Abstract
Rupture fronts can cause fault displacement, reaching speeds up to several ms−1 within a few milliseconds, at any distance away from the earthquake nucleation area. In the case of silicate-bearing rocks the abrupt slip acceleration results in melting at asperity contacts causing a large reduction in fault frictional strength (i.e., flash weakening). Flash weakening is also observed in experiments performed in carbonate-bearing rocks but evidence for melting is lacking. To unravel the micro-physical mechanisms associated with flash weakening in carbonates, experiments were conducted on pre-cut Carrara marble cylinders using a rotary shear apparatus at conditions relevant to earthquakes propagation. In the first 5 mm of slip the shear stress was reduced up to 30% and CO2 was released. Focused ion beam, scanning and transmission electron microscopy investigations of the slipping zones reveal the presence of calcite nanograins and amorphous carbon. We interpret the CO2 release, the formation of nanograins and amorphous carbon to be the result of a shock-like stress release associated with the migration of fast-moving dislocations. Amorphous carbon, given its low friction coefficient, is responsible for flash weakening and promotes the propagation of the seismic rupture in carbonate-bearing fault patches.
Similar content being viewed by others
Introduction
During an earthquake, at any distance away from the nucleation area, the passage of the rupture front results in fault slip reaching speeds up to several ms−1 within a few milliseconds1. The seismic rupture propagates because the fault strength decreases with increasing slip and slip rate upon the activation of a weakening mechanism. So far, frictional heating and thermal pressurization have been suggested as possible weakening mechanisms occurring at the initiation of slip in the case of both natural and experimental faults2,3. In natural silicate-bearing rocks pseudotachylites (solidified friction-induced melts) record frictional heating4 occurred during seismic slip events. Theoretical and experimental investigations5,6,7,8 have suggested that such frictional heat initiates at a few highly stressed microscopic asperities (flash heating), where abrupt temperature increase results in instantaneous melting (flash melting) at the asperity contact. The microscopic melt droplets produced at the initial stage of slip lubricate the fault and cause a reduction in frictional strength9. With progressive slip, the entire fault surface is covered by a continuous melt layer resulting in frictional melt lubrication4,10,11,12.
Faults cutting carbonate-bearing rocks produce moderate to large earthquakes (e.g., L’Aquila 2009 Mw 6.1 ref. 13, Wenchuan 2008 Mw 7.9 ref. 14). Moreover experiments performed on carbonates-bearing rocks approaching seismic deformation conditions15,16,17,18,19 report a 95% decrease of the initial experimental fault strength. Despite these evidences for fault weakening in the case of carbonate-bearing rocks, melt-related products were not observed and other processes were proposed to explain seismic rupture propagation.
Evidence for thermal decomposition15,16,17 (i.e., decarbonation vesicles) suggests that frictional heating occurs to activate thermochemical pressurization of fluids (CO2) leading to frictional strength reduction15,16. With progressive slip the transition to frictional weakening can be explained by nanoparticle and powder lubrication18,19,20,21, grain boundary sliding, nanometric flow and phase transformations22,23,24 or dynamic recrystallization25,26,27. All these proposed mechanisms rely on the presence of nanograins, crystal-plastic microstructures and mirror-like surfaces observed both in experimental and natural faults26,27,28. However, none of the aforementioned mechanisms are able to explain the processes operating at the micro-scale that produce the initial conditions for frictional heating, grain-size reduction and phase transformations, which are necessary to trigger fault weakening. In order to study the processes operating at the initiation of slip we sheared pre-cut samples of a 99% calcite Carrara marble to simulate the behaviour of a fault at conditions relevant for earthquake propagation. The experiments replicate the effect of an abrupt acceleration to seismic slip rates, which occurs when a part of the fault is subjected to a strong modification of the stress field (due to the rupture propagating from neighbouring points). The large surface frictional power density (1–100 MWm−2) dissipated into a low thermal diffusivity (~10×6 m2s−1) and a narrow (<cm) slipping zone resulted in intense rock fragmentation and in an abrupt temperature increase.
Dislocations as well as microcracks and grain boundaries have been previously studied in association with seismic activity during earthquakes29,30 and are responsible of reduced rock strength well below the theoretical strength of crystalline materials31. Dislocations moving at strain rates as fast as earthquake deformation rates may have an unpredictable effect on the frictional strength reduction as depicted by theoretical models for shock impacts and high speed friction32. When dislocations move at high speed the thermal softening associated with plastic deformation is hindered and brittle failure may occur33. Here we suggest that fast-moving dislocations within carbonate-bearing rocks cause the abrupt temperature increase, rock nano-fragmentation and the formations of patches of amorphous carbon that, in analogy with flash melting in the case of silicate-bearing rocks, trigger fault weakening at the initiation of seismic slip.
