Abstract
In this study, phylogenetic and biogeographic methods are used to investigate the evolutionary relationships between various types of Italian pasta ripiena (filled pasta) and related representatives from across Eurasia, using information from their geography, shape, content and cooking methods. Our results showed that, with the exception of the Sardinian Culurgiones, all the other pasta ripiena from Italy likely had a single origin in the northern parts of the country. Based on the proposed evolutionary hypothesis, the Italian pasta are divided into two main clades: a ravioli clade mainly characterized by a more or less flat shape, and a tortellini clade mainly characterized by a three-dimensional shape. The implications of these findings are further discussed.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
1 Introduction
Across Italy, a dizzying array of local variants of stuffed-pasta (pasta ripiena) dishes are prepared and served that often, from one town to another, show minor differences in size, shape, ingredients, or methods of preparation and serving. They are known by many different names, but the common feature in all pasta ripiena is the placement of uncooked filling in a thin shell made of rolled-out dough, which is then closed and shaped into specific forms before cooking. The use of local wild food plants or varieties of vegetables, herbs and spices as ingredients for filling or serving sauces adds unique layers of authenticity to family recipes that are often passed down for generations, reflecting the unique biocultural diversity in the country [1].
The Italian pasta ripiena are part of a large family of Eurasian stuffed dumplings that similarly come in a wide array of shapes and forms and are known by many different names, for example, the Turkish manti, German maultaschen, Polish pierogi, Jewish kreplach, Russian pelmeni, Georgian khinkali, Tibetan momo, Chinese wonton, Japanese gyoza, and many others. It is unclear whether all dumplings had a singular origin or evolved independently, or how the remarkable diversity observed in Italy is related to the greater variation present in Eurasia. Based on linguistic similarities, it has been speculated that stuffed dumplings were probably first invented in the Middle East and subsequently spread across Eurasia by Turkic and Iranian peoples [2]. Dumplings were known in China during the Han Empire (206 BC-220 AD) [3], where archaeological remnants of noodles from this period were also discovered [4]; however, in the same era, pasta had not yet made its appearance in Europe. The Italian ravioli have also been suggested to be a descendent of the Greek manti [5]. However, such scholarly theories often lack solid empirical evidence.
In Italy, ravioli are probably the oldest historically documented filled pasta, even though the early iterations of this dish evidently did not include the enclosing pasta casing [6]. Between the 12 and 13 centuries, a settler from Savona agreed to provide his master with a lunch for three people made of bread, wine, meat and ravioli, during the grape harvest [7]. Tortelli [8] and agnolotti [9] first appeared in literature much later. However, the origins of the iconic tortellini are controversial. The long-standing historical feud between the cities of Bologna and Modena over who invented the tortellini was symbolically settled at the end of the 19 century by Bolognese poet and satirist Giuseppe Ceri, who, in his poem “L’ombelico di Venere” (the navel of Venus), declared Castelfranco Emilia, a town halfway between the two cities, to be the birthplace of tortellini. According to this legend, one day, while Venus, Mars and Bacchus were visiting a tavern in Castelfranco Emilia, the innkeeper inadvertently caught Venus in a state of undress and was so astonished at the sight of the goddess’ navel that he ran into the kitchen and created tortellini in her honor. Clearly, a product as perfect as tortellini could be inspired only by Venus, the goddess of beauty [10].
In his legendary 1891 cookbook, Pellegrino Artusi [11] listed a total of approximately 10 dishes that can be counted as pasta ripiena, including three different kinds of tortellini: Italian tortellini (agnellotti), tortellini Bolognese, and pigeon-meat tortellini. He included all the stuffed pasta under “Minestre” (soups) since they are usually served in broth.
The century following Artusi witnessed an explosion in nontraditional recipes for stuffed pasta across Italy, with entire cookbooks dedicated to hundreds of new and unique varieties. David Alexander’s [12] modern morphological classification of Italian pasta includes the “ravioli (filled pasta) family”, with 33 dishes grouped into four different types: “Sachet”, Circular, Semi-circular, and “Crimped and tied” (Table 1). His map of regional origins correctly identified northern Italy as the hotspot of diversity for this group, with only two variants further south (Crespelle in Molise and ‘Culigiones’ [sic] in Sardinia).
