Abstract
Are color adjectives (“red”, “green”, etc.) relative adjectives or absolute adjectives? Existing theories of the meaning of color adjectives attempt to answer that question using informal (“armchair”) judgments. The informal judgments of theorists conflict: it has been proposed that color adjectives are absolute with standards anchored at the minimum degree on the scale, that they are absolute but have near-midpoint standards, and that they are relative. In this paper we report two experiments, one based on entailment patterns and one based on presupposition accommodation, that investigate the meaning of scalar adjectives. We find evidence confirming the existence of subgroups of the population who operate with different standards for color adjectives. The evidence of interpersonal variation in where standards are located on the relevant scale and how those standards can be adjusted indicates that the existing theories of the meaning of color adjectives are at best only partially correct. We also find evidence that paradigmatic relative adjectives (“tall”, “wide”) behave in ways that are not predicted by the standard theory of scalar adjectives. We discuss several different possible explanations for this unexpected behavior. We conclude by discussing the relevance of our findings for philosophical debates about the nature and extent of semantically encoded context sensitivity in which color adjectives have played a key role.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Arnkil, H. (2013). Colours in the visual world. Helsinki: Aalto Art Books.
Barner D., Snedeker J. (2008) Compositionality and statistics in adjective acquisition: 4-Year-olds interpret Tall and Short based on the size distributions of novel noun referents. Child Development 79(3): 594–608
Barr D. J., Levy R., Scheepers C., Tily H. J. (2013) Random effects structure for confirmatory hypothesis testing: Keep it maximal. Journal of Memory and Language 68(3): 255–278
Bartsch R., Vennemann T. (1972) The grammar of relative adjectives and comparison. Linguistische Berichte 20: 19–32
Bates D., Mächler M., Bolker B., Walker S. (2015) Fitting linear mixed-effects models using lme4. Journal of Statistical Software 67(1): 1–48
Burnett H. (2012) The puzzle(s) of absolute adjectives. UCLA Working Papers in Linguistics, Papers in Semantics 16: 1–50
Burnett H. (2014) A delineation solution to the puzzles of absolute adjectives. Linguistics and Philosophy 37(1): 1–39
Cappelen, H. (2012). Philosophy without intuitions. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Chierchia, G., Spector, B., & Fox, D. (2012). The grammatical view of scalar implicatures and the relationship between semantics and pragmatics. In C. Maienborn, K. von Heusinger, & P. Portner (Eds.), Semantics. An international handbook of natural language meaning (Vol. 3, pp. 2297–2332). Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Clapp L. (2012) Indexical color-predicates: Truth-conditional semantics vs. truth-conditional pragmatics. Canadian Journal of Philosophy 42(2): 71–100
Coppock, E., & Beaver, D. (2012). Weak uniqueness: The only difference between definiteness and indefinites. In A. Chereches (Ed.), Proceedings of Semantics and Linguistic Theory (SALT) (pp. 197–217). Ithaca, NY: CLC Publications.
Coppock E., Beaver D. (2015) Definiteness and determinacy. Linguistics and Philosophy 38(5): 377–435
Davies A. (2014) Off-target responses to occasion-sensitivity. Dialectica 68(4): 499–523
DeRose K. (2008) Gradable adjectives: A defense of pluralism. Australasian Journal of Philosophy 86(1): 141–160
Glanzberg M. (2007) Context, content, and relativism. Philosophical Studies 136(1): 1–29
Graff D. (2000) Shifting sands: An interest-relative theory of vagueness. Philosophical Topics 28(1): 45–81
Hansen N. (2011) Color adjectives and radical contextualism. Linguistics and Philosophy 34(3): 201–221
Hansen, N. (2015). A new argument from interpersonal variation to subjectivism about color: A response to gómez-torrente. Noûs, (EarlyView):1–8.
Hansen, N. (2016). Color comparisons and interpersonal variation. Review of Philosophy and Psychology, online first:1–18.
Kennedy C. (2007) Vagueness and grammar: The semantics of relative and absolute gradable adjectives. Linguistics and Philosophy 30(1): 1–45
Kennedy C., McNally L. (2005) Scale structure, degree modification, and the semantics of gradable predicates. Language 81(2): 345–381
Kennedy C., McNally L. (2010) Color, context, and compositionality. Synthese 174(1): 79–98
Klein E. (1980) A semantics for positive and comparative adjectives. Linguistics and Philosophy 4(1): 1–45
Kuehni R. (2004) Variability in unique hue selection: A surprising phenomenon. Color Research and Application 29: 158–162
Lang, E. (1989). The semantics of dimensional designation of spatial objects. In M. Bierwisch & E. Lang (Eds.), Dimensional adjectives: Grammatical structure and conceptual interpretation (pp. 263–417). New York, NY: Springer.