Methods
Ten experiments (Table 1) were performed with SHIVA34 (Slow to High Velocity Apparatus, installed at INGV Rome) on 50/30 mm outer/inner diameter Carrara marble cylinders (grain size ~300 μm, >99% calcite, without amorphous carbon or graphite: for description of sample preparation see Nielsen et al.35). Mechanical data (axial load, torque, axial displacement, angular rotation) were acquired at a frequency of 25 kHz and given in terms of equivalent slip δ, slip-rate V and shear stress τ determined on the annular sample36. Experiments consisted of the following steps: (1) application of normal stress σn = 10 MPa, (2) slip acceleration of 8.5 ms−2 to the target velocity Vtar and (3) slip deceleration to halt the sample at a specific slip distance, with the exception of experiments s257 and s301, where the final slip was manually attained. Experiment s915-0 was loaded to 10 MPa but not sheared to investigate the effects of sample grinding and polishing plus the application of normal stress on the sliding surface. Samples were recovered after the experiment, coated with a Cr-nanolayer and examined within a field-emission scanning electron microscope (FE-SEM; JEOL JSM-6500F, INGV, Rome) equipped with an energy-dispersive X-ray spectrometer(EDS). Selected areas of the samples s915-0, s915-1 and s761 (arrested at slip of 0, 1.5 mm and 5 mm, respectively) were coated with a Pt-nanolayer and analysed in a focused ion beam SEM (FIB-SEM, FEI Nova 600 Nano Lab, Utrecht University). FIB-SEM nano-manipulations were carried out either to obtain (1) cross-sections parallel and perpendicular to the shear direction or (2) ultra-thin, electron-transparent foils for transmission electron microscopy (TEM, FEI Tecnai 20F and FEI Tecnai 12, Utrecht University) investigations (Supplementary Fig. S1 online). The scanning mode of the Tecnai 20F TEM was used to generate high-angle annular dark-field scanning TEM (HAADF- STEM) images. Gas emissions were measured with a Pfeiffer Quadstarquadrupole mass spectrometer. To detect gas (e.g.,CO2) variations with respect to the atmospheric content and to avoid gas dispersions, we performed a specific experiment (s1187), in which we imposed a succession of slip pulses (three of 1.5 mm and one of 50 mm of slip, respectively) on the rock sample inserted in a vessel17. In experiment s1187, between each slip pulse, we opened the vessel to polish the surfaces and restore atmospheric conditions.
Results
We measured the shear stress (τ) at constant normal stress (σn) which approximates the frictional fault strength during slip (Fig. 1). In all experiments τ first increased almost linearly to a peak value τp = 7.17 ± 1.0 MPa during the acceleration stage. A velocity threshold (V* = 0.12 ± 0.05 ms−1) for weakening was observed in all experiments after which shear stress reduction initiated in combination with macroscopic slip. A minimum shear stress value achieved at macroscopic slip was τmin ~ 0.51 MPa after a total slip of 20 m. During the deceleration stage, the shear stress recovered from τminto a final value τf whose magnitude increased with slip. CO2 concentration increased by 4% after 1.5 mm, 33% after 5 mm and 130% after 50 mm of slip compared to the background CO2 value of ~350 ppm. In experiment s1187, performed by shearing the rock samples inside an insulating vessel, the concentration of H2 (mass 2) and CO2 (mass 44) relative to the atmospheric level increased after each individual 1.5 mm slip pulse. A significant increase in CxHy fragments (mass 15) was detected after the final 50 mm slip pulse (Fig. 2, given in terms of ion current). No significant variations in O2 (mass 32) were observed during the experiment. Calibration tests performed inside the vessel by replacing the rock samples with stainless steel cylinders confirmed that the detected gases resulted from the shearing of the Carrara marble. SEM imaging of the pre-sheared samples and sample surface sheared to 1.5 mm and 5 mm reveals a number of flattened micro-patches increasing in continuity and size with increasing slip (Supplementary Fig. S2 online). For δtot > 1.5 mm the sliding surface is smooth in agreement with observations from previously investigated carbonate sliding surfaces25,26,27.
The micro-patches of the pre-sheared rock surfaces (s915-0, δtot = 0.0 mm, Fig. 3a, Supplementary Fig. S3 online) present a flat-faced texture characterized by exposed cleavages, exfoliated fragments and extensive cracks parallel to the surface. TEM investigations of cross-sections excavated perpendicular to the flattened micro-patch reveal a 200 nm thick calcite nanograin layer (grain size: 40–100 nm) covering a deformation zone characterized by bands of interleaving, elongated calcite grains (Fig. 3d). However, the pre-sheared rock surface is dominated by the exposure of nanograin-free, calcite crystal surfaces implying that the incoherent grain micro-patches result from diamond tool rock polishing and application of normal stress (Supplementary Fig. S3 online).