In this study, phylogenetic and cladistic approaches were employed for the first time to investigate the origin and evolution of pasta ripiena, with a focus on Italy. The investigation focused on whether it is possible to empirically categorize Italian stuffed pasta into discrete evolutionary units; If so, how did these groups appear and evolve, what are their unique characteristics (if any), and how are they related to one another and to non-Italian stuffed pasta.
2 Materials and methods
2.1 Selection of the in-group
Even though it is difficult to speak of “standard” or “main” varieties of pasta ripiena, for this study, a selection was made of 28 entries that represented not only the types that have moved out of local spread and into national/international spread (ravioli, tortellini, etc.) but also local specialties such as the Sardinian culurgiones, Mantovan turtèl sguasaròt and others, alongside nine selected outgroups from across Eurasia (Table 1). Some entries were considered despite their close nomenclatural affinity (e.g., cjalzons and cjarsons, both from Friuli Venezia Giulia), primarily to determine if there are any meaningful differences between them. All non-ripiena pasta, including lasagna, gnocchi, open-shelled, layered or rolled pasta, as well as deep-fried pastries such as gnocco fritto, empanada or samosa, were excluded from this study. Dessert varieties of some of these entries, where the filling is often sweet and very different, were also not considered.
2.2 Selection and coding of characters
Using recipes from Artusi’s original 1891 edition of La scienza in cucina e l’arte di mangiar bene (“Science in the kitchen and the art of eating well”) alongside popular cookbooks focused on pasta [6, 13,14,15,16,17] and additional online resources (giallozafferano.it, Pasta Grannies channel on YouTube.com), a dataset for the 37 entries with 15 characters was created, coding for a wide range of characteristics—from their geographical provenance to the ingredients used in making the pasta and the filling, as well as the cooking and serving methods (Table 2). Among the 15 characters, eight were binary (present or absent), and seven were multistate. The provenance of the Italian pasta was divided into four main regions: northern Italy (all of the north to Liguria and Emilia-Romagna), central Italy (Tuscany and Marche to Lazio and Abruzzo), southern Italy (Molise and Campania to Sicily), and Sardinia. Selected characteristics included whether the flour used in making the pasta was primarily soft or durum wheat, and whether the eggs were used in preparation of the dough. Pasta shapes were coded according to the scheme proposed by Schira [6], and pasta size was coded in four categories from small (e.g., tortellini) to very large (e.g., tortelli alla lastra). The flatness or three-dimensional nature of the filled pasta was also considered. The folding of the pasta was classified into nine categories, from simple folded-and-thumb-pressed to wrapped around the finger, rolled, or bundled. Other considerations included whether vegetables or meat constituted the main ingredient of the filling, and whether any dairy products were included. Cooking was coded as boiled, pan-fried, roasted or steamed pasta. It was also taken into account whether the final dish was served primarily in broth or with sauce, if the sauce was meat or nonmeat based, and whether butter or oil was used in serving.
2.3 Phylogenetic analysis
The final data matrix was converted into nexus format in MESQUITE [18]. A heuristic add-and-rearrange method was initially used with the tree search criterion set to treelength, using the Subtree Pruning and Regrafting (SPR) rearranger and a maximum number of equally good trees set to 10000. Bayesian analysis was conducted in MRBAYES 3.2.6 [19], with Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) analysis allowed to run for 50,000,000 generations and repeated multiple times to check for convergence and stationarity. The results were subsequently tested using TRACER 1.7.1 [20]. Trees were edited using FIGTREE 1.4.4 [21]. A Maximum likelihood (ML) tree was further generated with the IQTREE web server (http://iqtree.cibiv.univie.ac.at) [22] with 10000 ultrafast bootstrap replicates. Finally, the regional divisions selected for the provenance of Italian pasta ripiena were incorporated in an analysis to reconstruct the ancestral distributions. The R package BioGeoBEARS [23] was used to compare three possible models of past geographical range estimation based on the Akaike information criterion and, for each of them, also a variant with a founder effect (parameter j): dispersal–extinction–cladogenesis (DEC), dispersal–vicariance analysis (DIVALIKE) and BI for discrete areas (BAYAREALIKE). The program then reflects these likelihoods as pie charts with all possible ranges for each node and their respective probabilities. A maximum of four possible ancestral areas was allowed.