Lasersohn P. (1999) Pragmatic halos. Language 75(3): 522–551
Lewis D. (1979) Scorekeeping in a language game. Journal of Philosophical Logic 8(1): 339–359
Liao S.-Y., McNally L., Meskin A. (2016) Aesthetic adjectives lack uniform behavior. Inquiry 59(6): 618–631
Liao, S.-Y. & Meskin, A. (2015). Aesthetic adjectives: Experimental semantics and context-sensitivity. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, Early View:1–28.
McNally L. (2005) Lexical representation and modification within the noun phrase. Recherches Linguistiques de Vincennes 34: 191–206
McNally, L. (2011). The relative role of property type and scale structure in explaining the behavior of gradable adjectives. In R. Nouwen, R. van Rooij, U. Sauerland, & H.-C. Schmitz (Eds.), ViC 2009: Papers from the ESSLLI 2009 workshop on vagueness in communication (Vol. 6517, pp. 151–168)., Lecture notes in computer science Heidelberg: Springer.
Morrison J. (2015) Anti-atomism about color representation. Noûs 49(1): 94–122
Panzeri, F., & Foppolo, F. (2012). Can children tell us something about the semantics of adjectives? In M. Aloni, V. Kimmelman, F. Roelofsen, G. W. Sassoon, K. Schulz, & M. Westera (Eds.), Logic, language and meaning: 18th Amsterdam Colloquium, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, December 19–21, 2011, revised selected papers (pp. 170–179). Berlin: Springer.
Phelan, M. (2016). Gradability and multidimensionality in aesthetic adjectives. Unpublished ms.
Recanati, F. (2004). Literal meaning. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Rett, J. (2015). The semantics of evaluativity. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Rothschild D., Segal G. (2009) Indexical predicates. Mind and Language 24(4): 467–493
Rotstein C., Winter Y. (2004) Total adjectives vs. partial adjectives: Scale structure and higher-order modifiers. Natural Language Semantics 12(3): 259–288
Sapir E. (1944) Grading: A study in semantics. Philosophy of Science 11(2): 93–116
Sassoon G. W. (2012) A typology of multidimensional adjectives. Journal of Semantics 30(3): 1–46
Searle J. R. (1978) Literal meaning. Erkenntnis 13(1): 207–224
Searle, J. R. (1980). The background of meaning. In F. Kiefer & M. Bierwisch (Eds.), Speech act theory and pragmatics (pp. 221–232). Dordrecht, Holland: Reidel.
Solt, S. (2016). Multidimensionality, subjectivity and scales: Experimental evidence. Unpublished ms.
Sprouse J. (2011) A validation of amazon mechanical turk for the collection of acceptability judgments in linguistic theory. Behavior Research Methods 43(1): 155–167
Stanley, J. (2004). On the linguistic basis of contextualism. Philosophical Studies, 119(1–2), 119–146.
Syrett, K. (2007). Learning about the structure of scales: Adverbial modification and the acquisition of the semantics of gradable adjectives. Ph.D. thesis, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL.
Syrett K., Kennedy C., Lidz J. (2010) Meaning and context in children’s understanding of gradable adjectives. Journal of Semantics 27(1): 1–35
Szabó, Z. G. (2001). Adjectives in context. In I. Kenesei & R. M. Harnish (Eds.), Perspectives on semantics, pragmatics, and discourse: A Festschrift for Ferenc Kiefer (pp. 119–146). Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing Company.
Team, R. C. (2015). R: A language and environment for statistical computing. Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing.
Toledo, A. & Sassoon, G. W. (2011). Absolute vs. relative adjectives—Varience within vs. between individuals. In Proceedings of SALT 21 (pp. 135–154). Rutgers University. MIT Working Papers in Linguistics.
Travis, C. (1989). The uses of sense: Wittgenstein’s philosophy of language. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Travis, C. (1997). Pragmatics. In B. Hale & C. Wright (Eds.), A companion to the philosophy of language (pp. 87–107). Oxford: Blackwell.
Travis, C. (2006). Thought’s footing. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Tribushinina, E. (2008). Cognitive reference points: Semantics beyond the prototypes in adjectives of space and colour. Ph.D. thesis, Universiteit Leiden, Leiden, The Netherlands.
Unger, P. (1975). Ignorance: A case for skepticism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
van Rooij, R. (2009). Vagueness in linguistics. In G. Ronzitti (Ed.), The Vagueness handbook (pp. 123–170). Berlin: Springer.
Vicente A. (2015) The green leaves and the expert: Polysemy and truth conditional variability. Lingua 157: 54–65
Yoon Y. (1996) Total and partial predicates and the weak and strong interpretations. Natural Language Semantics 4: 217–236
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.
About this article
Cite this article
Hansen, N., Chemla, E. Color adjectives, standards, and thresholds: an experimental investigation. Linguist and Philos 40, 239–278 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10988-016-9202-7
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10988-016-9202-7