In contrast with the pre-sheared rock surfaces, no exfoliation and surface cracking is observed on the sheared surface of the experiment stopped at δtot = 1.5 mm (s915-1, cf. Fig. 3a with b), where the deformation zone is 10–20 μm thick and shows a gradual increase in the degree of crystallinity away from the surface into the bulk rock material (Fig. 3e). We identified three domains between the sliding surface and the pristine calcite grains (dashed lines in Fig. 3e). Domain 1 consists exclusively of nanograins with a grain size of 5–100 nm (Fig. 4a,b; Supplementary Fig. S4 online). Domain 2 exhibits grains that are characterized by microfractures and closely spaced (~200 nm apart) cleavage bending planes (dashed lines in Fig. 4a). In domain 2 calcite areas in between cleavage planes exhibit intense mosaicism (Fig. 4c) alternating between areas that are nearly dislocation free to those that exhibit a high dislocation density (dashed region and domains indicated by yellow arrow heads in Fig. 4c and high diffraction contrast, HDC, in Fig. 4d). Although the HDC areas are crystallographic coherent with the surrounding crystal domains the ring-shaped nature of the selected area electron diffraction (SAED) patterns implies that these areas are polycrystalline, i.e. formed by individual nanograins (inset in Fig. 4c). In addition, nanograin formation is associated with intense micro- and nano-cracking (Fig. 5) and cleavage plane parting (dashed lines, Fig. 4a). This is in agreement with previous natural carbonate fault rock observations26. Domain 3 consists of subparallel cleavage planes spaced 2–3 μm apart from and merging into the pristine calcite grains (Fig. 3e) and is free of nanograins.
The sheared surface of the experiment stopped at δtot = 5 mm (s761, Fig. 3c) is characterised by a large number of smooth sliding surfaces (Supplementary Fig. S2 online) and presents features similar to those of the experiment stopped after δtot = 1.5 mm (c.f. Fig. 3b,c). However, flat slip micro-patches are covered by an amorphous carbon (a–C) nanofilm (Fig. 3f and HAADF-STEM image in Fig. 4e). Amorphous-C was identified by EDS and SAED analysis (red curve in Fig. 4g) on a selected area of the sheared zone (indicated with a red star in Fig. 4f). The EDS shows the disappearance of peaks corresponding to Ca (black curve in Fig. 4g), which are detected in a region about 500 nm below the sheared surface (black star in Fig. 4f). Calcite nanograins make up a discrete layer beneath the slip surface and are interspersed with and rimmed by a-C nanofilms (Fig. 4f).
Discussion
Microstructures and reaction products summarized in Figs 3 and 4 show evidence for a strong structural disorder: (1) internal grain fragmentation and dramatic grain size reduction (mosaicism, cleavage bending) without major changes in calcite habit (Fig. 4a,c), as well as (2) CO2 emission and a-C formation (Figs 2 and 4e,f). CO2 emission triggered by a decarbonation reaction suggests the achievement of local temperatures (T) in excess of 650 °C ref. 37 after 1.5 mm of slip. In addition the a–C formation likely results from CO2 decomposition (CO2(g) → C(s) + O2(g)) under either highly compressed (several GPa), anoxic conditions38 or by thermochemical vapour deposition of C in the presence of H2 ref. 39. In our experiments the anoxic conditions are attained by separating the (back) reaction products if O2 escapes faster than the time needed for oxidation to occur40, suggesting that the mechanism leading to a–C deposition is short-lived (<ms). Alternatively, the reaction leading to carbon deposition is either CH4(g) = C(s) + 2H2(g), where CH4 forms by the hydrogenation of calcite (CaCO3(s) + 4 H2(g) → CaO(s) + CH4(g) + 2H2O (g)), or from the reduction of CO2 by CO2(g) + 2H2(g) → C(s) + 2H2O(g) at T > 580 °C. H2 in both cases results from the electrolysis of the acidified surface-adsorbed H2O (room-humidity). Given that the slow kinetics of the electrolyses, the short duration of the process can occur, in the absence of a catalysts, only under an enhanced chemical reactivity. The detection of molecular fragments of hydrocarbons (CxHy, Fig. 2) seems to support a mechanism of thermochemical vapour deposition. Hydrocarbons might have formed also from the reaction of CO and H2 where CO-rich gases proceeds through the intermediate step CO2 → CO + 1/2O2. In this case carbon forms spontaneously by the disproportionation of CO according to 2CO(s) → C(s) + CO2(g). This reaction is highly exothermic and characterized by high activation energy. As a consequence the a–C formation can occur only on chemically active new surfaces by non-equilibrium process like CO adsorption41. Since we can only investigate post-deformation microstructures and measure gas emission relatively far from the shear zone the mechanism of a–C formation remains puzzling. However, all observations are indicative of an abrupt and local temperature rise (the CO2 emission and the presence of a–C material are consistent with T > 600 °C) possibly concomitant with stress transients of few GPa and a high chemical reactivity.