3 Results
3.1 Phylogenic analyses
Our inferred phylogenies using different methodologies demonstrated slightly different topologies (Fig. 1). As expected with variable categorical data, the overall support (bootstrap and Bayesian posterior probabilities) for deeper nodes was weak. Different types of pasta did not always group together based on their shape or provenance, and often appeared in unexpected sister-group relationships. Throughout our analyses, the Sardinian culurgiones had an unstable position, sometimes appearing within the Italian clade as a sister to the other Sardinian entry puligioni and sometimes among the outgroups. The Italian pasta ripiena was monophyletic only according to our Bayesian analysis. Entries with unique autapomorphies, such as tortelli alla lastra of Corezzo (a fire-baked pasta) or the turtèl sguasaròt of Mantova (bean-filled pasta served with peanut oil), appeared on long branches within clades with other pasta with whom they shared synapomorphies such as their shape or size.
Throughout our analyses, aside from the outgroups, the Italian pasta appeared in two main groups: a “ravioli clade” and a “tortellini clade” (Fig. 2). The ravioli clade included ravioli, tordelli, schlutzkrapfen, cjarsons, cjalzons, casunziei, ciaroncie, tortél-dóls, and turtel sguasaròt. Even though, in our Maximum Likelihood analysis, this clade was monophyletic, it appeared paraphyletic in our Bayesian analysis (Fig. 1). Two additional entries (cappellacci and zembi d’arzillo) were also part of the ravioli group in our Maximum Likelihood analysis; however, they appeared as part of the tortellini clade in the Bayesian inference. The most important shared characteristic of this group (with the exception of cappellacci) is the “flatness” of their shape. On the other hand, the tortellini clade contained all the remaining Italian pasta ripiena, with the main shared characteristic being their three-dimensional nature. The rolled pasta ripiena entries casoncelli, caramelle and scarpinocc always clustered together.
3.2 Biogeographic analysis
The preferred biogeographical model according to the corrected Akaike information criterion was the dispersal–extinction–cladogenesis model with a founder effect (DEC + j) (Supplementary Information S1). This model predicted a high likelihood of a north-Italian origin for the ancestral Italian pasta ripiena. The Sardinian culurgiones was the only exception since it appeared among the outgroups, signaling a possible secondary origin.
4 Discussion
Contrary to Alexander [12] whose classification was based mainly on pasta shapes, our multivariate analyses showed that with the exception of culurgiones, all the other Italian filled pasta can be classified into two distinct groups: a “ravioli clade” and a “tortellini clade” (Fig. 2). In addition, it was revealed that these varieties had a single origin in northern Italy, with subsequent dispersal to other regions of the country. As indicated previously, most Italian filled pasta recipes are from the northern and central regions. This clustering is probably correlated with the climate specificities of different Italian regions and the associated differences in agricultural products and food sources available. For example, durum wheat – from which dry pasta shapes are produced – does not thrive on the Padania Plain; thus, fresh pasta, often produced with the addition of eggs, is the speciality of Emilia-Romagna [12]. In fact, the addition of eggs to dough is much more common in northern areas, with a few exceptions that also stand out in our phylogenetic analysis. A possible explanation for this high local diversity is the phenomenon of “variation on a common theme”, where each town, region and state strived to have their own signature gastronomy and to claim a type of pasta for their own [12]. Our proposed evolutionary clustering shows that the now well-established distinctive pasta shapes were likely not so strongly differentiated in the past. A hypothetical framework that could explain this local radiation of shapes is a gradual differentiation in both space and time and the subsequent loss of intermediate forms in favor of more “identity-defining” shapes.
