crops with low arsenic accumulation to efficiently reduce arsenic exposure to human health in an arsenic-polluted mining region. Journal of Cleaner Production, 308(12), 127403. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.127403
Zhang, X., Zhong, T., Liu, L., & Ouyang, X. (2015). Impact of soil heavy metal pollution on food safety in China. PLOS ONE, 10(8), e0135182. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0135182
Zhou, H., Chen, Y., Yue, X., Ren, D., Liu, Y., & Yang, K. (2023). Identification and hazard analysis of heavy metal sources in agricultural soils in ancient mining areas: A quantitative method based on the receptor model and risk assessment. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 445(September 2022), 130528. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2022.130528
Zhou, Y., Niu, L., Liu, K., Yin, S., & Liu, W. (2018). Arsenic in agricultural soils across China: Distribution pattern, accumulation trend, influencing factors, and risk assessment. Science of the Total Environment, 616–617, 156–163. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2017.10.232
Zhu, D., Wei, Y., Zhao, Y., Wang, Q., & Han, J. (2018). Heavy metal pollution and ecological risk assessment of the agriculture soil in Xunyang mining area, Shaanxi Province, Northwestern China. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 101(2), 178–184. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00128-018-2374-9
Zhuang, P., McBride, M. B., Xia, H., Li, N., & Li, Z. (2009a). Health risk from heavy metals via consumption of food crops in the vicinity of Dabaoshan mine, South China. Science of the Total Environment, 407(5), 1551–1561. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2008.10.061
Zhuang, P., Zou, B., Li, N. Y., & Li, Z. A. (2009b). Heavy metal contamination in soils and food crops around Dabaoshan mine in Guangdong, China: Implication for human health. Environmental Geochemistry and Health, 31(6), 707–715. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10653-009-9248-3
Acknowledgements
The authors thank the Association of Jancheras “Unión y Progreso” for their collaboration in this research. In addition, we thank the ESPOL Research Dean and Academic Writing Center of ESPOL for the support provided to this research.
Funding
Open Access funding provided thanks to the CRUE-CSIC agreement with Springer Nature.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
PRC was involved in methodology, writing—original draft, and project administration. SJO was involved in conceptualization, methodology, writing—original draft, and supervision. BSA contributed to methodology, writing—original draft, and project administration. JZA contributed to data curation and visualization. CGC was involved in formal analysis and investigation. AGV contributed to writing—review and editing. PH was involved in writing—review and editing.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary Information
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Romero-Crespo, P., Jiménez-Oyola, S., Salgado-Almeida, B. et al. Trace elements in farmland soils and crops, and probabilistic health risk assessment in areas influenced by mining activity in Ecuador. Environ Geochem Health 45, 4549–4563 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10653-023-01514-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10653-023-01514-x