An upper estimate of the bulk temperature increase in the slipping zone, due to the frictional heat exchanged along a sliding interface, can be obtained by42:
where κ is the calcite thermal diffusivity (2.4 10−6m2s−1), ρ is the calcite density (2711 kg m−3), Cp the calcite heat capacity (852 J kg−1 K−1). Conversely to the high temperature rise predicted from the microstructural and geochemical observations, the solution of Eq. (1) results in a bulk temperature increase of ~100 °C after 5 mm of slip (Fig. 6). This estimate is consistent with measurements obtained with an infrared thermo-camera in experiments performed on limestone under similar deformation conditions21. It has been proposed that grain size reduction to the nanoscale reduces the melting (and decarbonation) point temperature in ceramic materials43. The ratio (K) between the grain size and the atomic bond length controls the depression of the melting point: for K > 20, the melting point depression is negligible. The nanograins (Fig. 4b) produced in our experiments are ~10 nm in radius and considering a bond length in calcite to be ~0.13 nm yields a K-value of ~77. Thus, the expected melting (i.e., decarbonation for calcite) temperature depression in our experiments is of a few tens of °C at most. Moreover, nanograins may resulted from abrasion and wearing but the mechanics of abrasion and wearing is the same as the mechanics of grain fracturing44. Fracture theory predicts a limit to grain size reduction down to 1 μm in compression45. Smaller grain size can be achieved by sub-critical crack growth (low strain rates) and shock loading (high strain rates)46. However the slowness of the process of sub-critical crack growth (1 s to split a 1μm in size grain under a typical crack velocity of 10−6 ms−1 in wet calcite47) compared to the short duration of the experiments (≪1 s) suggests that nanograins formed at conditions approaching those of a shock loading. This consideration is also in agreement with our observation that failure have initiated at many closely spaced points within a small volume where multiple fracture have grown simultaneously (Fig. 5). Energetic considerations on rock fragmentation mechanics predicts that the short and closely spaced fractures should have occurred in a cohesive rock under an instantaneous and local stress of the order of GPa and strain rates in excess of 105 s−1 ref. 28.
A way to reconcile the above mineralogical and geochemical considerations (e.g. CO2 emission, a–C formation) with (1) nanograin formation, (2) abrupt temperature rise, (3) shear stress reduction at slip initiation and (4) the presence of a threshold in slip velocity to trigger frictional weakening, is to consider the microstructural processes operating at the initiation of slip. These microstructural processes have to provide the energy necessary for both frictional heating causing phase transformations (e.g. a–C) and brittle nanofracturing. Our microstructural, mineralogical and geochemical observations are all indicative of a high structural disorder that has occurred during a short time period within an extremely narrow zone. In particular, the internal fragmentation of calcite by fracturing (Fig. 5) and the high dislocation density as expressed by the mosaics structures (Fig. 4c,d) indicate that slip initiation is controlled by defect-related mechanisms, i.e. dislocation mobility. Indeed, the strength of the material and its plastic flow depends on how easily dislocations are created and destroyed and what energy threshold is required to move them. At high strain rates, stress relaxation occurring by the collective motion of discrete newly formed or pre-existent dislocations may be inhibited, changing the ductile failure behaviour typical of low strain rates into a brittle failure under highly dynamic conditions33. Moreover, at high strain rates, given the low thermal diffusivity of calcite, the kinetic energy of fast moving dislocations within a narrow shear band is (adiabatically) dissipated into heat. The exchange of kinetic energy into heat is thus accompanied by (1) an abrupt temperature increase, (2) the generation of new defects, (3) chemical disorder in the crystal structure and (4) brittle fracturing. Although it is challenging to monitor dislocation motion in-situ during deformation at high strain rates, the predictions of the fast-moving dislocations theory48,49 are in agreement with our microstructural and geochemical observations (e.g. nanofracturing, thermal decomposition and amorphization). Moreover, the fast moving dislocation theory necessarily introduces a critical strain rate at which the mechanism of thermal softening is hindered leading to brittle failure. The critical strain rate, as discussed later, may be related to the direct experimental observation of a critical velocity for the initiation of fault weakening.
The microstructural observations summarized by Figs 3 and 4 and the reaction products are analogous to those attributed to shock-induced metamorphism in calcite50 suggesting that similar processes may occur within a seismically active shear zone. Numerical models proposed for shock loading and meteoritic impacts32,51 are based on the theory of fast-moving dislocations and a similar approach was theorized in the framework of high speed friction experiments32.
The mechanics of fast moving dislocations and the way dislocations trigger flash heating and weakening in carbonate-bearing faults, can be summarized in three stages (Fig. 6).
Birth of dislocations
The sharp change in strain-rate due to an increase in velocity results in a sudden change in the state of stress at grain boundaries or pre-existing defects and the nucleation of new dislocations. Most of the strain is accommodated by slip along cleavage planes and newly-formed dislocations migrating through the crystal structure until reaching microstructural obstacles (e.g., cleavage planes, micro-cracks, twins and grain boundaries), producing intragranular micro-fractures along crystallographically controlled weaknesses52,53.
Pile up of dislocations
Dislocations emitted from the same source will pile up at the microstructural obstacle, increasing the dislocation density. The stress at the head of the pile up will subsequently increase until it reaches the yielding point (σy) given by the Hall-Petch relationship (σy = σi + kHPd−1/2), where σi is the flow stress related to the density of dislocations accumulated in dislocation boundaries, d is the grain size and kHP is a constant derived empirically for each material which is also known as the Hall - Petch parameter54.