This “proximity” hypothesis, however, does not fully explain our results. Because of their unique characteristics, some of the Italian entries (e.g., culurgiones or tortelli alla lastra) often appeared among the outgroups, albeit with weak support. In fact, the latter two entries are the only Italian pasta ripiena prepared without eggs in the dough. Culurgiones in particular shares many other characteristics with Eurasian bundle-shaped dumplings and often appeared among the outgroups in our analyses, suggesting a second, independent origin with respect to the North Italian cluster. Culurgiones are made with durum wheat semolina and are endemic to the island of Sardinia, which is climatically, agriculturally, and historically different from northern and central parts of Italy.
One limitation of this study was that some crucial variables for which no data were available through primary sources (recipes) could not be codified, and thus they were excluded. An example pertains to the way filled pasta are consumed (e.g., the peculiar method of eating khinkhali with a characteristic imbibing of the juices). In addition, taste and other sensory properties could not be considered, i.e., the use of pork vs. cow meat, the exact nature of the seasoning (e.g., Allium-based vs. aromatic plants vs. others), the diverse amount of possible aged cheese varieties used (e.g., pecorino, parmigiano, etc.) or their rate of "umami" contributions. Sensory perception, an important indicator in food products, is largely influenced by shape [24, 25]. In the case of pasta, at the physicochemical level, shape affects the surface area exposed to boiling water, determining the rate of hydration and the degree of gelatinization of the starch during cooking, thus affecting the textural properties and even the digestibility of the cooked pasta [26,27,28,29]. Texture, in turn, influences the oral tactile sensation and sensory perception [30]. Studies have shown that basic taste, such as sweetness, is related not only to the sugar content in a product but also to its hardness or viscosity, influencing the speed of its spread in the oral cavity during the eating process [31]. Furthermore, surface roughness or presence of hollow spaces, as also pertinent to pasta shapes, affects sauce adhesion and retention [32]. Each type of pasta is in fact an artificial geometric element on its own right. The mouth perceives the physical differences between one shape of pasta and another, providing the brain with different information about volume, texture, and smoothness. Hence, pasta with different shapes turn out differently with the same ingredients, and the multitude of existing shapes are by no means interchangeable for Italians because each has its “right” pairing with the sauce.
The shape and size of foods also affect consumer preference, as they can influence the implicit associations individuals make about an object and its value [33]. Shape has not only a pragmatic but also a symbolic and communicative function [34] and is easily recognizable and tied to cultural identity. A stiff dough of semolina or flour, water and possibly eggs is as malleable and versatile as clay and can be shaped as a distinctive and identifying element, historically established as “traditional,” but without excluding the possibility of further evolution and innovation. 3D-printed unconventional pasta shapes, characterized by a high degree of personalization and complexity, have been developed [35] to convey cultural content [32], and the design concept of “morphing” [36], that is, a change in shape under certain conditions, has been recently applied to pasta [37]. Morphing pasta is flat, 2D pasta, that transforms into 3D during cooking due to water hydration and starch gelatinization. Morphing pasta is suitable for flat packaging, reducing shipping costs and storage space. Although not suitable for stuffed pasta, morphing technology is still another example of how many implications the shape of pasta has.
5 Conclusions
To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to provide empirical evidence towards a scientific classification of Italian pasta ripiena. Even though the primary sources used to create the dataset for this study were by nature nonscientific, they are in many ways the most reliable sources due to their historicity and/or popular usage. The addition of other filled pasta and dumpling varieties from across Italy and Eurasia and the inclusion of other informative characters that can add further resolution to the phylogenetic inference are the next steps in this research. Evaluation of elements such as taste and methods of consumption would require surveys and experimental design and can perhaps be considered in a subsequent, more inclusive study on all Eurasian pasta ripiena.
Data availability
All the data used in this study are provided in their entirety within the paper or as supplementary materials.
References
Nazari V, Belardinelli S, Pieroni A, Motti R, Chiarucci A, Destro Bisol G, Vacchiano G, Bortolini E, Mezzavilla M, Garaffa L, Pievani D. Biocultural diversity in Italy. Huma Ecol. 2023;51:1263–75. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10745-023-00455-4.
Marchetti S. The history of the dumpling: from ravioli to wonton to gyoza, why they all belong to the same food family. South China morning post 2021. sc.mp/e16m. 7 April 2024.
Zhang Q. Spread of Chinese food culture along the southern silk road in the pre-Qin period, Han, and Jin dynasties. Senri Ethnol Stud. 2019;100:83–97. https://doi.org/10.15021/00009388.
Gong Y, Yang Y, Ferguson DK, Tao D, Li W, Wang C, Lü E, Jiang H. Investigation of ancient noodles, cakes, and millet at the Subeixi site, Xinjiang China. J Archaeol Sci. 2011. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2010.10.006.
Buell PD, Anderson EN, de Pablo MM, Oskenbay M. Crossroads of cuisine: the Eurasian heartland, the silk roads and food. Brill: Leiden; 2020.
Schira R. Il libro della pasta Fresca e ripiena. Edizione digitale. Milano: Ponte Alle Grazie; 2015.
Faccioli E. L’arte della cucina in Italia. Giulio Einaudi editore. XXX+878 pp. 1997.
Platina BS. De honesta voluptate et valetudine. Bernardinus de vitalibus: Venedig; 1467
Anonymous. La cucinera piemontese. Vercelli; 134 pp. 1771.
Cesari L. A brief history of pasta: the Italian food that shaped the world. London: Profile books; 2022.
Artusi P. La scienza in cucina e l’arte di mangiar bene: manuale pratico per le famiglie. Firenze; 392 pp. 1891.
Alexander D. The geography of Italian pasta. Prof Geogr. 2000;52(3):553–66. https://doi.org/10.1111/0033-0124.00246.
Zanini De Vita O. Atlante dei prodotti tipici: la pasta. AGRA; 522 pp. 2004.
Puzzi A. Pasta. Le forme del grano. Slow food editore; 336 pp. 2017.
Colleo L. Pasta fresca e ripiena. Bologna: Script edizioni; 2011.
Yarvin B. A world of dumplings: filled dumplings, pockets, and little pies from around the globe. Woodstock: Countryman Press; 2017.
Stephenson M. The lost ravioli cookbook: ravioli recipes for the family. Home cooking, kindle edition; 349 pp. 2018.
Maddison WP, Maddison DR. Mesquite: a modular system for evolutionary analysis. Version 2.72. 2018. https://mesquiteproject.org/. Accessed Apr 2024.
Ronquist F, Teslenko M, van der Mark P, Ayres D, Darling A, Höhna S, Larget B, Liu l, Suchard MA, Huelsenbeck JP. MrBayes 3.2: efficient bayesian phylogenetic inference and model choice across a large model space. Syst Biol. 2012;61:539–42. https://doi.org/10.1093/sysbio/sys029.
Rambaut A, Drummond AJ, Xie D, Baele G, Suchard MA. Posterior summarization in bayesian phylogenetics using Tracer 1.7. Syst Biol. 2018;67:901–4. https://doi.org/10.1093/sysbio/syy032.
Rambaut A. Figtree. Version 1. 4.4. Computer program and documentation distributed by the author. 2018. http://github.com/rambaut/figtree. Accessed Apr 2024.
Trifinopoulos J, Nguyen lT, von Haeseler A, Minh BQ. w-IQ-TrEE: a fast online phylogenetic tool for maximum likelihood analysis. Nucl Acid Res. 2016;44(w1):w232–5. https://doi.org/10.1093/nar/gkw256.
Matzke N. Probabilistic historical biogeography: new models for founder-event speciation, imperfect detection, and fossils allow improved accuracy and model-testing. Front Biogeogr. 2013;5:242–8. https://doi.org/10.21425/F5FBG19694.