Dislocation avalanches
Piled up dislocations are instantaneously unpinned at the critical stress of the strongest microstructural obstacle, resulting in catastrophic dislocation avalanches55. The kinetic energy of fast-moving dislocations is converted into heat through the viscous damping by electrons and phonons in the crystal structure48,49. The avalanches will result in an ultrafast conversion of the kinetic energy from dislocations into heat and will induce the formation of “dislocation hot-spots” (i.e., the emission of newly formed, locally sourced dislocations) and fast stress release56. The temperature increase (ΔT) inside the crystal, when the piled up dislocations are abruptly released, can be estimated by55:
where is the Hall-Petch microstructural shear stress intensity for the pile up, λ the thermal conductivity, l the average grain size of calcite, a = 2(1 − v)(2 − v) with v being the Poisson’s ratio, vdis the average velocity of dislocations inside the grain, G the shear modulus, b the Burgers vector and the dislocation spacing at the tip of the pile up. If the micro-cracks are formed by dislocation pile ups at grain boundaries, the number of micro-cracks should be proportional to the dislocation density ρdis ref. 57 which, following the Orowan’s relation, leads to a strain rate of:
where ρdiscorresponds to a fraction p, ranging between [0–1], of the entire population of dislocations, which is moving at vdis. Given the slipping zone thickness h = [0.5–10] μm (domains 1 and 2 in Fig. 3e,f) and V* ~0.1 ms−1 (Table 1) the average strain rate across the slipping zone when large frictional weakening occurs is V/h ~ 104 s−1. For Carrara marble and shocked calcite (ρdis = [1012–1014 ] m−2 ref. 58, l = 0.3 mm, λ = 5.54 (Ns−1K−1), a = 2.38, G = 35 GPa ref. 59, b = 0.49 nm ref. 58 and at cracking55) the temperature increase calculated from Eq. (2) for a calcite crystal after 1.5 mm of slip is up to 104 K, i.e. orders of magnitude higher than the bulk temperature increase estimated in the slipping zone from Eq. (1) (Fig. 6).
Similarly, it is possible to estimate the critical strain rate above which thermal instability of a crystal occurs. The critical strain rate is related to dislocation mobility which is in turn affected by the resistance to dislocations motion including phonon scattering, impurity drag and lattice periodicity (e.g. the Peierls potential). The resistances can be lowered by an amount of energy ΔG given by thermal fluctuations; thus the rate at which the dislocations pass the energetic barrier (aided by the energy contribution ΔG) increases with temperature and the dislocation mobility will be enhanced. However, as the strain rate increases, there is less time available for the dislocations to overcome the energetic barrier until, above a critical strain rate , thermal activation is rendered ineffective48,49:
where fd is the vibrational frequency of the dislocations (~1011s−1) ref. 60. Using Eq. (4), ~ 103–105 s−1 in the case of calcite and, given a homogeneously distributed strain in a slipping zone of thickness h = [0.5–10] μm, V* is approximatively in a range of [0.05–1] ms−1. The lower estimate of V* is compatible with the V* measured in our experiments (~0.10 ms−1).
Although the conceptual framework of fast-moving dislocations for calcite is still incomplete, the existence of a critical strain rate may also justify the initial sliding at high shear stress where thermal softening, occurring by thermal activation, relaxes the stress singularity at the crack tip by viscous flow61. However, for the mechanism of stress relaxation is inhibited and the ductile behaviour of calcite, typical at low strain rates near the crack tip, turns into a brittle behavior33. As a consequence, calcite is more prone to release stress by fracturing at high sliding velocities. The fast stress release separates highly compressed from uncompressed domains within the calcite grains and induces grain fragmentation and mosaicism (Figs 4a–d and 5). The ultimate fragment size is determined by the minimum grain size that can sustain dislocation pile up62, corresponding to a few nanometers in our experimental conditions. The high rate of dislocations production results in grain size reduction and in an increase in specific surface area enhancing chemical reactivity63. The latter might allow the thermochemical vapour deposition of amorphous carbon in the presence of H2 and the observed shorter slip weakening distance in the presence of liquid H2O (Fig. 4 in Violay et al.9). The brittle failure induced by the fast moving dislocations could also explain nanograin formation in both natural25,26,27,28 and experimental fault zones16,18,19,20,21,23,24,25. Nanograins formed under mechanical treatment are composed of nano-crystals separated by interfaces or amorphous layers63. Once slip ceases, the temperature rapidly decreases and the chemical reactivity is strongly reduced. Surface reconstruction and chemical reactions with the environment result in the layered microstructures of the slip surface (Fig. 4f).
Once generated, fast-moving dislocations act as a viscous component of the rheology of calcite grains with two major consequences for the shear stress dependence with strain rate. Firstly, the theory of fast-moving dislocations predicts a strain rate threshold V* to trigger a dislocation avalanche, which results from the competition between thermal relaxation and the thermal excitation of dislocation motion. V* in the present experiments was ~0.10 m s−1, which is compatible with previous studies8,9,21 and estimates from Eq. (4). The high strain rates associated with seismic deformation conditions might be responsible for the thermal activation of flash heating. Secondly as thermal excitation increases with temperature, a positive feedback is established between the temperature rise due to dislocation kinetics damping and the viscous dissipation itself which sustains fast dislocation motion during slip initiation.
The transition from slip initiation to frictional strength reduction and fault weakening (δ > 5 mm, Fig. 6c) is triggered by fast moving dislocations and may be due to either a grain-size dependent process (e.g. diffusion creep, grain boundary sliding, superplasticity22,23,24) or to the presence of discontinuous fault micro-patches covered by a nano-layer of a–C.
Amorphous-C has been previously indicated as a lubricant for fault weakening64,65 due to its low friction coefficient value (~0.15) ref. 66. This lubrication mechanism developed at the asperity contacts would be equivalent in carbonate-bearing rocks to the formation of asperity scale melt drop patches responsible for abrupt initial weakening in silicate-bearing rocks (flash heating and melting2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9). Given that amorphization is a low temperature type of melting67, the presence of an amorphous phase results in a strong inverse non-linear dependency of viscosity (and, as a consequence, on shear stress) on temperature. This dependence is able to explain the shear stress recovery upon sample deceleration (τf in Table 1).
Recent studies have proposed that grain boundary sliding in nano-grain built slipping zones results in frictional strength reduction for δ > 0.5 m in carbonate-bearing faults23,24. Nanograin formation has been attributed to phase transformations accompanied by CO2 release19 which is in agreement with the observations reported here. Although the discussion on processes activated at large fault slip is beyond the scope of this paper, grain boundary sliding may operate in conjunction with a–C at slip initiation and become the dominant weakening mechanism with progressive slip. According to the above scenario, fast-moving dislocations are the microphysical process responsible for the abrupt temperature rise at the asperity scale which leads to nanograins and a-C formation in carbonate-bearing rocks and possibly to flash melting in silicate-bearing rocks. In this interpretation, fast-moving dislocations are a general microphysical mechanism for flash heating at the initiation of seismic slip.
Additional Information
How to cite this article: Spagnuolo, E. et al. Fast-moving dislocations trigger flash weakening in carbonate-bearing faults during earthquakes. Sci. Rep. 5, 16112; doi: 10.1038/srep16112 (2015).
References
Chang, J. C., Lockner, D. A. & Reches, Z. Rapid acceleration leads to rapid weakening in earthquakes-like laboratory experiments. Science 338, 101–105 (2012).
Rice, J. R. Heating and weakening of faults during earthquake slip. J. Geophys. Res. 111, B05311 (2006).
Di Toro, G. et al. Fault lubrication during earthquakes. Nature 471, 494–498 (2011).
Di Toro, G., Hirose, T., Nielsen, S., Pennacchioni, G. & Shimamoto, T. Natural and experimental evidence of melt lubrication of faults during earthquakes. Science 311, 647–649 (2006).
Rice, J. R. Flash heating at asperity contacts and rate-dependent friction. Eos Trans. AGU 80, 46 (Fall Meet. Suppl.) F681 (1999).
Beeler, N. E., Tullis, T. E. & Goldsby, D. L. Constitutive relationships and physical basis of fault strength due to flash heating. J. Geophys. Res. 113, B01401 (2008).
Rempel, A. W. & Weaver S. L. A model for flash weakening by asperity melting during high-speed earthquake slip. J. Geophys. Res. 113, B11308 (2008).
Goldsby, D. L. & Tullis, T. E. Flash heating leads to low frictional strength of crustal rocks at earthquake slip rates. Science 334, 216–218 (2011).
Violay, M. et al., Effect of water on the frictional behavior of cohesive rocks during earthquakes. Geology 42, 27–30 (2014).
Hirose, T. & Shimamoto, T. Growth of molten zone as a mechanism of slip weakening of simulated faults in gabbro during frictional melting. J. Geophys. Res. 110, B05202 (2005).
Nielsen, S., Di Toro, G. D., Hirose, T. & Shimamoto, T. Frictional melt and seismic slip J. Geophys. Res. 113, B01308 (2008).
Niemeijer, A. R., Di Toro, G., Nielsen, S. & Di Felice, F. Frictional melting of gabbro under extreme experimental conditions of normal stress, acceleration and sliding velocity. J. Geophys. Res. 116, B07404 (2011).
Chiarabba, C. et al. The 2009 L’Aquila (central Italy) Mw 6.3 earthquake: Main shock and aftershocks. Geophys. Res. Lett. 36, L18308 (2009).
Chen, J., Yang, X., Ma, S. & Spiers, J. Mass removal and clay mineral dehydration/rehydration in carbonate-rich surface exposures of the 2008 Wenchuan Earthquake fault: Geochemical evidence and implications for fault zone evolution and coseismic slip. J. Geophys. Res. 118, 474–496 (2013).
Collettini, C., Viti, C., Tesei, T. & Mollo S. Thermal decomposition along natural carbonate faults during earthquakes. Geology 41, 927–930 (2013).
De Paola, N. et al. Fault lubrication and earthquake propagation in thermally unstable rocks. Geology 39, 35–38 (2011).