Wang QJ, Carvalho FR, Persoone D, Spence C. Assessing the effect of shape on the evaluation of expected and actual chocolate flavour. Flavour. 2017;6:1–6. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13411-017-0052-1.
Costantini M, Sabovics M, Galoburda R, Kince T, Straumite E, Summo C, Pasqualone A. Effect of die configuration on the physico-chemical properties, anti-nutritional compounds, and sensory features of legume-based extruded snacks. Foods. 2021;10:3015. https://doi.org/10.3390/foods10123015.
Carini E, Vittadini E, Curti E, Antoniazzi F. Effects of different shaping modes on physico-chemical properties and water status of fresh pasta. J Food Eng. 2009;93(4):400–6. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfoodeng.2009.02.002.
Shreenithee CR, Prabhasankar P. Effect of different shapes on the quality, microstructure, sensory and nutritional characteristics of yellow pea flour incorporated pasta. J Food Meas Charact. 2013;7:166–76. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11694-013-9152-5.
Suo X, Mosca AC, Pellegrini N, Vittadini E. Effect of pasta shape and gluten on pasta cooking quality and structural breakdown during mastication. Food Funct. 2021;12(22):11577–85. https://doi.org/10.1039/D1FO02339J.
Suo X, Dall’Asta M, Giuberti G, Minucciani M, Wang Z, Vittadini E. Effect of “shape” on technological properties and nutritional quality of chickpea-corn-rice gluten free pasta. LWT. 2024;192:115661. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.lwt.2023.115661.
Chen J. Food oral processing: some important underpinning principles of eating and sensory perception. Food Struct. 2014;1(2):91–105. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foostr.2014.03.001.
Hoppert K, Zahn S, Puschmann A, Ullmann I, Rohm H. Quantification of sensory difference thresholds for fat and sweetness in dairy-based emulsions. Food Qual Prefer. 2012;26:52–7. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodqual.2012.03.008.
Chung MJ, Lee SH, Kim HW, Chung MS, Park HJ. Investigating the effect of lattice design on sauce adhesion in 3D printed durum wheat pasta. Food Biosci. 2024;59: 103858. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fbio.2024.103858.
Li S, Zeng Y, Zhou S. The congruence effect of food shape and name typeface on consumers’ food preferences. Food Qual Prefer. 2020;86: 104017. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodqual.2020.104017.
Staniszewska E. Design as a means of conveying postmodern myths and narrations. J Art Humanit. 2015;4(11):19–29. https://doi.org/10.18533/journal.v4i11.736.
Tan C, Toh WY, Wong G, Li L. Extrusion-based 3D food printing–materials and machines. Int J Bioprinting. 2018. https://doi.org/10.18063/IJB.v4i2.143.
Choma J. Morphing: a guide to mathematical transformations for architects and designers. London: Hachette; 2015.
Tao Y, Lee YC, Liu H, Zhang X, Cui J, Mondoa C, Babaei M, Santillan J, Wang G, Luo D, Liu D. Morphing pasta and beyond. Sci Adv. 2021. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.abf409.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank Andrea Chiesi (Parma, Italy) for inspiring this research, Soojin Yang (Bra [CN], Italy) for original drawings used in this study, and Massimo Montanari (Bologna, Italy) for his comments on an early draft of the manuscript.
Funding
Open access funding for this study was provided by Università degli Studi di Padova.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
V.N. created the dataset, performed the phylogenetic analyses and wrote the manuscript. A.Pa. revised the manuscript and wrote part of the discussion. A.Pi. provided intellectual input and revised the manuscript. V.T. performed biogeographic analysis. S.B. and T.P. provided analytical perspective, wrote part of the discussion and revised the manuscript. All authors have read, reviewed, and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Not applicable.
Consent for publication
All the authors have approved the manuscript for submission.
Competing interests
The authors have no relevant financial or nonfinancial interests to disclose.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary Information
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Nazari, V., Pasqualone, A., Pieroni, A. et al. Evolution of the Italian pasta ripiena: the first steps toward a scientific classification. Discov Food 4, 57 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1007/s44187-024-00136-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s44187-024-00136-1