Violay, M. et al. Pore fluid in experimental calcite-bearing faults: Abrupt weakening and geochemical signature of co-seismic processes. Earth Planet Sc. Lett. 361, 74–84 (2013).
Han, R., Shimamoto, T., Hirose, T., Ree, J.-H. & Ando, J. I. Ultralow friction of carbonate faults caused by thermal decomposition. Science 316, 878–881 (2007).
Han, R., Hirose, T. & Shimamoto T., Strong velocity weakening and powder lubrication of simulated carbonate faults at seismic slip rates. J. Geophys. Res. 115, B03412 (2010).
Reches, Z. & Lockner, D. A. Fault weakening and earthquake instability by powder lubrication. Nature 467, 452–456 (2010).
Tisato, N., Di Toro, G., De Rossi, N., Quaresimin, M. & Candela, T. Experimental investigation of flash weakening in limestone. J. Struct. Geol. 38, 183–199 (2012).
Verberne, B. A., Plümper, O., de Winter, D. A. M. & Spiers C. J. Superplastic nanofibrous slip zones control seismogenic fault friction. Science 346, 1342–1344 (2014).
Green II, H. W., Shi, F., Bozhilov, K., Xia, G. & Reches, Z. Phase transformation and nanometric flow cause extreme weakening during fault slip, Nat. Geos. 8, 484–489 (2015).
De Paola, N., Holdsworth R., Viti, C., Collettini, C. & Bullok, R., Can grain size sensitive flow lubricate faults during the initial stages of earthquake propagation? Earth Planet Sc. Lett. 431, 48–58 (2015).
Smith, S. et al. Coseismic recrystallization during shallow earthquake slip, Geology, 41, 63–66 (2013).
Siman-Tov, S., Aharonov, E., Sagy, A. & Emmanuel, S. Nanograins from carbonate fault mirrors. Geology 41, 703–706 (2013).
Fondriest, M. et al. Mirror-like faults and power dissipation during earthquakes. Geology 41, 1175–1178 (2013).
Reches, Z. & Dewers, T. A. Gouge formation by dynamic pulverization during earthquake rupture. EPSL 235, 361–374 (2005)
Weertman, J. Continuum distribution of dislocations on faults with finite friction. Bull. Seism. Soc. Am. 54, 1035–1058 (1964).
Fisher, D. S. Collective transport in random media: From Superconductors to Earthquakes. Phys. Rep. 301, 113–150 (1998).
Poirier, J.-P. Creep of Crystals: High-Temperature Deformation Processes in Metals, Ceramics and Minerals (Cambridge Univ. Press, 1985).
Holian, B. L., Hammerberg J. E. & Lomdahl, P. S. The birth of dislocations in shock waves and high-speed friction. J. Comput-Aided Mater. 5, 207–224 (1998).
Cleveringa, H., der Giessen, E. V. & Needleman, A. A discrete dislocation analysis of mode I crack growth. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 48, 1133–1157 (2000).
Di Toro, G. et al. From field geology to earthquake simulation: a new state-of-the-art tool to investigate rock friction during the seismic cycle (SHIVA). Rend. Fis. Acc. Lincei 21, S95–S114 (2010).
Nielsen, S., Spagnuolo, E. & Violay, M. The ultimate sample preparation for rotary shear experiments. Rapporti Tecnici INGV 215, 1–16 (2012).
Shimamoto, T. & Tsutsumi, A. A new rotary-shear high-velocity frictional testing machine: Its basic design and scope of research (in Japanese with English abstract). J. Tectonic Res. Group of Japan 39, 65–78 (1994).
Rodriguez-Navarro, C., Ruiz-Agudo, E., Luque, A., Rodriguez-Navarro, A. B. & Ortega-Huertas, M. Thermal decomposition of calcite: Mechanism of formation and textural evolution of CaO nanocrystals. Am. Mineral. 94, 578–593 (2009).
Oganov, A. R. Structure, bonding and mineralogy of carbon at extreme conditions. Reviews in Mineralogy & Geochemestry 75, 47–77 (2013).
Oohashi, K. et al. Carbon-forming reactions under a reducing atmosphere during seismic fault slip. Geology 42, 787–791 (2014).
Kuo, L.-W. et al. Gouge graphitization and dynamic fault weakening during the 2008 Mw 7.9 Wenchuan earthquake. Geology 42, 4570–4573 (2014).
Mathez, E. A., Roberts, J. J., Duba, A. G., Kronenberg, A. K. & Karner S. L. Carbon deposition during brittle rock deformation: Changes in electrical properties of fault zones and potential geoelectric phenomena during earthquakes, J. Geophys. Res. 113, B12201, (2008).
Carlslow, H. & Jaeger, J. Conduction of Heat in Solids. 1–517 (Oxford Univ. Press, 1959).
Sun, C. Q. Size dependence of nanostructures: Impact of bond order deficiency. Prog. Solid State Ch. 35, 1–159 (2007).
Scholz, C. The mechanics of earthquake and faulting (Cambridge Univ. Press. 2002).
Kendall, K. The impossibility of comminuting small particles by compression, Nature 272, 710–711 (1978).
Sammis, C. G. & Ben-Zion, Y. Mechanics of grain-size reduction in fault zones, J. Geophys. Res. 113, B02306 (2008).
Atkinson, B. K. & Meredith, P. The theory of sub-critical crack growth with applications to minerals and rocks. In Fracture Mechanics of Rock (Academic Press Geology Series, 2008, 111–165).
Roos, A., de Hosson, J. T. M. & der Giessen, E. V. High-speed dislocations in high strain-rate deformations. Comp. Mater. Sci. 20, 19–27 (2001).
De Hosson, J. T., Roos, A. & Metselaar, E. D. Temperature rise due to fast-moving dislocations. Philos. Mag. A 81, 1099–1120 (2001).
Langenhorst, F. Shock metamorphism of some minerals: basic introduction and microstructural observations. B. Czech Geol. Surv. 77, 265–282 (2002).
Armstrong, R. W. Dislocation mechanics aspects of energetic material composites. Rev. Adv. Mater. Sci. 19, 13–40 (2009).
Fusseis, F. & Handy, M. Micromechanisms of shear zone propagation at the brittle - viscous transition. J. Struct. Geol. 30, 1242–1253 (2008).
Austin, N. J., Kennedy, L. A., Logan, J. M. & Rodway, R. Textural controls on the brittle deformation of dolomite: the transition from brittle faulting to cataclastic flow. Geol. Soc. London Special Publications 243, 51–66 (2005).
Hansen, N. Hall-Petch relation and boundary strengthening. Scripta Mater. 51, 801–806, (2004).
Armstrong, R. W. & Elban, W. L. Temperature rise at a dislocation pile-up breakthrough. Mater. Sci. Eng. A122, L1–3 (1989).
Armstrong, R. W. Dislocation mechanisms for shock-induced hot spots, J. Phys. IV France, 5, C4-89-C4-102 (1995).
Stroh, A. N. The cleavage of metal single crystals. Philos. Mag. 3, 597–606 (1958).
Barber, D. J., Wenk, H.-R., Gomez-Barreiro, J., Rybacki, E. & Dresen, G. Basal slip and texture development in calcite: new results from torsion experiments. Phys. Chem. Miner. 34, 73–84 (2007).
Crystran Ltd. Available at: http://www.crystran.co.uk. (Accessed January, 2015).
Kocks, U. F., Argon, A. S. & Ashby, M. F. Thermodynamics and kinetics of slip. Prog. Mater. Sci. 19, 1–292 (Pergamon Press, 1974).
Hirsch, P., Roberts, S. & Samuels J. Dislocation mobility and crack tip plasticity at the ductile-brittle transition. Revue Phys. Appl. 23, 409–418 (1988).
Koch, C. C. Synthesis of nanostructured material by mechanical milling: problems and opportunities. Nanostruct. Mater. 9, 13–22 (1997).
Baláˆz, P. et al. Hallmarks of mechanochemistry: from nanoparticles to technology. Chem. Soc. Rev. 42, 7571–7637 (2013).
Oohashi, K., Hirose, T. & Shimamoto, T. Graphite as a lubricating agent in fault zones: An insight from low- to high-velocity friction experiments on a mixed graphite-quartz gouge. J. Geophys. Res. Solid Earth 118, 2067–2084 (2013).
Ma, T.-B., Wang, L.-F., Hu, Y.-Z., Li, X. & Wang, H. A shear localization mechanism for lubricity of amorphous carbon materials. Scientific Reports 4, 36–62 (2014).
Yu, X., Zhang, X., Wang C.-B., Liu, F.-T. & Fu Z.-Q. Structural, mechanical and frictional properties of tetrahedral amorphous carbon film by altered cathodic vacuum arc system. Surf. Coat. Tech. 201, 4995–4998 (2007).
Fecht, H. J. Defect-induced melting and solid-state amorphization. Nature 356, 133–135 (1992).
Acknowledgements
This study was founded by the ERC CoG NOFEAR project 614705 (GDT and ES) and supported through a Veni grant (863.13.006) awarded by the Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research, NWO (OP). We thank Piergiorgio Scarlato for laboratory support, D. A. M. de Winter for technical support; GDT acknowledges Chris Scholz and EinatAharanov for discussions.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
E.S. wrote the paper; E.S., O.P., G.D.T. and M.V. contributed to the final version of the manuscript. E.S., G.D.T. and O.P. concept development; E.S. and M.V. experiments; O.P. and A.C. microstructural analysis; all authors provided input into the interpretation of the microphysical mechanism.
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Electronic supplementary material
Rights and permissions
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in the credit line; if the material is not included under the Creative Commons license, users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to reproduce the material. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
About this article
Cite this article
Spagnuolo, E., Plümper, O., Violay, M. et al. Fast-moving dislocations trigger flash weakening in carbonate-bearing faults during earthquakes. Sci Rep 5, 16112 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1038/srep16112
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/srep16112
- Springer Nature Limited